• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Insects Are Dying En Masse

Rogue Valley

Lead or get out of the way
DP Veteran
Joined
Apr 18, 2013
Messages
94,329
Reaction score
82,719
Location
Barsoom
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
Insects Are Dying En Masse, Risking ‘Catastrophic’ Collapse Of Earth’s Ecosystems

180828204911_1_540x360.jpg


2/11/19
There have been warning signs for years about plummeting insect populations worldwide, but the extent of the potentially “catastrophic” crisis had not been well-understood — until now. The first global scientific review of insect population decline was published this week in the journal Biological Conservation and the findings are “shocking,” its authors said. More than 40 percent of insect species are dwindling globally and a third of species are endangered, concluded the peer-reviewed study, which analyzed 73 historical reports on insect population declines. “It is very rapid. In 10 years you will have a quarter less, in 50 years only half left and in 100 years you will have none,” study co-author Francisco Sánchez-Bayo, an environmental biologist at the University of Sydney, Australia, told The Guardian. “If insect species losses cannot be halted, this will have catastrophic consequences for both the planet’s ecosystems and for the survival of mankind,” Sánchez-Bayo added. Scientists have warned that a human-caused sixth mass extinction is now underway on Earth. Vertebrate species, both on land and under the sea, are threatened at a global scale because of human activities. But according to the new review, the proportion of insects in decline is currently twice as high as that of vertebrates and the insect extinction rate is eight times faster than that of mammals, birds and reptiles.

Insects play a profoundly important role in Earth’s ecosystems. They are a food source for many animals, are critical pollinators and recycle nutrients back into the soil. In a November New York Times report about a possible “insect apocalypse,” scientists were asked to imagine a world with no insects. They found “words like chaos, collapse, Armageddon,” the Times wrote. ”[One entomologist] describes a flowerless world with silent forests, a world of dung and old leaves and rotting carcasses accumulating in cities and roadsides, a world of ‘collapse or decay and erosion and loss that would spread through ecosystems.’” According to the new scientific review, habitat loss because of intensive agriculture is the top driver of insect population declines. The heavy use of pesticides, climate change and invasive species were also pinpointed as significant causes. “Unless we change our ways of producing food, insects as a whole will go down the path of extinction in a few decades,” the review’s co-authors wrote. “The repercussions this will have for the planet’s ecosystems are catastrophic to say the least.”

Catastrophic damage to the food chain will occur if insect populations keep dying off. Wild bumblebees have almost disappeared in the United States.

Related: Worldwide decline of the entomofauna: A review of its drivers

Bumblebee listed as endangered species for first time
 
Yes, this is a real and very dangerous thing.

We must find out what the cause is and sort it quickly.
 
If habitat loss is due to agricultural uses, then it seems the answer is reducing the need for more agriculture. That would be population control. I seldom if ever see that proposed.

As best we can tell, there have been at least 6 catastrophic climate changes including one which wiped out 95% of the worlds species. All 6 happened long before man existed.
 
If habitat loss is due to agricultural uses, then it seems the answer is reducing the need for more agriculture. That would be population control. I seldom if ever see that proposed.

As best we can tell, there have been at least 6 catastrophic climate changes including one which wiped out 95% of the worlds species. All 6 happened long before man existed.
Common sense tells me we will not have to worry. Mother Earth will control our population for us, sooner or later. There might be hell to pay in between tho
 
If habitat loss is due to agricultural uses, then it seems the answer is reducing the need for more agriculture. That would be population control. I seldom if ever see that proposed.

As best we can tell, there have been at least 6 catastrophic climate changes including one which wiped out 95% of the worlds species. All 6 happened long before man existed.

Can we somehow apply this to mosquitos? Disappearing habitat and climate change would be my guess as to the big causes.
 
Mankind began dooming itself when it went with Sky Daddy instead of Mama Nature.
 
Common sense tells me we will not have to worry. Mother Earth will control our population for us, sooner or later. There might be hell to pay in between tho

That's true. One of the things I concluded long ago is that man will never destroy the earth, but the earth will destroy man at some point.
 
Monsanto what exactly?
From what I have read, the new bio engineered crops have insecticide coded into them.
It is likely not enough to kill the pollinators directly , but could weaken the hive.
Speculation on my part, but I suspect it is difficult to make a selective insecticide,
the kills the parasitic insects but not the symbiotic insects.
 
Monsanto what?? :shock:

Exactly.

Has anyone any evidence Monsanto is at the helm of this Titanic?

I live far from Monsanto crops and have seen colony collapse.

Because of that I actually left active hives in a stand of plumbago and in our car port. Each hive survived for years. We are hoping fro a new swarm this year and have a box standing by.
 
From what I have read, the new bio engineered crops have insecticide coded into them.
It is likely not enough to kill the pollinators directly , but could weaken the hive.
Speculation on my part, but I suspect it is difficult to make a selective insecticide,
the kills the parasitic insects but not the symbiotic insects.

Colony collapse has been seen in areas Monsanto hasn't monopolized.

Scientists have pointed to any number of causes to include parasitic critters and even fungi/molds.

There used to be a wide expanse of grassland near us. Now it is all faux medditeran houses. The Anise weed swallowtail is rare where they used to be abundant.
 
Colony collapse has been seen in areas Monsanto hasn't monopolized.

Scientists have pointed to any number of causes to include parasitic critters and even fungi/molds.

There used to be a wide expanse of grassland near us. Now it is all faux medditeran houses. The Anise weed swallowtail is rare where they used to be abundant.

You may be right, while the cause is unclear, I think it is likel not global warming, as we are still well within the bees normal temperature range.
 
CLUE: Global Warming.
/

Nope, for once, the climate is the minor issue.
Monoculture and factory farming, and extensive overuse of a wide variety of dangerous pesticides.
Those are the major issues. If it was just a massive increase in temp and carbon, the insects would adapt, and rather quickly.

They pollinate what we grow, they eat what dies, they eat what we plant, they are on the other end of several chains that we've been polluting.
We've been destroying their immune systems with things that they seem unable to fight back against.
 
If habitat loss is due to agricultural uses, then it seems the answer is reducing the need for more agriculture.

Not agriculture, the KIND of agriculture. Nature NEVER plants "monoculture" and most of modern mankind now practices monoculture.
Nature never uses natural gas based fertilizer, and most of us now use it exclusively.
Nature finds ways to put a lot of carbon and microbes back into the soil. We do not, but we know how (biochar) but until we start doing it, what we grow will gradually become less and less nutritious.

Our farming system is convenient for humans, but it is not compatible.
 
CLUE: Global Warming.
/

Given that there has not been any such warming to justify such things it is not that.

I know you want just the one answer to all problems but the world is far more complex.
 
If habitat loss is due to agricultural uses, then it seems the answer is reducing the need for more agriculture. That would be population control. I seldom if ever see that proposed.

As best we can tell, there have been at least 6 catastrophic climate changes including one which wiped out 95% of the worlds species. All 6 happened long before man existed.

Nope, the effect has been seen in German forrests. Middle of them away from farms.
 
And where there are no Monsanto crops?

Eh?

The loss of insect populations is a very very alarming thing. We don't know what is causing it but something recent must be doing it. One of the recent changes in pesticides is the introduction of neo-nicitinoids.

Why are you talking about crops? How would they effect the ecology of a forrest tens of miles away from the nearest farm?
 
That we are mucking up the place is not really in question. My take on it is that human population was under control up until the advent of agriculture. And, then the discovery of fossil fuels really shot that through the roof.
 
Eh?

The loss of insect populations is a very very alarming thing. We don't know what is causing it but something recent must be doing it. One of the recent changes in pesticides is the introduction of neo-nicitinoids.

Why are you talking about crops? How would they effect the ecology of a forrest tens of miles away from the nearest farm?

That is sort of my question.... I have asked it of others. If one is no where near an E-Vile Monsanto farm how can the Monsanto evils have an effect?
 
Back
Top Bottom