• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

NFL Says Vegan Players are "Breaking the Mold"

Joined
Feb 20, 2016
Messages
3,089
Reaction score
571
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Progressive
So much for the nay sayers

NFL veganism? David Carter, Griff Whalen have broken the mold - NFL.com

David Carter, a 6-foot-5, 300-pound defensive lineman, and his teammates are at a steakhouse, the second-most-frequented nonresidential house for NFL types after the field house.

Beefy football players order large slabs of steak. Knives cut through the buttery brown exterior and forks puncture the reddish center.

In front of Carter sits a dish of green beans, no butter.

This was a familiar scene for the now-retired Carter in his final couple of seasons as the rare vegan football player. After adopting the diet in 2014, his 300 pounds were 100 percent plant-powered, as the vegan diet prohibits the consumption of all animal products, including honey, eggs, meat and dairy.

"Socially, it kind of isolates you," Carter said. "Football is a machismo sport, which is great, but everything can't be machismo. On the field and at practice, yes, you can be machismo, but when it comes to diet, you need to have compassion for your body."

As a defensive lineman, Carter always focused on being big. A three-star recruit on Rivals.com coming out of high school, he worked his way up the depth chart at UCLA, eventually starting and earning the program's Kenneth S. Washington Award for Outstanding Senior in 2010. Drafted in the sixth round of the 2011 NFL Draft by the Arizona Cardinals, Carter never could've imagined giving up his carnivorous lifestyle, fearful of becoming weak and skinny. He drank milkshakes and chomped down meat, consuming as much protein as possible. But as the years went on, he suffered from high blood pressure and nerve damage. He couldn't feel half of his right hand and had agonizing tendonitis in most of his joints. He took painkillers but still struggled to do push-ups and even make a fist.

One night in 2014, he watched a documentary titled "Forks Over Knives" that explained how dairy and animal fats can cause inflammation in joints.

"It got me thinking, why do we need meat?" Carter said. "I need protein to be big and strong, but look at some of the largest and strongest animals in the world and none of them eat meat."

When he became a vegan, all of his ailments dissipated, and his performance at practices and in the weight room improved.

"My food is my medication now," said Carter, who played with the Cardinals in 2011 and '12 before spending time with the Cowboys, Raiders, Jaguars and Bears from 2013 through '15. Having hung up his cleats, Carter now travels the country advocating for the diet.
 
So much for the nay sayers

NFL veganism? David Carter, Griff Whalen have broken the mold - NFL.com

David Carter, a 6-foot-5, 300-pound defensive lineman, and his teammates are at a steakhouse, the second-most-frequented nonresidential house for NFL types after the field house.

Beefy football players order large slabs of steak. Knives cut through the buttery brown exterior and forks puncture the reddish center.

In front of Carter sits a dish of green beans, no butter.

This was a familiar scene for the now-retired Carter in his final couple of seasons as the rare vegan football player. After adopting the diet in 2014, his 300 pounds were 100 percent plant-powered, as the vegan diet prohibits the consumption of all animal products, including honey, eggs, meat and dairy.

"Socially, it kind of isolates you," Carter said. "Football is a machismo sport, which is great, but everything can't be machismo. On the field and at practice, yes, you can be machismo, but when it comes to diet, you need to have compassion for your body."

As a defensive lineman, Carter always focused on being big. A three-star recruit on Rivals.com coming out of high school, he worked his way up the depth chart at UCLA, eventually starting and earning the program's Kenneth S. Washington Award for Outstanding Senior in 2010. Drafted in the sixth round of the 2011 NFL Draft by the Arizona Cardinals, Carter never could've imagined giving up his carnivorous lifestyle, fearful of becoming weak and skinny. He drank milkshakes and chomped down meat, consuming as much protein as possible. But as the years went on, he suffered from high blood pressure and nerve damage. He couldn't feel half of his right hand and had agonizing tendonitis in most of his joints. He took painkillers but still struggled to do push-ups and even make a fist.

One night in 2014, he watched a documentary titled "Forks Over Knives" that explained how dairy and animal fats can cause inflammation in joints.

"It got me thinking, why do we need meat?" Carter said. "I need protein to be big and strong, but look at some of the largest and strongest animals in the world and none of them eat meat."

When he became a vegan, all of his ailments dissipated, and his performance at practices and in the weight room improved.

"My food is my medication now," said Carter, who played with the Cardinals in 2011 and '12 before spending time with the Cowboys, Raiders, Jaguars and Bears from 2013 through '15. Having hung up his cleats, Carter now travels the country advocating for the diet.

Simple answer, creatine
 
Pro athletes consume 10k to 12k calories a day in some instances. Michael Phelps famously followed such a high calorie diet.

Is it possible to fuel your body with only plant based foods, as a pro athlete, while maintaining a very high caloric intake? No.

Notice Carter says he learned of Veganism in 2014, and retired from the NFL in 2015. Retiring from football probably had more to do with him feeling better than veganism did.
 
Damn aliens, they need to go back to Vega already and leave Earth for the humans. They're bringing drugs, they're bringing crime, they're rapists..........
 
Pro athletes consume 10k to 12k calories a day in some instances. Michael Phelps famously followed such a high calorie diet.

Is it possible to fuel your body with only plant based foods, as a pro athlete, while maintaining a very high caloric intake? No.

Notice Carter says he learned of Veganism in 2014, and retired from the NFL in 2015. Retiring from football probably had more to do with him feeling better than veganism did.

I agree. I was a competitive powerlifter in my youth - and trying to compete as a master next year. There is simply no way I can get the 250 grams of protein I'm supposed to eat daily on a primarily plant diet. Hell it's tough enough when you eat meat.
 
Damn aliens, they need to go back to Vega already and leave Earth for the humans. They're bringing drugs, they're bringing crime, they're rapists..........

And some, I assume, are good beings
 
So much for the nay sayers

NFL veganism? David Carter, Griff Whalen have broken the mold - NFL.com

David Carter, a 6-foot-5, 300-pound defensive lineman, and his teammates are at a steakhouse, the second-most-frequented nonresidential house for NFL types after the field house.

Beefy football players order large slabs of steak. Knives cut through the buttery brown exterior and forks puncture the reddish center.

In front of Carter sits a dish of green beans, no butter.

This was a familiar scene for the now-retired Carter in his final couple of seasons as the rare vegan football player. After adopting the diet in 2014, his 300 pounds were 100 percent plant-powered, as the vegan diet prohibits the consumption of all animal products, including honey, eggs, meat and dairy.

"Socially, it kind of isolates you," Carter said. "Football is a machismo sport, which is great, but everything can't be machismo. On the field and at practice, yes, you can be machismo, but when it comes to diet, you need to have compassion for your body."

As a defensive lineman, Carter always focused on being big. A three-star recruit on Rivals.com coming out of high school, he worked his way up the depth chart at UCLA, eventually starting and earning the program's Kenneth S. Washington Award for Outstanding Senior in 2010. Drafted in the sixth round of the 2011 NFL Draft by the Arizona Cardinals, Carter never could've imagined giving up his carnivorous lifestyle, fearful of becoming weak and skinny. He drank milkshakes and chomped down meat, consuming as much protein as possible. But as the years went on, he suffered from high blood pressure and nerve damage. He couldn't feel half of his right hand and had agonizing tendonitis in most of his joints. He took painkillers but still struggled to do push-ups and even make a fist.

One night in 2014, he watched a documentary titled "Forks Over Knives" that explained how dairy and animal fats can cause inflammation in joints.

"It got me thinking, why do we need meat?" Carter said. "I need protein to be big and strong, but look at some of the largest and strongest animals in the world and none of them eat meat."

When he became a vegan, all of his ailments dissipated, and his performance at practices and in the weight room improved.

"My food is my medication now," said Carter, who played with the Cardinals in 2011 and '12 before spending time with the Cowboys, Raiders, Jaguars and Bears from 2013 through '15. Having hung up his cleats, Carter now travels the country advocating for the diet.

He is retired - none of this for active players.

Meat is required by active players.

Thread title is misleading.
 
Stop spamming the forum with your vegan **** propaganda. If you want to subsist on dirt, that's your prerogative; you don't know to shove our faces into the dirt along with you.
 
So much for the nay sayers

NFL veganism? David Carter, Griff Whalen have broken the mold - NFL.com

David Carter, a 6-foot-5, 300-pound defensive lineman, and his teammates are at a steakhouse, the second-most-frequented nonresidential house for NFL types after the field house.

Beefy football players order large slabs of steak. Knives cut through the buttery brown exterior and forks puncture the reddish center.

In front of Carter sits a dish of green beans, no butter.

This was a familiar scene for the now-retired Carter in his final couple of seasons as the rare vegan football player. After adopting the diet in 2014, his 300 pounds were 100 percent plant-powered, as the vegan diet prohibits the consumption of all animal products, including honey, eggs, meat and dairy.

"Socially, it kind of isolates you," Carter said. "Football is a machismo sport, which is great, but everything can't be machismo. On the field and at practice, yes, you can be machismo, but when it comes to diet, you need to have compassion for your body."

As a defensive lineman, Carter always focused on being big. A three-star recruit on Rivals.com coming out of high school, he worked his way up the depth chart at UCLA, eventually starting and earning the program's Kenneth S. Washington Award for Outstanding Senior in 2010. Drafted in the sixth round of the 2011 NFL Draft by the Arizona Cardinals, Carter never could've imagined giving up his carnivorous lifestyle, fearful of becoming weak and skinny. He drank milkshakes and chomped down meat, consuming as much protein as possible. But as the years went on, he suffered from high blood pressure and nerve damage. He couldn't feel half of his right hand and had agonizing tendonitis in most of his joints. He took painkillers but still struggled to do push-ups and even make a fist.

One night in 2014, he watched a documentary titled "Forks Over Knives" that explained how dairy and animal fats can cause inflammation in joints.

"It got me thinking, why do we need meat?" Carter said. "I need protein to be big and strong, but look at some of the largest and strongest animals in the world and none of them eat meat."

When he became a vegan, all of his ailments dissipated, and his performance at practices and in the weight room improved.

"My food is my medication now," said Carter, who played with the Cardinals in 2011 and '12 before spending time with the Cowboys, Raiders, Jaguars and Bears from 2013 through '15. Having hung up his cleats, Carter now travels the country advocating for the diet.

A retired football player that just started his vegan diet within a year before retiring from the NFL is breaking the mold? Looking at his wikipedia page it looks like he had a ****ty career with the NFL while on his vegan diet.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_Carter_(defensive_lineman)
Carter was drafted by the Arizona Cardinals in the sixth round of the 2011 NFL Draft. He spent two seasons with the Cardinals, starting just four games and totaling one sack and 17 total tackles.

Carter signed with the Dallas Cowboys in 2013, appearing in three games for the Cowboys.[2]

Carter was signed by the Jacksonville Jaguars on August 2, 2014. The Jaguars released Carter on August 24, 2014.[3]

The Chicago Bears signed Carter to a one-year contract on July 28, 2015.[4] On September 5, 2015, he was released by the Bears.[5]
 
I doubt that they have enough strength to break a mold.
 
Bad player goes vegan, lasts 22 days with one team and a few months with another? Great success story.




I lift a lot and run a lot. I don't have these joint and nerve problems. I also don't play professional football.

Now, maybe I'm insane, but somehow - just somehow - I suspect those problems were related to being a 300 pound beast that slammed into other 300 pound beasts at absurd levels of force, and the disappearance of those problems were related to no longer slamming into other 300 pound beasts. I do recall having all sorts of such issues, but not as severe, when I was a lowly 200ish "beast" slamming into 240ish pound "beasts" back in High School football....

Funny thing about repeated high-velocity impacts: they cause damage.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top Bottom