Holy Moly! I tried to just scroll down in the Food Forum to find this thread, and discovered the forum had become
All About teh Vegan. Had to do a search. What in the world is going on?
Anyway, wanted to follow up about my decision. I was about to order one of the inexpensive pans recommended in this thead, but then stumbled upon (at least that's my story and I'm sticking to it) this Emeril by All-Clad non-stick fry pan on sale on Amazon:
https://www.amazon.com/gp/product/B00KG7IEEQ/ref=oh_aui_detailpage_o00_s00?ie=UTF8&psc=1
Supposed retail = $50
"Used" = $33 (and now it's down to $30)
They're new, but the ad copy said they had minor scratches on the handle. Turned out to be some scratches you can barely see on the bottom of the handle. Now I'm kicking myself that I replaced the 10" pan I ruined with an 8" one, but I am really happy with the performance - so far - as well as the feel of this pan. Of course, the longevity of the coating remains to be seen, but my experience with the 3 Emeril non-stick pots/pans I've bought in the past has been extremely positive.
Often, little pans or skillets, especially inexpensive ones, want to tip easily because the handle is too heavy for the size of the pot, or they try to solve that problem by making the handle too short which puts your hand too close to the heat. This one has a real solid feel. And the handle stays cool during normal useage.
I never don't use at least a little oil or butter, so have no idea how this pan would do with something like eggs without some oil, but so far it is absolutely non-stick. I'd forgotten how great a brand new pan like this performs, my others lasted so long. They never have failed, just degraded slightly over time.
So, it's been so much fun cooking fried eggs and omelets since I got this, that I checked out the prices for larger Emeril skillets. No thanks. Too much money. I don't even want to look to see what the actual All-Clad stuff costs.