• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservatives

Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

So I did a little research. The Black Robe Regiment was actually restarted, as a concept, by Chuck Baldwin of the constitutionalist party back in the mid 2000s.

Resurrecting the Black Regiment

Chuck Baldwin has a rich history with American militia groups and just last week was urging armed revolution against the federal government on his website...

Chuck Baldwin Live | Fighting for Constitutional Government in America

And, Chuck is headed out west, to MOntana, to join up with like-minded "Patriots."



What message do you think that Glenn Beck is sending by co-opting this existing entity/idea?

I think he is trying to gain support from religious leaders to lend credibility to his cause, without actually knowing for sure what his cause is.
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

Oh, I don't know...

klu_klux_klan_139321s.jpg

Right. So 240 blacks, whites, Hispanics, Christians, Jews, Muslims.....are now the new KKK and will be going after....................who?
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

Where is your response to the OTHER post?
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

So I did a little research. The Black Robe Regiment was actually restarted, as a concept, by Chuck Baldwin of the constitutionalist party back in the mid 2000s.

Resurrecting the Black Regiment

Chuck Baldwin has a rich history with American militia groups and just last week was urging armed revolution against the federal government on his website...

Chuck Baldwin Live | Fighting for Constitutional Government in America

And, Chuck is headed out west, to MOntana, to join up with like-minded "Patriots."



What message do you think that Glenn Beck is sending by co-opting this existing entity/idea?

Can you link Beck to this man? Can you cite where Glenn Beck has said we should take up arms against our government? If so, I'd love to read it. Otherwise, I believe Beck modeled the new Black Robes to the 1700s group of religious people.
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

Where is your response to the OTHER post?

And your response to mine?
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

Mine was obviously satire. :D

Good to hear that. So why is it so silly to you?
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

Actually, after reading about Chuck Baldwin, I don't find it silly at all.

Glenn Beck could not possibly have been unaware of Chuck Baldwin's Black Robe Regiment. They are both libertarian/constitutionalists, and they run in similar circles. Pull your head out of the sand, Melly.
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

Actually, after reading about Chuck Baldwin, I don't find it silly at all.

Glenn Beck could not possibly have been unaware of Chuck Baldwin's Black Robe Regiment. They are both libertarian/constitutionalists, and they run in similar circles. Pull your head out of the sand, Melly.

It's spelled Mellie, thanks.

Still waiting for the proof that they are linked and/or Glenn has advocated taking up arms against the government.
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

It's spelled Mellie, thanks.

Still waiting for the proof that they are linked and/or Glenn has advocated taking up arms against the government.

The Black Robe REgiment is definitely linked. As far as Glenn advocating taking up arms against the government, I never claimed this. Baldwin is the one who wants a revolution, per se.
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

The Black Robe REgiment is definitely linked. As far as Glenn advocating taking up arms against the government, I never claimed this. Baldwin is the one who wants a revolution, per se.

How are Glenn's Black Robes linked to Baldwin's take on it? Their ideas do not work together. Grasping at straws cuz that's all ya got.
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

It's spelled Mellie, thanks.

Still waiting for the proof that they are linked and/or Glenn has advocated taking up arms against the government.

Melie:

If even 25% of the paranoid b.s. that he spews on his show were actually true... (and by true I mean based on facts and reality)...I would take up arms agains the government.

He runs these video pieces so filled with propaganda and fearful images, and yet, the guy won the lier of the year award from that fact-check outfit.

No, he doesn't come right out and say, "take up arms", but the whole premise of his show is "be afraid, be very afraid, Acorn and Obama are out to get you..."

Fear is the great motivator.
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

How are Glenn's Black Robes linked to Baldwin's take on it? Their ideas do not work together. Grasping at straws cuz that's all ya got.

Glenn Beck's black robes are identical to Baldwin's. Where do you think Glenn Beck got the idea. Are you going to tell me that Glenn Beck didn't research this before creating this idea?

Black Robe Brigade (2004) Pastors

Chuck Baldwin

These guys are constitutionalists and run in the same circles.

Why don't you do some research, Mellie. Isn't it convenient that Glenn Beck is copying an idea from David Black, who copied it from Chuck Baldwin, and that Chuck and Dave are old constitutionalist buddies?

http://www.chuckbaldwinlive.com/blackregiment.php
 
Last edited:
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

I'm sorry....Glenn Beck created the new Black Robes to take over the government? Is that what you think, Catz? And I still have no proof from you that Glenn and Baldwin have any links to each other. The new Black Robes are modeled after the 18th century one.
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

Resurrecting the Black Regiment - Chuck Baldwin's MySpace Blog |


Resurrecting the Black Regiment | Print | E-mail
Written by Chuck Baldwin Friday, 04 September 2009 02:41
It is for this reason that I took on the task of resurrecting the Black Regiment. In July of 2007, I put out my first appeal to help locate a modern-day Black Regiment. (And my appeal echoes other great Americans’, such as Professor David Alan Black and Rev. Wayne Sedlak, who called for a resurrection of the Black Regiment even before I did.) I asked readers to help me locate brave and courageous patriot-pastors in the similitude of the Black Regiment of old. The result of this appeal has been truly exciting.

On my Black Regiment website (Chuck Baldwin Live), we now have over 200 pastors and evangelists who have signed up to be included in a modern-day Black Regiment. This was done primarily so that people around the country who hunger to attend a church that has a patriot-pastor in the pulpit can find a place of worship. I extend the invitation to readers of this column to further assist me in locating such patriot-preachers.

I am personally convinced that the only thing necessary for God to send another Great Awakening — along with the accompanying reclamation of liberty and independence — is for God’s men in the pulpits to return to their heritage by becoming the champions of freedom: sounding forth the clarion call to resist tyranny and defend liberty, as did our forebears in the Black Regiment.
Chuck Baldwin is a radio broadcaster, syndicated columnist, and pastor. He was the Constitution Party's nominee for president in 2008.
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

And I still have no proof from you that Glenn and Baldwin have any links to each other. The new Black Robes are modeled after the 18th century one.

No. The Black Robes of Glenn Beck ARE the black robes of CHuck Baldwin are the black robes of David Alan Black. Duh.

I'm sorry....Glenn Beck creayted the new Black Robes to take over the government? Is that what you think, Catz?

Don't be obtuse. My point is that Glenn Beck is trying to build on the foundation of the whackjob reconstructionist constitutionalists, and pull them into his fold.
 
Last edited:
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

You're right, nut. Glenn doesn't come right out and say take up arms. He doesn't even imply it. However, he does come right out and say to STAY PEACEFUL....to be NON-VIOLENT...to be KIND, PRAYERFUL and POLITE.

So....I guess all that non-violence talk is code for "Kill 'em all!" I bet you really hated Ghandi and MLK.

LOL!
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

No. The Black Robes of Glenn Beck ARE the black robes of CHuck Baldwin are the black robes of David Alan Black. Duh.

How so? They're all the same people? They have the same goals?
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

GY7u9.jpg
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati


Fear Anger Hate Tea?

Is that suppose to mean something? Why should I fear tea - I thought it was an anticarcinogen and healthy?
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati


Are not the anti-Beck crowd preaching fear and hate toward Beck and his beliefs?
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

Are not the anti-Beck crowd preaching fear and hate toward Beck and his beliefs?

Of course they are!

But they'll never admit to that.
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

Life is suffering.

Just ask any Buddhist.

:lol:

It's true!
The First Noble Truth.

No one can deny the truth in it.
 
Re: TRENDING: At rally, Beck positions himself as new leader for Christian conservati

Life is suffering.

Just ask any Buddhist.

:lol:

Yeah, but there is something to be said about suffering in SILENCE.....
 
Back
Top Bottom