• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Distributions of wealth in this country

You can't give all the new wealth of a country to just a few golden few. Capitalism dies when the incentive of the possibility to get ahead is taken away. Which it has been the case since 1981. I would like the greatest most powerful richest country in the world, to stay capitalistic and a Republic. Not caring about the fact that the golden few get it all and in no way deserve it all is selling out my country.

The question is not whether there is harmful distribution of wealth. History is just about uniform in a few respects, one of which is that the more disparity and the smaller the top class, the higher the probability of civil unrest (no matter who is right in principle and who is right in how they go about what they do about it).

The question that matters: what can be done that is not more harmful than the disparity, in the short and long term?
 
1. Forgive student loan debt.
2. A new homestead act.
3. Large tax increases on unearned wealth and tax cuts for wages.
4. Government subsidized loans to young families 0 interest and principal forgiveness upon the birth of each additional child.
5. Closed borders until the working age male activity rate is at least 95%.
6. Enactment of tariffs to correct the trade deficit.
7. Enactment of large public works spending instead of indiscriminate welfare to able-bodied men.

This is not comprehensive, but this would be a great start.

Yep, that's radical.
 
Yep, that's radical.

And what would you do differently to fix our current situation of poverty and indebtedness among working families? We need radical changes to fix a racial problem. Family formation is being delayed because of poor economic conditions for young people.

Family+household+formation.GIF
 
I am all for more people getting more wealth, I really am. I do think the rich have too much money. However I do not support taking money from one person to give it to another. If you want to see wealth distributed more evenly then stop giving money to the uber wealthy. The poor and middle class of this country line up in droves to give money freely to those at the top.
The problem has nothing to do with someone taking money from someone else , it's the government tax law and tax rate that funnels all profits to the top. It's a choice and the people who want it all have controlled the right enough to achieve that goal. No the Democrats don't do it unless under extreme need to do so. The right doesn't believe in a progressive tax rate , the democrats do, the right cuts taxes on the wealthy with token tax cuts to others as a coverup , for instance the last tax cut 86% went to the top, everyone else got the other 14%, Reagan Trickle down lie was even worse. Cutting corporate tax cuts goes only into the hands of the wealthy. Democrats have no qualms about making our taxes more progressive or raise the tax on the fat boys at the top, right wing 1% think they deserve it all , Democrats 1% know they have to pay taxes and many of them in fact support raising their taxes . So no it's not the dems it's the hate group they call a party that want it all and think they deserve it all.
 
The question is not whether there is harmful distribution of wealth. History is just about uniform in a few respects, one of which is that the more disparity and the smaller the top class, the higher the probability of civil unrest (no matter who is right in principle and who is right in how they go about what they do about it).

The question that matters: what can be done that is not more harmful than the disparity, in the short and long term?
If your really interested there's tons that can be done, most within the perimeters of tax law. There is one issue that is the main driving law of capitalism, the promise of the potential to get ahead , in fact without which it is no better a economic system then any other. Take the incentive out of capitalism and cap[capitalism dies and in this country , the country dies with it.
 
And liberals know that. They know that immigration and free trade greatly reduce replacement cost for labor, which is a big reason why wages are so much lower today than they were 50 years ago.

05economix-1-blog480.jpg


I don't know how anyone can look at this and be satisfied with the status quo.
Except your wrong, moving corporations off shore keeps down wages more then Illegal immigration and generally in legal immigration also. By the way look at your own chart, what happened in 1981. Reagan was president , it was his first year.
 
And what would you do differently to fix our current situation of poverty and indebtedness among working families? We need radical changes to fix a racial problem. Family formation is being delayed because of poor economic conditions for young people.

Family+household+formation.GIF
actually minimum wage is the start , no American corporation should need me to use my taxes to feed and house a worker that works for them full time. It's stupid they profit and I pay.
 
Ok, and what nazi policies have I endorsed or the party I'm affiliated with implemented in the past 2 years? Please name one.
Nazi's made a hate list, Unions Jews and gypsies , yours is way way longer. Unions ,Muslims, women, gays, our government as it is, immigrants, everyone except old white fat guys, Scum bags promoted hate level and your almost extinct hate group is way further along then Hitler was at three years, Scum bag is way further along with the attack on the press as Hitler was in the same period of time. Scum bag and his grooming of his followers to except lies is way ahead of Hitlers in the same time period. Hitler is a rooky compared to scum bags ability to create a world that is a threat, that doesn't even exist, by the use of non stop endless lies. Scum Bag is better at being Hitler then even Hitler was. you need a history lesson, all dictators work the exact same way you and your ugly leader has and does.
 
Except your wrong, moving corporations off shore keeps down wages more then Illegal immigration and generally in legal immigration also.

They both do. I'm in favor of high tariffs and zero immigration until wages start rising.

By the way look at your own chart, what happened in 1981. Reagan was president , it was his first year.

Amnesty Ron? Yeah, not a fan.
 
actually minimum wage is the start , no American corporation should need me to use my taxes to feed and house a worker that works for them full time. It's stupid they profit and I pay.

I have a lot of sympathy for this position. Corporations ought to be footing the welfare bills for their workers.
 
They both do. I'm in favor of high tariffs and zero immigration until wages start rising.



Amnesty Ron? Yeah, not a fan.
nope the trickle down lie. Increase minimum wage to a living wage , this isn't rocket science. Better that then tax dollars needed to feed their family and keep a roof over their head, why should I have my taxes used to increase the bottom line of any company in this country.
 
Last edited:
Nazi's made a hate list, Unions Jews and gypsies , yours is way way longer. Unions ,Muslims, women, gays, our government as it is, immigrants, everyone except old white fat guys, Scum bags promoted hate level and your almost extinct hate group is way further along then Hitler was at three years, Scum bag is way further along with the attack on the press as Hitler was in the same period of time. Scum bag and his grooming of his followers to except lies is way ahead of Hitlers in the same time period. Hitler is a rooky compared to scum bags ability to create a world that is a threat, that doesn't even exist, by the use of non stop endless lies. Scum Bag is better at being Hitler then even Hitler was. you need a history lesson, all dictators work the exact same way you and your ugly leader has and does.
Boy I missed the main one, the Nazi's made up a threat against their nation to consolidate their power ,just as the right and scum bag are doing.
 
nope the trickle down lie. Increase minimum wage to a living wage , this isn't rocket science. Better that then tax dollars needed to feed their family and keep a roof over their head, why should I have my taxes used to increase the bottom line of any company in this country.

What is a "living wage" in dollars?
 
Nazi's made a hate list, Unions Jews and gypsies , yours is way way longer. Unions ,Muslims, women, gays, our government as it is, immigrants, everyone except old white fat guys, Scum bags promoted hate level and your almost extinct hate group is way further along then Hitler was at three years, Scum bag is way further along with the attack on the press as Hitler was in the same period of time. Scum bag and his grooming of his followers to except lies is way ahead of Hitlers in the same time period. Hitler is a rooky compared to scum bags ability to create a world that is a threat, that doesn't even exist, by the use of non stop endless lies. Scum Bag is better at being Hitler then even Hitler was. you need a history lesson, all dictators work the exact same way you and your ugly leader has and does.

I don't hate anybody. I don't have much of an opinion on unions, I don't care what Muslims do as long as they don't blow up buildings, I don't hate women, I don't hate gays, and I want immigrants to obey our immigration laws.
 
You can't give all the new wealth of a country to just a few golden few. Capitalism dies when the incentive of the possibility to get ahead is taken away. Which it has been the case since 1981. I would like the greatest most powerful richest country in the world, to stay capitalistic and a Republic. Not caring about the fact that the golden few get it all and in no way deserve it all is selling out my country.

Great nations of the past have been destroyed by small numbers of wicked opportunists who parlayed 'rob the rich for the sake of the poor' lying propaganda into successful coups. Those formerly great nations were not transformed into meccas for the poor. In fact, the poor often got poorer and even were butchered by the millions in some cases for not liking the new oppressive leaders.
 
Just watch, historically there is only one party that will change this in the right direction. Like I said just watch, this hate group they call a party is doomed and that's the best thing that can happen for this country.

The "right'" direction? Presumably you mean Left? Who hates the rich the most, the Right or the Left? But do enlighten us as to the changes in detail you would employ to accomplish what you are claiming to be the "right direction".
 
Liberal WHINE about the distribution of wealth, but have you seen any millionaire and billionaire democrats redistribute their wealth. Why dont they put their wallet where their mouth is.
 
You can't give all the new wealth of a country to just a few golden few. Capitalism dies when the incentive of the possibility to get ahead is taken away. Which it has been the case since 1981. I would like the greatest most powerful richest country in the world, to stay capitalistic and a Republic. Not caring about the fact that the golden few get it all and in no way deserve it all is selling out my country.

I am from the UK, so things may be a little different here, but my guess is not an awful lot.

Firstly, capitalism is the only thing that works, so despite what some of the younger generations may believe, socialism and communism are ideals, and are not workable in the real world. Capitalism executed correctly can be compassionate, unfortunately greed tends to stop this. It works well if the people at the top have a conscience, and are prepared to share the success of the company with their employees. It may be that at some point governments need to legislate for this. Then there is the welfare issue. How much money should be distributed to those who can't work, for what ever reason. In the UK this is a massive talking point, as I would imagine it is in the U.S. Over this side of the pond the government waists an awful lot of money on the so called disabled. Believe it or not, you have only have to convince the doctor you are disabled and you will receive a benefit that can be cashed in for a brand new car, that is taxed, insured, and serviced for you. The benefit isn't even means tested, so you can be a millionaire and you still get it. If you have child with type of disability, you really are made for life. We also have the lazy bar stewards who won't work, but are very good at ticking the correct boxes on the claim forms. I have no idea how they do it, but they manage to live reasonably well and can go an entire lifetime without lifting a hand or paying tax. Unfortunately, as soon as the government make any attempt to cut back, the left liberals are out in force. Unfortunately these people shout the loudest, and therefore get listened to.
 
What is a "living wage" in dollars?
easy what ever it take for a person to feed his family(wife and two kids)' I don't have to figure that out , it's figured out monthly. It's the cost of living index.
 
Great nations of the past have been destroyed by small numbers of wicked opportunists who parlayed 'rob the rich for the sake of the poor' lying propaganda into successful coups. Those formerly great nations were not transformed into meccas for the poor. In fact, the poor often got poorer and even were butchered by the millions in some cases for not liking the new oppressive leaders.
Bull****, your not even worth reading.
 
Liberal WHINE about the distribution of wealth, but have you seen any millionaire and billionaire democrats redistribute their wealth. Why dont they put their wallet where their mouth is.
Bull**** that the difference between your hate group and real people, real people like the democratic 1%, they have no qualms about paying taxes, many have said that their taxes should be raised. , something the democrats know is just the price in living in a civilized society, in fact the level of a countries civilization is in direct relationship to the amount of their taxes.
 
I am from the UK, so things may be a little different here, but my guess is not an awful lot.

Firstly, capitalism is the only thing that works, so despite what some of the younger generations may believe, socialism and communism are ideals, and are not workable in the real world. Capitalism executed correctly can be compassionate, unfortunately greed tends to stop this. It works well if the people at the top have a conscience, and are prepared to share the success of the company with their employees. It may be that at some point governments need to legislate for this. Then there is the welfare issue. How much money should be distributed to those who can't work, for what ever reason. In the UK this is a massive talking point, as I would imagine it is in the U.S. Over this side of the pond the government waists an awful lot of money on the so called disabled. Believe it or not, you have only have to convince the doctor you are disabled and you will receive a benefit that can be cashed in for a brand new car, that is taxed, insured, and serviced for you. The benefit isn't even means tested, so you can be a millionaire and you still get it. If you have child with type of disability, you really are made for life. We also have the lazy bar stewards who won't work, but are very good at ticking the correct boxes on the claim forms. I have no idea how they do it, but they manage to live reasonably well and can go an entire lifetime without lifting a hand or paying tax. Unfortunately, as soon as the government make any attempt to cut back, the left liberals are out in force. Unfortunately these people shout the loudest, and therefore get listened to.
I quit at this "If you have child with type of disability, you really are made for life. " I know one fact which is exactly the same in this country . Goofballs all have comments about people who are on disability or unemployment. And the non stop bull**** of they know a guy. There is no way for anyone to know about another persons disability or being poor or sick, just a lot of bull**** from people who think they do. Your just another voice driven by hatred of your fellow man. That wouldn't bother me because I would never have a person around me that thought like you do.
 
Back
Top Bottom