• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Catholic League On Predatory Priests: It’s Not Rape If The Child Isn’t Penetrated

beefheart

Ice Cream for Crow?
DP Veteran
Joined
Sep 30, 2013
Messages
61,530
Reaction score
64,665
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Moderate
Catholic League On Predatory Priests: It?s Not Rape If The Child Isn?t Penetrated

William Donohue is pure filth.

Catholic League On Predatory Priests: It’s Not Rape If The Child Isn’t Penetrated
August 16, 2018 by Michael Stone

Catholic League president Bill Donohue defends predatory priests by claiming it’s not rape if the child isn’t penetrated.

In a bizarre, insensitive, and outrageous post, Bill Donohue, president of the very conservative Catholic League, attacked the recent grand jury report documenting the rape and sexual abuse of over a 1,000 children by hundreds of Catholic priests in Pennsylvania.

Donohue called the report released by the Pennsylvania Supreme Court an “obscene lie” while defending the Catholic Church and their deplorable record of covering up and enabling the rape and sexual abuse of children by predatory priests.

In his post titled “Pennsylvania Grand Jury Report Debunked,” Donohue desperately tries to minimize the findings of the Pennsylvania Supreme Court, and in so doing Donohue reveals the profound poverty of both his intellect and his character.

At one point in the deplorable post Donohue has the audacity to claim that the statement “the priests raped their victims” is actually a “myth,” writing:

Myth: The priests “raped” their victims.

Attempting to justify his assertion that the claim that “the priests raped their victims” is a “myth,” Donohue writes:

Fact: This is an obscene lie. Most of the alleged victims were not raped: they were groped or otherwise abused, but not penetrated, which is what the word “rape” means.

In a fleeting moment of self-awareness the rabid defender of all things Catholic continues:

This is not a defense — it is meant to set the record straight and debunk the worst case scenarios attributed to the offenders.

Donohue is being dishonest. He is defending predatory priests. When he claims it’s not rape if the child isn’t penetrated, he is attempting to minimize the horrific crimes of predatory priests, and in so doing he is defending those predatory priests. Full stop.
 
I think he's correct. Grope is not rape. Abuse isn't always pedophilia. Lets get our facts straight. The liberal media conflates everything together and highlights the most salacious incidents. We need numbers. Facts don't care about outrage.
 
I think he's correct. Grope is not rape. Abuse isn't always pedophilia. Lets get our facts straight. The liberal media conflates everything together and highlights the most salacious incidents. We need numbers. Facts don't care about outrage.

Where do you draw the line to "abuse?"


 
I think he's correct. Grope is not rape. Abuse isn't always pedophilia. Lets get our facts straight. The liberal media conflates everything together and highlights the most salacious incidents. We need numbers. Facts don't care about outrage.

A child can't legally give consent under a certain age.So it's a felony no matter what you call it to give a little boy a blow job.
Gross sexual imposition is a crime!
 
I think he's correct. Grope is not rape. Abuse isn't always pedophilia. Lets get our facts straight. The liberal media conflates everything together and highlights the most salacious incidents. We need numbers. Facts don't care about outrage.

Are you defending the perverted priest?
 
His statements are deplorable. He should just condemn the abuse and move on.

I think one thing that most don't realize is this:

What do priests, Boy Scout leaders, and teachers have in common? They all spend a lot of time with children. These situations attract pedophiles because pedophiles want to be around children.

The other thing most people don't think about is that it's only recently that we have this social awareness about sexual abuse. So, if you look back 30, 40, years you're going to find a lot of abuse.

The vast majority of priests are good and decent people. Sadly, the teachings regarding sin and forgiveness are completely inappropriate for dealing with pedophilia. For a long time, people didn't understand that this was a serious mental disorder. They thought of it as some sin that could be counseled and rehabilitated.
 
"Fact: This is an obscene lie. Most of the alleged victims were not raped: they were groped or otherwise abused, but not penetrated, which is what the word “rape” means. "

Oy vey...
 
I think he's correct. Grope is not rape. Abuse isn't always pedophilia. Lets get our facts straight. The liberal media conflates everything together and highlights the most salacious incidents. We need numbers. Facts don't care about outrage.

By all means, defend child raping priests, see where that will get you...
 
Catholic League president Bill Donohue defends predatory priests by claiming it’s not rape if the child isn’t penetrated.

Say what?!?!

giphy.gif






Holy "missing the point," Batman!


The form of the abuse doesn't matter when it's child whom one defiles!
 
This is what I mean. Do you know what pedophilia is? What percent of priest abuse is pedophilia?




His statements are deplorable. He should just condemn the abuse and move on.

I think one thing that most don't realize is this:

What do priests, Boy Scout leaders, and teachers have in common? They all spend a lot of time with children. These situations attract pedophiles because pedophiles want to be around children.

The other thing most people don't think about is that it's only recently that we have this social awareness about sexual abuse. So, if you look back 30, 40, years you're going to find a lot of abuse.

The vast majority of priests are good and decent people. Sadly, the teachings regarding sin and forgiveness are completely inappropriate for dealing with pedophilia. For a long time, people didn't understand that this was a serious mental disorder. They thought of it as some sin that could be counseled and rehabilitated.
 
Dumb. Read what I said. Breathe into a paper bag.

Again, it sure sounds like you are defending these priests.

Do you want to clarify your position on this matter?
 
I don't know why I should. My statements are pretty clear.

Again, it sure sounds like you are defending these priests.

Do you want to clarify your position on this matter?
 
This is what I mean. Do you know what pedophilia is? What percent of priest abuse is pedophilia?

Any improper touching by these priests is wrong.

What is worse is the defenders and minimizers and the hierarchy of the church that allowed this to happen, I've been reading the reports, priests like Ernest Paone who the church knew about for 41 years, and they did nothing....
 
I think he's correct. Grope is not rape. Abuse isn't always pedophilia. Lets get our facts straight. The liberal media conflates everything together and highlights the most salacious incidents. We need numbers. Facts don't care about outrage.

Says the person who has chosen not to disclose his/her gender.
 
Says the person who has chosen not to disclose his/her gender.

Yeah, over a thousand pages of documented cases of priests raping children...but.....its a liberal media thing.

He want's numbers? He can read the freaking report like I am doing.

Oh, and here are 389 more priests from the database....not including the PA priests.

Database of Priests Accused of Sexual Abuse


Here are the files on 128 more priests in the LA diocese...some sick stuff here.

Clergy Files - Archdiocese of Los Angeles
 
Last edited:
Still, Donahue has a point - and you're proving it. You're part of the problem - not part of solution.


Yeah, over a thousand pages of documented cases of priests raping children...but.....its a liberal media thing.

He want's numbers? He can read the freaking report like I am doing.

Oh, and here are 389 more priests from the database....not including the PA priests.

Database of Priests Accused of Sexual Abuse


Here are the files on 128 more priests in the LA diocese...some sick stuff here.

Clergy Files - Archdiocese of Los Angeles
 
Still, Donahue has a point - and you're proving it. You're part of the problem - not part of solution.

I don't see you doing any condemnation of the priests.

Touching and grabbing is bad, rape is worse. But, hey, just keep minimizing, because somehow that makes you look good ?
 
Saying it isn't technically rape is one thing. Calling it an "obscene lie" shows how unserious he takes the molesting of children. Why not just say, "calling it a rape is a bit of an over-exaggeration"? Still a tone-deaf answer but nowhere near as callus.
 
Last edited:
Saying it isn't technically rape is one thing. Calling it an "obscene lie" shows how unserious he takes the molesting of children. Why not just say, "calling it a rape is a bit of an over-exaggeration"? Still a tone-deaf answer but nowhere near as callus.

Rape is not about sex it's about power, so using a definition of sex as a qualifier is a false premise.
 

wow, when william donohue is punched in the face by somebody i bet the jury will rule thats obscene lie and technically he just fell into somebody's fist:lol:


The Pennsylvania Age of Consent is 16 years old. Individuals aged 15 or younger in Pennsylvania are not legally able to consent to sexual activity, and such activity may result in prosecution for statutory rape.
 
I think he's correct. Grope is not rape. Abuse isn't always pedophilia. Lets get our facts straight. The liberal media conflates everything together and highlights the most salacious incidents. We need numbers. Facts don't care about outrage.

Never had you pinned as a child ****er. They diddle you as a kid and now youve convinced yourself it's OK?
 
Back
Top Bottom