• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

When children are raped, abused etc. when adults and children are brought together...

Since the law in question has been there for some time, why is it that no President since its passing til Trump ever had a problem with separating thousands of kids within a matter of several weeks?
Now that he's signed an Executive Order that is in contradiction with that law, how long before someone claims that Trump thinks he's above the law?

Sent from my Z982 using Tapatalk
 
This is why you fail.

Nope, in fact I've won since Trump is reversing his decision about not keeping families together. He's right I never get tired of winning.
 
It seems that it's being pursued and that the tech is just coming up to par to try to start doing something along that route. Though I'm not really trusting of government and biometric data.

We've had the tech for a while, we just haven't had enthusiastic support for it, probably because Democrats want the votes and Republican donors want the cheap labor. On immigration, at least at the establishment level, Democrats and Republicans completely agree. Why do you think Trump was opposed so vehemently by establishment Republicans?
 
We've had the tech for a while, we just haven't had enthusiastic support for it, probably because Democrats want the votes and Republican donors want the cheap labor. On immigration, at least at the establishment level, Democrats and Republicans completely agree. Why do you think Trump was opposed so vehemently by establishment Republicans?

The article you linked to says this sort of system has bipartisan support.

Congress passed legislation in 2004 requiring the implementation of a biometric entry/exit system. Still, 12 years later, actually implementing that system has remained elusive—though experts say technological advances mean it’s on the horizon -- at least for people arriving by air.

There’s widespread consensus that such a program needs to be put in place, but it’s been much more difficult to do in practice than it is to support in theory. One House aide noted that it’s not a partisan issue: various proposals for implementing the system have received broad bipartisan support.

“If it was easy, it would have been done already,” the aide CBS News.

It said there have been technological issues with implementation, but advances in technology mean that this sort of system is "on the horizon".

To begin with, it wasn’t until the last few years that technology was up to the task: a 2009 pilot program at airports ended up being scrapped, experts say, because the process was too clunky to use nation-wide and would have required too many additional security staffers, among other reasons. There are also questions about how such a system could be implemented while still keeping the flow of international passengers moving at high-volume airports in the U.S.

Still, technology is beginning to catch up, and this appears to be on the horizon for airports at least: A group of DHS officials who testified before the House Homeland Security Committee this summer said Homeland Security Secretary Jeh Johnson has called for biometric exit procedures to be in place starting in high-volume airports in 2018.

When it comes to implementing the system at land border crossings, things become even more complicated: though the lanes to enter the U.S. at the border with Mexico are equipped to handle a new system, the “exit” lanes to Mexico aren’t—and trying to put a biometric system in place for those lanes leaving the U.S. would create massive delays (or require construction of hundreds more lanes over various border crossings).

“For the land environment, such an approach to biometric exit would require building and staffing of hundreds of outbound lanes at land ports of entry, many of them operational 24-hours a day,” the DHS officials said in a statement before their congressional testimony.

So it would seem that it has received bipartisan support and has required the tech to catch up with the theory.
 
The article you linked to says this sort of system has bipartisan support.



It said there have been technological issues with implementation, but advances in technology mean that this sort of system is "on the horizon".



So it would seem that it has received bipartisan support and has required the tech to catch up with the theory.

Except...

CIS said:
Congress has mandated the deployment of an exit-tracking system in eight separate statutes, starting in 1996. The three most recent laws require a biometric element. But the executive branch has so far refused to implement such a system.

In contrast to the rejection of biometric exit-tracking at home, the same federal government is helping install biometric border systems abroad, in Nigeria and the Philippines.

https://cis.org/Implementation-EntryExit-System
 
It was mandated, and as the other source stated, they hadn't been able to make anything practical enough to implement. 96 was Clinton, but we've had Bush, Obama, and now Trump. If it's just the "executive branch", why hasn't Trump put it into the works?

Actually this was one of the first executive orders that Trump signed. The courts have shut it down.

https://www.bayometric.com/biometric-entry-exit-screen-system-trumps-usa/

The link says that the courts have blocked implementation, but I can't find any articles about it. Section 7 of the EO contained the entry/exit system implementation, but I don't know what's happened with the newer EO's.

EDIT: The newer EO also called for expedited implementation of the entry/exit system, but I haven't heard anything for a while now.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Execu...n_of_the_biometric_entry–exit_tracking_system
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom