New York greed

PCB66 · May 7, 2020

The Democrats in New York are now saying that they are going to require that the contract health workers that came in to help out with the virus pay the filthy NY income tax.

My god those Democrats are assholes! That is as greedy as it gets. Despicable!

Good luck ever getting anybody else from out of state to help them out.

I live in Florida. Back in the 1990s I was went to California to work on an Engineering proposal. I worked there for a little over three months.

A couple of months after I got back I received a letter from the filthy ass government in California saying that I owe them income tax for the money I earned while working in the state.

I sent a letter back to them telling them to shove it where the sun don't shine. They can kiss my Cracker ass.

vegas giants · May 7, 2020

PCB66 said:
The Democrats in New York are now saying that they are going to require that the contract health workers that came in to help out with the virus pay the filthy NY income tax.

My god those Democrats are assholes! That is as greedy as it gets. Despicable!

Good luck ever getting anybody else from out of state to help them out.

I live in Florida. Back in the 1990s I was went to California to work on an Engineering proposal. I worked there for a little over three months.

A couple of months after I got back I received a letter from the filthy ass government in California saying that I owe them income tax for the money I earned while working in the state.

I sent a letter back to them telling them to shove it where the sun don't shine. They can kiss my Cracker ass.

Same thing happens if you work in Alabama.

Is it the filthy Democrats???

Drowning Man · May 7, 2020

PCB66 said:
The Democrats in New York are now saying that they are going to require that the contract health workers that came in to help out with the virus pay the filthy NY income tax.

My god those Democrats are assholes! That is as greedy as it gets. Despicable!

Good luck ever getting anybody else from out of state to help them out.

I live in Florida. Back in the 1990s I was went to California to work on an Engineering proposal. I worked there for a little over three months.

A couple of months after I got back I received a letter from the filthy ass government in California saying that I owe them income tax for the money I earned while working in the state.

I sent a letter back to them telling them to shove it where the sun don't shine. They can kiss my Cracker ass.

The real question is where you do you get that there is an exception in the tax laws for health care workers who come to the state to help out with COVID-19?
I'd like you to show me an exception used by Texas, Florida or other Republican states during Hurricanes or other disasters.
Anything?

ttwtt78640 · May 7, 2020

vegas giants said:
Same thing happens if you work in Alabama.

Is it the filthy Democrats???

I'm not so sure about that. For years I worked in DC (at the Washington Navy Yard), lived in MD and was paid by a defense contract company in VA. I paid only MD state income taxes on my salary.

ttwtt78640 · May 7, 2020

Drowning Man said:
The real question is where you do you get that there is an exception in the tax laws for health care workers who come to the state to help out with COVID-19?
I'd like you to show me an exception used by Texas, Florida or other Republican states during Hurricanes or other disasters.
Anything?

I can assure you that Texas does not have a state income tax.

Drowning Man · May 7, 2020

ttwtt78640 said:
I can assure you that Texas does not have a state income tax.

I bet those that helped with disaster recovery in Texas still payed taxes... We're they exempted from paying sales tax while they are there? Greedy Republicans!

ttwtt78640 · May 7, 2020

Drowning Man said:
I bet those that helped with disaster recovery in Texas still payed taxes... We're they exempted from paying sales tax while they are there? Greedy Republicans!

My point is that state income taxes are paid to your state of residency, regardless of where your job site(s) were. You seem to remain clueless that Texas does not have a state income tax.

Drowning Man · May 7, 2020

ttwtt78640 said:
My point is that state income taxes are paid to your state of residency, regardless of where your job site(s) were. You seem to remain clueless that Texas does not have a state income tax.

So they still payed taxes to Texas! Greedy Republicans!

Jezcoe · May 7, 2020

As a resident of NYC... these volunteers should get a waiver.

There is no reason that they shouldn't

Citizen · May 7, 2020

ttwtt78640 said:
I'm not so sure about that. For years I worked in DC (at the Washington Navy Yard), lived in MD and was paid by a defense contract company in VA. I paid only MD state income taxes on my salary.

You pay taxes according to where you live. If they are living in NY for about 3 months, that is where you pay your taxes for 3 months. Have you ever read a tax form

ttwtt78640 · May 7, 2020

Drowning Man said:
So they still payed taxes to Texas! Greedy Republicans!

It is simply not possible that they paid Texas state income taxes. Your "greedy republicants" argument makes no sense.

Drowning Man · May 7, 2020

ttwtt78640 said:
It is simply not possible that they paid Texas state income taxes. Your "greedy republicants" argument makes no sense.

Please point out where I said INCOME taxes. I did specifically talk about SALES taxes.
Greedy Republicans!

ttwtt78640 · May 7, 2020

Citizen said:
You pay taxes according to where you live. If they are living in NY for about 3 months, that is where you pay your taxes for 3 months. Have you ever read a tax form

Hmm... that seems to amount to taxation without representation. I seriously doubt if congress critters pay DC income taxes for the months that they lived and worked there.

ttwtt78640 · May 7, 2020

Drowning Man said:
Please point out where I said INCOME taxes. I did specifically talk about SALES taxes.
Greedy Republicans!

The OP is about state income taxes - if you are talking about sales taxes then that is off topic.

Drawdown · May 7, 2020

Drowning Man said:
The real question is where you do you get that there is an exception in the tax laws for health care workers who come to the state to help out with COVID-19?
I'd like you to show me an exception used by Texas, Florida or other Republican states during Hurricanes or other disasters.
Anything?

Texas has no state income tax period

Drowning Man · May 7, 2020

ttwtt78640 said:
The OP is about state income taxes - if you are talking about sales taxes then that is off topic.

Nice try. Tell me how Democrats are greedy for collecting taxes from people helping out because of a crisis, but Republicans aren't greedy for collecting taxes from people helping out because of a crisis.

Try harder.

Drowning Man · May 7, 2020

Drawdown said:
Texas has no state income tax period

Where did I specifically talk about income taxes?
If the state is collecting money through income taxes, it's greed...but through sales taxes, it's not?

Please have a little bit of intellectual honesty.

Logical1 · May 7, 2020

In the future when NY has some disaster and needs help, people should just say die you greedy scum.

Citizen · May 7, 2020

ttwtt78640 said:
Hmm... that seems to amount to taxation without representation. I seriously doubt if congress critters pay DC income taxes for the months that they lived and worked there.

Maybe not, but if you read a tax form, it asks have you lived in that particular state for the entire year and you must name other states in which you have resided in that year

less right · May 7, 2020

Citizen said:
Maybe not, but if you read a tax form, it asks have you lived in that particular state for the entire year and you must name other states in which you have resided in that year

It seems a lot of posters are unaware of how working out of state and taxes actually work.

I would say that it would have been a nice gesture for New York to give volunteers waivers but that's separate from the ignorance surrounding taxes.

Citizen · May 7, 2020

less right said:
It seems a lot of posters are unaware of how working out of state and taxes actually work.

I would say that it would have been a nice gesture for New York to give volunteers waivers but that's separate from the ignorance surrounding taxes.

Yes, and you must keep in mind that if that health care worker lived in another state for only 9 months, they are only obligated to pay taxes for that state for those nine months

Eriech · May 7, 2020

Why is anyone who is still working during this paying taxes? Everywhere not just NY. Essential workers are funding nonessential workers to stay home currently. Risking their lives daily to provide for those hiding in fear.

It is especially obscene to take money from these health care workers brought in to save NYC and give it to DeBlasio. Hope NYC doesn't need help again.......

Sent from my SM-G892A using Tapatalk

less right · May 7, 2020

Citizen said:
Yes, and you must keep in mind that if that health care worker lived in another state for only 9 months, they are only obligated to pay taxes for that state for those nine months

My understanding is that even professional sports teams have to pay taxes to the state where the games are played unless there is a tax-pact between the home state and state where the game is played.

Moderate Right · May 7, 2020

Citizen said:
Yes, and you must keep in mind that if that health care worker lived in another state for only 9 months, they are only obligated to pay taxes for that state for those nine months

It's also possible that these people may owe a city tax, which I'm guessing that NYC has a local tax of some kind which would be in addition to the state income tax. I actually was born and lived in New York State for 21 years. Loved the scenery but the people and the government drove me away. I moved away and never came back and I'm glad now more than ever.

Jezcoe · May 7, 2020

Moderate Right said:
It's also possible that these people may owe a city tax, which I'm guessing that NYC has a local tax of some kind which would be in addition to the state income tax. I actually was born and lived in New York State for 21 years. Loved the scenery but the people and the government drove me away. I moved away and never came back and I'm glad now more than ever.

NYC does have a city tax.

It should be waived for volunteers.

New York greed

PCB66

Active member

vegas giants

Drowning Man

ttwtt78640

Sometimes wrong

ttwtt78640

Sometimes wrong

Drowning Man

ttwtt78640

Sometimes wrong

Drowning Man

Jezcoe

Citizen

ttwtt78640

Sometimes wrong

Drowning Man

ttwtt78640

Sometimes wrong

ttwtt78640

Sometimes wrong

Drawdown

Drowning Man

Drowning Man

Logical1

Citizen

less right

Citizen

Eriech

less right

Moderate Right

Jezcoe