• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Indiana Grandmother Jailed After Buying One Box Too Many of Cold Medicine

RightinNYC

Girthless
DP Veteran
Joined
Mar 21, 2005
Messages
25,893
Reaction score
12,484
Location
New York, NY
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Slightly Conservative
Legal Blog Watch

Ultimately, it was the box of Mucinex-D that Sally Harpold purchased for her daughter in March 2009 at a Clinton, Indiana, drugstore that got her thrown in jail. Because it came on the heels of a purchase of a box of Zyrtec-D cold medicine that she had already dared to pick up for her husband earlier that week, Harpold, a grandmother of triplets, was awoken by police officers banging on the front door of her home on July 30 (four months after the purchases) and taken in handcuffs to the Clinton Police Department. She was questioned about her cold medicine purchases, and then sent to jail until her husband posted $300 bail. Later, her police mug shot appeared on the front page of her local newspaper in an article entitled, "17 Arrested in Drug Sweep."

...

Indiana police arrested Harpold because her two purchases meant that she was technically in violation of a statute that restricts the sale of ephedrine and pseudoephedrine products to no more than 3.0 grams within any seven-day period. The statute is intended to help fight the problem of methamphetamine production in the area, as pseudoephedrine can be used to manufacture "meth." As Vermillion County Prosecutor Nina Alexander notes, however, the law does not require that the purchase must be made with the intent to make meth. Alexander told the local press that the public has the responsibility to know what is legal and what is not, and ignorance of the law is no excuse. "I’m simply enforcing the law as it was written,” Alexander said.

While this is obviously absurd, it's part of a growing trend of criminalization of things that don't require intent. It's a serious problem.
 
Oh, FFS !

This is insane. The lack of any kind of useful cold medicines anymore already pisses me off. They don't work for nothing anymore ('cept for Nyquil, that still works ... )
 
Ignorance is stupidity. Law is not morality.
 
Legal Blog Watch



While this is obviously absurd, it's part of a growing trend of criminalization of things that don't require intent. It's a serious problem.

I sure hope this woman is paying a visit to the ACLU. Additionally, which ever official it was that authorized this woman's arrest needs to be fired.
 
Brought to you by the brilliantly conceived and fabulously executed war on drugs! But Brutus is an honorable man.
 
Last edited:
What happens when we break the law?
What happens when the rules aren't fair?
 
WOW !! And all of this time I thought that musilex was a cereal !! So it's against the law to buy too much cereal.
 
I went to the pharmacy last month to "stock up" because my husband and my 2 kids had bad colds. I had to sign an agreement and they took my drivers license, and verified my address just in case I was using 4-way, Triaminic night time cold relief, Children's Benedryl, and Advil cold and sinus for purposes not intended.

Guess they thought I was cooking something other than meatballs in my kitchen. Totally crazy! I can see a cause for concern if I buy 20 boxes of sudafed but give me a break!
 
Sweet Jumping Geebus! Pardon her for wanting to keep her household as well as possible!
 
Oh, FFS !

This is insane. The lack of any kind of useful cold medicines anymore already pisses me off. They don't work for nothing anymore ('cept for Nyquil, that still works ... )

The good ones are kept behind the counter, and you have to sign a form and provide identification to get them (they are meth precursors).

The problem is that it puts the onus on private businesses to notify consumers when they've exceeded their mandatory amount in a set timeframe. I can't imagine that 2 boxes in a week should be enough to set off this kind of response.

These laws were put into place because individuals were buying dozens of boxes on behalf of meth cookers, who then turned them into meth. Not because someone bought TWO boxes in a week.

I smell lucrative civil lawsuit.
 
The good ones are kept behind the counter, and you have to sign a form and provide identification to get them (they are meth precursors).

The problem is that it puts the onus on private businesses to notify consumers when they've exceeded their mandatory amount in a set timeframe. I can't imagine that 2 boxes in a week should be enough to set off this kind of response.

These laws were put into place because individuals were buying dozens of boxes on behalf of meth cookers, who then turned them into meth. Not because someone bought TWO boxes in a week.

I smell lucrative civil lawsuit.


I didn't know that about the good ones being kept behind the counter!
 
Re: Indiana Grandmother Jailed After Buying One Box Too Many of Cold Medicine

Brought to you by social conservatives! Thanks guys!
 
I didn't know that about the good ones being kept behind the counter!

They totally do. There is only one cold medicine that really works well for me, I think it's called pseudoephedrine. The others make me really loopy.

I guess I'm risking prosecution every time I seek out the good cold meds.
 
Brought to you by social conservatives! Thanks guys!

I dunno, I don't know many people who think that methamphetamine production in the U.S. should be encouraged. It's a pretty negative drug in every possible way, from the effects on users to the toxic residues left behind from cooking it.
 
They totally do. There is only one cold medicine that really works well for me, I think it's called pseudoephedrine. The others make me really loopy.

I guess I'm risking prosecution every time I seek out the good cold meds.

Pseudoephedrine (Sudafed/Wal-phed, etc) is totally awesome. It's the only thing that unstuffs my nose and if I take it with 1000 mg. of Tylenol, it totally knocks out my sinus headaches.

What happened to that woman is a miscarriage of justice, and whoever ordered her arrest really should be shot. :roll:
 
I'm not sure what her being a grandmother has to do with anything other than to paint a picture of her that didn't need painting. The arrest was absurd, but I'm sure she wasn't physically heaved into a jail cell the way the author pens it. The facts are scarey enough without the added drama.

In the 1980's, I had wild hair. I was a college student and was well aware that I looked like a party girl. I got this horrible cough that wouldn't go away, so the dr suggested I ask the pharmacist for something called terpenhydrate (sp?). My mother (bless her old heart) said they used to call that stuff "GI gin." :rofl

I was sick, so I'm sure I looked like heck when I asked the pharmacist for that stuff. He refused to sell it to me. My mother went over to the counter while I stood around the corner and asked for the same thing. He gave it to her.

I dunno. :shrug: I wasn't the least bit happy about it, but there's always been some crazy stuff surrounding cough medicines. While I don't agree with someone being arrested for buying cough medicine and subsequently have their name splashed in the news, it's something most of us are aware of and take precautions against.
 
Last edited:
Lock the old biddy up and throw away the key.
 
The whole clamping down on domestic manufacture of Meth has been a big factor in the current escalation of the Mexican drug wars. A lot of meth is now made in Mexico. Not that I'm in favor of meth, it's an absolute scourge.
 
Back
Top Bottom