- Joined
- Oct 28, 2007
- Messages
- 23,944
- Reaction score
- 16,534
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Independent
I'm not talking about you and Sven, but there are others such as Chagos who is a one trick pony specialising in shooting the messenger not the message. I've seen the odd constructive post, but mostly it's a barrage of nonsense about 'Kremlin propaganda'. We don't know the reasons why people come and go - I doubt it's because they've been defeated by Remain arguments. In fact, often there are no Remain arguments made. I suspect that's because Remainers honestly think Brexit is self evidently such a stupid idea that there is no need to make the case against it.
The truth is more that neither Leavers nor Remainers do much listening to each other. There is very obvious contempt for the other, and a gulf so large that it's un-bridgeable (at least on the extremes). I suspect however that the UK will leave the EU but maintain close links. As you know, I've always felt that May's deal will pass parliament at the last minute provided the EU can fashion something on the backstop for May to take home. If they won't give her anything at all - then that would be a mistake.
The argument for Remaining is pretty clear: free access to the single market. There are other things too such as a huge rebate and outputs from things we don't like such as Schengen and the Euro. If you want the best reason for staying - look at the supposed golden age before the UK joined the EEC in 1973 and look at our GDP in comparison with European nations like Germany, Italy and France. As soon as we joined, our GDP and wealth began to rise - that is documented fact.
Sovereignty was never given up, we pooled sovereignty where necessary.
It's a rebellion against gaping inequality, against cosmopolitan wealth and small town decay. It was a vote that empowered and energised those who have done badly out of globalism - the white working class who have been subject to years of being called racists, who have no prospects thanks to endless supplies of cheap labor, whose towns have changed without their consent. For many Leavers, the feeling of being ignored, forgotten, fed scraps was lifted. Brexit brought hope when before there was none. Leavers want change, and often on the basis that nothing can be worse than the destruction and hopelessness of the status quo.
Most of those reasons for leaving are down to national policy, not EU policy. Cheap labour - jobs in farming, industry and other areas have been left to EU migrants because many didn't want those jobs. They were better paid staying on unemployment benefit than going to the farm to pick fruit and vegetables. If locals were willing to do more of that work - why would employers hire from Europe?
It can be argued that cheap foreign labour suppressed wages but that is down to local not EU policy.
~ Indeed, i know more Remainers who accept that the UK must now leave and just want to get on with it.
Many like me are curious to see who the Brexiteers will have to blame once we are out of the EU. Believe me, someone else is always going to be at fault - no responsibility will be taken.