• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Cheesecake - Pie or Cake???

A cheesecake is a


  • Total voters
    33
Nope. I make my own NY style cheesecake. Takes a total of 6 hours, but OMG it's good!

Well to each his own....some people even make em out of lowfat cottage cheese combined with no fat yogurt......and after that...

I say do it right or not at all when it comes to me.

NY Style is very respectable.
 
In a pie crust, therefore pie.


You call it cake, I'll eat it anyway.
 
It's a pie because it's a custard.

Raise your hand if you own your own spring form pan.

I own 3. :lol: Well, two and a half. I am pretty well known for my heavy, dense NY style cheesecakes, and a friend wanted me to make one for her once. I believe it was a banana split cheesecake. I made it for her and forgot to put the parchment paper in, so the cheesecake sat directly on the bottom of the pan. I let her take it home with her, and she promised to bring it back. Then she moved and took my pan bottom with her.
 
Is a "traditional" American cheese cake a pie? Or a cake?

Why?

Does it really matter? Whatever it is it is usually delicious.
 
I own 3. :lol: Well, two and a half. I am pretty well known for my heavy, dense NY style cheesecakes, and a friend wanted me to make one for her once. I believe it was a banana split cheesecake. I made it for her and forgot to put the parchment paper in, so the cheesecake sat directly on the bottom of the pan. I let her take it home with her, and she promised to bring it back. Then she moved and took my pan bottom with her.

I finally threw out all my top halves missing their bottoms. BTW, I'm a NY style myself, but I've done what I think is called "Williamsburg style," and it was great. But rewind--a banana split cheesecake?! Wow.
 
I finally threw out all my top halves missing their bottoms. BTW, I'm a NY style myself, but I've done what I think is called "Williamsburg style," and it was great. But rewind--a banana split cheesecake?! Wow.

Yeah, I guess I should toss it. It would keep me from getting angry every time I look at it. :lol: What is Williamsburg style? I think hubs would disown me if I ever did anything other than NY style.

Yeah, banana split. See, a cheesecake is a blank slate. You can do anything with it. In addition to the banana split, I've done chocolate, banana pudding, reese's, turtle, hot fudge sundae and a handful of others that are not immediately coming to light at 5am. :lol: All you have to do is just add ingredients to it that you like. And keep a good selection of good flavorings or extract. That's the key, there. Like for banana split, I added a smidge of banana extract, to make the cheesecake itself taste like bananas. The crust was crushed up oreos (without the cream filling, so you just got the intense chocolate taste) and then I decorated the top with different banana split toppings. I didn't use bananas as a topping, because first of all, you have the banana flavor in the cheesecake, and secondly, the bananas would brown too quickly and look ugly. I just used nuts, maraschino cherries, drizzles of chocolate, a little crushed pineapple and whipped cream. I added those all around the edges, and it was a beautiful cheesecake, and tasted just like a banana split. :)
 
vegan raw cake

raw-mint-pomegranate-cake-683x1024.jpg
 
Last edited:
It can be made as a cake, a pie, a flan whatever you want. As long as I get some I'm happy
 
Yeah, I guess I should toss it. It would keep me from getting angry every time I look at it. :lol: What is Williamsburg style? I think hubs would disown me if I ever did anything other than NY style.

Yeah, banana split. See, a cheesecake is a blank slate. You can do anything with it. In addition to the banana split, I've done chocolate, banana pudding, reese's, turtle, hot fudge sundae and a handful of others that are not immediately coming to light at 5am. :lol: All you have to do is just add ingredients to it that you like. And keep a good selection of good flavorings or extract. That's the key, there. Like for banana split, I added a smidge of banana extract, to make the cheesecake itself taste like bananas. The crust was crushed up oreos (without the cream filling, so you just got the intense chocolate taste) and then I decorated the top with different banana split toppings. I didn't use bananas as a topping, because first of all, you have the banana flavor in the cheesecake, and secondly, the bananas would brown too quickly and look ugly. I just used nuts, maraschino cherries, drizzles of chocolate, a little crushed pineapple and whipped cream. I added those all around the edges, and it was a beautiful cheesecake, and tasted just like a banana split. :)

I think I must be a cheesecake purist, but this sounds divine. I know most people use lemon or another fruit juice to keep sliced bananas from turning color, but my mom's secret was spritzing them with white wine or just letting them sit a few minutes in it.
 
I think I must be a cheesecake purist, but this sounds divine. I know most people use lemon or another fruit juice to keep sliced bananas from turning color, but my mom's secret was spritzing them with white wine or just letting them sit a few minutes in it.

I hadn't thought of the lemon for the bananas, and the white wine sounds even better!
 
I hadn't thought of the lemon for the bananas, and the white wine sounds even better!

I have lingering fruit salad feelings of inadequacy, so I've never tried this. Every Thanksgiving, 15 of them now, I go through this fruit salad angst and rebellion against peeling grapes, which makes me a failure, of course, so I don't try. But I promise you that lemon juice squeezed over avocados/guacamole prevents color-turn.
 
I have lingering fruit salad feelings of inadequacy, so I've never tried this. Every Thanksgiving, 15 of them now, I go through this fruit salad angst and rebellion against peeling grapes, which makes me a failure, of course, so I don't try. But I promise you that lemon juice squeezed over avocados/guacamole prevents color-turn.

I can gladly say that I have never in my life peeled a grape, and I never will. :lol:
 
I can gladly say that I have never in my life peeled a grape, and I never will. :lol:

I suspect I won't either, hence the angst. I should at least attempt this amazing fruit salad (real whipping cream and dates). But I never even manage to get all the stringy dealies off oranges and grapefruit, and this too is a must.

I also didn't have a relish tray, sigh. I used to watch Mom make radish roses (not that anybody ate these, but they were sooo pretty) and slice the ends of celery sticks into tiny strips and then somehow crimp them so that they were curly and frilly, and I can't do that either.

I did learn how she fluted the cucumber slices, though (peel the cucumber and then run a fork from top to bottom all around and slice--very pretty).

I've got to stop going through this annual orgy of guilt.
 
I have lingering fruit salad feelings of inadequacy, so I've never tried this. Every Thanksgiving, 15 of them now, I go through this fruit salad angst and rebellion against peeling grapes, which makes me a failure, of course, so I don't try. But I promise you that lemon juice squeezed over avocados/guacamole prevents color-turn.

Why would you peel grapes?
 
Why would you peel grapes?

To remove their skins.

And depending on the type of grape, the seeds must also be removed.
 
I voted OTHER ............... I'll have a nice Cuban cigar & a Chianti Classico ...............
 
Is a "traditional" American cheese cake a pie? Or a cake?

Why?

I make sweet potato pie during this time of year and it has a very similar consistency. Not sure why its called cheesecake but its really pie. Don't care what you call it, its really good.
 
Back
Top Bottom