• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Man Who Refuses to Pay Taxes Until Abortion Is Defunded Wins Huge Court Victory

Stealers Wheel

DP Veteran
Joined
Apr 5, 2018
Messages
10,713
Reaction score
10,786
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Slightly Liberal
Man Who Refuses to Pay Taxes Until Abortion Is Defunded Wins Court Victory

A Christian man who refuses to pay his taxes until the government stops funding abortion has won an historic lawsuit against the IRS.

Michael Bowman has refused to file a tax return or pay taxes since 1999. “I’m not a tax protester. I love my country,” he told reporters. “I have a duty to my country. I have a duty to my conscience.”

Lifesitenews.com reports: The IRS has sent him numerous warnings over unpaid taxes from 2002 to 2014, and in 2012 the Oregon Department of Revenue began garnishing money from Bowman’s bank account. In response, he started cashing out his paychecks and leaving only a minimum balance in his account.

This, federal prosecutors say, constituted “remov[ing] his income from the reach of taxing authorities.” They indicted him for felony tax evasion in the amount of $356,857, as well as four misdemeanor counts of willful failure to file tax returns.

Bowman’s attorney, Matthew Schindler, argued that his client was fully transparent every step of the way, from disclosing all of his paychecks to cashing them at his own bank, under his own name.

“Like a player collapsing as they lose Twister, the government has reached too far forward and stretched way too far back,” his motion to dismiss read.

Last week, US District Judge Michael Mosman sided with Bowman on the felony charge, ruling that the feds failed to show he attempted to conceal income or deceive the government. Prosecutors remain free to re-introduce the charge in the future, and are currently weighing whether to do so.

On Tuesday, Bowman elaborated on his stand in an interview with CBN News.

“First, I would love to pay taxes so as to have a normal life, however, our government is using the tax dollars to fund Planned Parenthood; which commits abortions – the death of the innocent,” Bowman said. “Apparently, a woman has the right to choose, but evidently, I do not.”

He also took aim at the common rejoinder that every American citizen has to pay taxes for things with which they might personally disagree, such as war. “You see, the Constitution grants certain abilities to the government, e.g. funding the military, but killing children is not a Constitutional backed, compelling interest of the government by any stretch of the imagination,” Bowman explained.

Planned Parenthood receives more than $500 million per year from the federal government, and performs more than 300,000 abortions. Federal law forbids taxpayer dollars from being directly spent on abortions, though pro-life groups argue that the money still enables abortion facilities to grow their reach and influence, and spend more revenue from other sources on abortions.

“All the government has to do is put a check box on the tax forms that says check here to support Planned Parenthood, and write in your donation amount,” Bowman proposed. “Then, just like any church or charity, Planned Parenthood will be funded by those that have no problem with it, and the 150 million people like me that are pro-life, can pay their taxes and live knowing we kept our conscience clean.”

He vowed that he will continue his resistance as long as the government continues funding the abortion industry.

“My effort [is] about standing up, standing firm for my Constitutional rights, and getting the government to honor title 42 Chapter 21.b The Religious Freedom Restoration Act, so that I may live a peaceful life, and in the end face God, and hopefully have Him say, ‘Well done, good and faithful servant!” he said.

I knew it would eventually come to this. Refusing to comply with the law on religious grounds started a while back with courts ruling that religious bigotry trumps civil rights. This guy has a deeply held belief that paying taxes is an abomination in the eyes of God.

I'm gonna join his church and save a fortune.
 
Man Who Refuses to Pay Taxes Until Abortion Is Defunded Wins Court Victory



I knew it would eventually come to this. Refusing to comply with the law on religious grounds started a while back with courts ruling that religious bigotry trumps civil rights. This guy has a deeply held belief that paying taxes is an abomination in the eyes of God.

I'm gonna join his church and save a fortune.

This is really dumb. I also refuse to pay taxes on grounds that my tax dollars go towards bombing people in 3rd world countries and my religion prohibits that.
 
Man Who Refuses to Pay Taxes Until Abortion Is Defunded Wins Court Victory



I knew it would eventually come to this. Refusing to comply with the law on religious grounds started a while back with courts ruling that religious bigotry trumps civil rights. This guy has a deeply held belief that paying taxes is an abomination in the eyes of God.

I'm gonna join his church and save a fortune.

1) This started in 1999, well before any of the "court rulings" you reference (and mischaracterize).

2) The ruling here had nothing whatsoever to do with religious exemptions to anything.
 
This is not going to win much further. There is no way that this will fly. For one thing, the federal government does not have to spend federal money to aid others overseas (which could be argued as overreaching). Also, it is only his opinion that this is not in the interest of the government to fund such programs. What would prevent a person against federal funds towards education in using such an argument? Or someone against supporting certain businesses, including farmers or other failing businesses? Or federal funding for the space program (not required for national security)? Or a border wall (again, definitely not required for national security)?
 
I knew it would eventually come to this. Refusing to comply with the law on religious grounds started a while back with courts ruling that religious bigotry trumps civil rights. This guy has a deeply held belief that paying taxes is an abomination in the eyes of God.

I'm gonna join his church and save a fortune.

Well if I ever decided to murder my family I'll make sure to claim that honor killings are part of my deeply held religious beliefs.

Nope. Sorry, your religion does not permit you to blatantly ignore the law. You can't start the church of speeding so you can get to work faster. You have a right to worship your god in the comfort of your own home or church, but when your religious beliefs start to impact the lives of other people around you in a negative way the laws of the land override your silly faith.
 
Man Who Refuses to Pay Taxes Until Abortion Is Defunded Wins Court Victory



I knew it would eventually come to this. Refusing to comply with the law on religious grounds started a while back with courts ruling that religious bigotry trumps civil rights. This guy has a deeply held belief that paying taxes is an abomination in the eyes of God.

I'm gonna join his church and save a fortune.

What you might save in taxes will be largely offset by attorney's fees, good luck.

I would like to do the same thing the man did regarding taxes going to the war on terror, not declared in accordance with Constitutional requirements.
 
2) The ruling here had nothing whatsoever to do with religious exemptions to anything.
Yes, more people need to understand the court did not rule he did not have to pay taxes because of religious beliefs.
 
The clock is ticking......


The charge was dismissed without prejudice, meaning prosecutors could seek a new indictment. Assistant U.S Attorney Donna Maddux said the government is considering options.

Bowman still faces four misdemeanor counts of willful failure to file tax returns.
 
Well if I ever decided to murder my family I'll make sure to claim that honor killings are part of my deeply held religious beliefs.

Nope. Sorry, your religion does not permit you to blatantly ignore the law. You can't start the church of speeding so you can get to work faster. You have a right to worship your god in the comfort of your own home or church, but when your religious beliefs start to impact the lives of other people around you in a negative way the laws of the land override your silly faith.

This is exactly what the USSC has ruled. If you or your corporation has a deeply held religious belief, you and/or your corporation are exempt from complying with law that offends that belief.

In Burwell v. Hobby Lobby, the court held that the HHS contraception mandate substantially burdens the exercise of religion.

The Religious Freedom Restoration Act of 1993 (RFRA) prohibits the
“Government [from] substantially burden[ing] a person’s exercise of
religion even if the burden results from a rule of general applicability”

Therefore, the burden is now on the government to prove that forcing someone to pay taxes over their religious objection "(1) is in furtherance of a compelling governmental interest; and (2) is the least restrictive means of furthering that compelling governmental interest.”
 
The judge just killed the felony charge, they will simply garnish his wages, meaning he will lose in the long run, even bankruptcy does not kill off the debt. Just so ya know...
 
This is really dumb. I also refuse to pay taxes on grounds that my tax dollars go towards bombing people in 3rd world countries and my religion prohibits that.

It will be appealed and he will lose. This is a regular occurrence. Religious beliefs may not be used to avoid paying taxes.
 
Man Who Refuses to Pay Taxes Until Abortion Is Defunded Wins Court Victory



I knew it would eventually come to this. Refusing to comply with the law on religious grounds started a while back with courts ruling that religious bigotry trumps civil rights. This guy has a deeply held belief that paying taxes is an abomination in the eyes of God.

I'm gonna join his church and save a fortune.
Couldnt you at least TRY to make a coherent argument without lying? Is your position THAT pathetic?
 
This is really dumb. I also refuse to pay taxes on grounds that my tax dollars go towards bombing people in 3rd world countries and my religion prohibits that.
You have an argument the moment you disclose your voting record. If you have voted for a democrat that supported the war in Iraq or any democrat that supported Bill Clintons military actions and you voted for Obama then your argument is tossed on the scrapheap...because you actually VOTE and support people that bombed people in 3rd world countries.
 
Man Who Refuses to Pay Taxes Until Abortion Is Defunded Wins Court Victory



I knew it would eventually come to this. Refusing to comply with the law on religious grounds started a while back with courts ruling that religious bigotry trumps civil rights. This guy has a deeply held belief that paying taxes is an abomination in the eyes of God.

I'm gonna join his church and save a fortune.

The guy's religious belief had nothing to do with the ruling of that court. Stop being dishonest.
 
This is really dumb. I also refuse to pay taxes on grounds that my tax dollars go towards bombing people in 3rd world countries and my religion prohibits that.

You obviously did not read the article. Even Bowman discounts what you said in that article.

He also took aim at the common rejoinder that every American citizen has to pay taxes for things with which they might personally disagree, such as war. “You see, the Constitution grants certain abilities to the government, e.g. funding the military, but killing children is not a Constitutional backed, compelling interest of the government by any stretch of the imagination,” Bowman explained.

And again, the ruling of the court had nothing to do with Bowman's religion.
 
You have an argument the moment you disclose your voting record. If you have voted for a democrat that supported the war in Iraq or any democrat that supported Bill Clintons military actions and you voted for Obama then your argument is tossed on the scrapheap...because you actually VOTE and support people that bombed people in 3rd world countries.

The first time I voted for Democrats was last November. Always been a Green Party voter. Just voted straight ticket Democrat in MI for the first time last November. The GOP scared me into the arms of the Dems, lol.
 
You obviously did not read the article. Even Bowman discounts what you said in that article.



And again, the ruling of the court had nothing to do with Bowman's religion.

The guy who thinks it's a good idea to not pay taxes because God, that's dumb.
 
The first time I voted for Democrats was last November. Always been a Green Party voter. Just voted straight ticket Democrat in MI for the first time last November. The GOP scared me into the arms of the Dems, lol.
Riiiiiiiiiight

Really? what scared you into the arms of the democrats? The booming and robust economy? The actions against illegal immigrants supported until only recently BY democrats? The fact that the last democrat president didnt just bomb third world countries but INCREASED the rate of bombings?

Always curious about what causes people like you such 'fear' and cowardice that it would inspire you to compromise your values and stance.
 
Riiiiiiiiiight

Really? what scared you into the arms of the democrats? The booming and robust economy? The actions against illegal immigrants supported until only recently BY democrats? The fact that the last democrat president didnt just bomb third world countries but INCREASED the rate of bombings?

Always curious about what causes people like you such 'fear' and cowardice that it would inspire you to compromise your values and stance.

My hatred of the GOP grew in the past couple years. The Obama drone strikes, Libya, bombing wedding caravans as an oopsie. Yeah, that's a big reason why I never supported Democrats. However, the Trump administration is too grotesque to stomach. I really disagree with a lot of his appointments. Scott Pruitt, Wilbur Ross, Betsy DeVos, all slimeballs who are there to serve special interests, not the people. And it's fun watching Trump's wounded narcissism when he lost big last November.
 
My hatred of the GOP grew in the past couple years. The Obama drone strikes, Libya, bombing wedding caravans as an oopsie. Yeah, that's a big reason why I never supported Democrats. However, the Trump administration is too grotesque to stomach. I really disagree with a lot of his appointments. Scott Pruitt, Wilbur Ross, Betsy DeVos, all slimeballs who are there to serve special interests, not the people. And it's fun watching Trump's wounded narcissism when he lost big last November.
"hatred'. Thats....pathetic.

But all you have is rhetoric. What have they DONE to deserve your hatred? Take Betsy Devos for example. Specifically...what has she done in office that you disapprove of?
 
Man Who Refuses to Pay Taxes Until Abortion Is Defunded Wins Court Victory



I knew it would eventually come to this. Refusing to comply with the law on religious grounds started a while back with courts ruling that religious bigotry trumps civil rights. This guy has a deeply held belief that paying taxes is an abomination in the eyes of God.

I'm gonna join his church and save a fortune.

Good man with a non-traditional way to resist government funding of unborn baby murder. The democrats are doing everything they can to stop Trump and this man is making great headway resisting government funding of infanticide. God bless him.
 
Newsflash ya dumb cluck...Jesus made it clear...paying taxes is a Christian obligation...

"He said to them: “Whose image and inscription is this?” They said: “Caesar’s.” Then he said to them: “Pay back, therefore, Caesar’s things to Caesar, but God’s things to God.” Matthew 22:20,21
 
"hatred'. Thats....pathetic.

But all you have is rhetoric. What have they DONE to deserve your hatred? Take Betsy Devos for example. Specifically...what has she done in office that you disapprove of?

She is corrupt. She uses her position to further enrich herself and her friends.

Investigations Into For-Profit College Abuses Dismantled Under Betsy DeVos
Look at this story from last year:

The Department of Education “has effectively killed investigations” into possible fraud at several prominent for-profit colleges, according to the New York Times.

These for-profit colleges, the paper reported, are places where the leading hires of Education Secretary Betsy DeVos used to work.

Investigators at a special team at the Education Department have been reassigned, sidelined or told to concentrate on other work, current and former employees told the Times. The department has been whittled down from more than a dozen to just three people, who have been assigned to paperwork regarding student loan forgiveness.
 
Man Who Refuses to Pay Taxes Until Abortion Is Defunded Wins Court Victory

I knew it would eventually come to this. Refusing to comply with the law on religious grounds started a while back with courts ruling that religious bigotry trumps civil rights. This guy has a deeply held belief that paying taxes is an abomination in the eyes of God.

I'm gonna join his church and save a fortune.

The hilarious part of your bigoted rant is that the Religious Freedom Restoration Act was passed by your buddy, Schumer, and signed into law by Bill. It was a leftist bill that ended up providing something good in the end, for once.
 
She is corrupt. She uses her position to further enrich herself and her friends.

Investigations Into For-Profit College Abuses Dismantled Under Betsy DeVos
Look at this story from last year:

Right. So because she once worked for a for profit university you believe that influenced that decision..and that makes her evil and worthy of hatred. You dont mention the pioneering of school choice and school voucher programs which have created gateways to successs for hundreds of thousands of inner city kids trapped in otherwise failing schools. Or the charter school system which has similarly been credited as provided much greater graduation rates and college opportunites for inner city kids-in some places allowing the entire graduating class to both receive scholarships and attend college. Or the funding of scholarships.

She is evil...because progs told you so.

****, it must suck living life on strings.
 
Back
Top Bottom