• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

“Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white suprem

Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

It's all Excuses, Explanations, Fun and Games ... Until its done to you or someone you love.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

https://shareblue.com/hung-from-a-t...alls-for-lynching-critics-of-white-supremacy/

Critics demand Missouri lawmaker resign after saying vandals should be 'hung from a tall tree with a long rope' | Political Fix | stltoday.com

Missouri lawmaker posts hope that monument vandal be 'hung' | Nation | stltoday.com



So over the past few weeks there have been many arguments about how antifa are just as bad as white supremacists. Many of the equivocations point to the fact that both are just fringe extremist groups.

Aside from the fact that we have seen many Charlottesville marchers associating with Republican senators, we now get actual sitting representatives ultimately calling for the lynching of those who would deface statues. Maybe you disagree, but to me, calling for lynchings in Missouri carries certain race connotations with it. As the article states, it's a terrorist act specifically associated with white supremacists and the KKK.

Of course, he 'denies' that's what he meant.



But the issue still remains - this kind of sentiment, the sentiment that I would expect from white supremacists, is something that pervades American society at every level to a far greater degree than the rhetoric of antifa. This is exactly why the threat posed to Americans by white supremacist far outweigh the threat posed by Antifa or BLM. There exist people in power structures who hold biases that align with those of white supremacy.

To add, I don't think there is an excuse for violence but this is also a key reason why those who try to fight oppression often turn to violence. It's much harder for a group like BLM to make change within the confines of the law when there are people like this who help control the law.

Of course, this is simply the actions of one man, but it's one man who holds a fair amount of power, and it's indicative of a far more deep rooted problem.

Soooooo, where's your thread about the Missouri state senator who called for Trump's assassination?
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

is something that pervades American society at every level to a far greater degree than the rhetoric of antifa

Is this supposed to be ironic? Currently, academia and media are swarming with people who are far to the left (some of them even Marxists, literally). There is no mainstream figure who is a white supremacist. It blows my mind how someone can, with a straight face, say that white supremacy is currently more prevalent than radical Progressivism, Marxism, and anarchism.

Even if it were, it is completely the fault of the left. This progressive bull**** where you shame and bash the other side and play identity politics has shifted the Overton window so much that people now think views like this are somewhat acceptable. Irrationality is being answer with irrationality and for some reason this surprises people.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

https://shareblue.com/hung-from-a-t...alls-for-lynching-critics-of-white-supremacy/

Critics demand Missouri lawmaker resign after saying vandals should be 'hung from a tall tree with a long rope' | Political Fix | stltoday.com

Missouri lawmaker posts hope that monument vandal be 'hung' | Nation | stltoday.com



So over the past few weeks there have been many arguments about how antifa are just as bad as white supremacists. Many of the equivocations point to the fact that both are just fringe extremist groups.

Aside from the fact that we have seen many Charlottesville marchers associating with Republican senators, we now get actual sitting representatives ultimately calling for the lynching of those who would deface statues. Maybe you disagree, but to me, calling for lynchings in Missouri carries certain race connotations with it. As the article states, it's a terrorist act specifically associated with white supremacists and the KKK.

Of course, he 'denies' that's what he meant.



But the issue still remains - this kind of sentiment, the sentiment that I would expect from white supremacists, is something that pervades American society at every level to a far greater degree than the rhetoric of antifa. This is exactly why the threat posed to Americans by white supremacist far outweigh the threat posed by Antifa or BLM. There exist people in power structures who hold biases that align with those of white supremacy.

To add, I don't think there is an excuse for violence but this is also a key reason why those who try to fight oppression often turn to violence. It's much harder for a group like BLM to make change within the confines of the law when there are people like this who help control the law.

Of course, this is simply the actions of one man, but it's one man who holds a fair amount of power, and it's indicative of a far more deep rooted problem.

Do you support vandalism?
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

So yes???

Also how does 'hang from tree with rope' not elicit associations to lynching??

Because hanging used to be legal.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

https://shareblue.com/hung-from-a-t...alls-for-lynching-critics-of-white-supremacy/

Critics demand Missouri lawmaker resign after saying vandals should be 'hung from a tall tree with a long rope' | Political Fix | stltoday.com

Missouri lawmaker posts hope that monument vandal be 'hung' | Nation | stltoday.com



So over the past few weeks there have been many arguments about how antifa are just as bad as white supremacists. Many of the equivocations point to the fact that both are just fringe extremist groups.

Aside from the fact that we have seen many Charlottesville marchers associating with Republican senators, we now get actual sitting representatives ultimately calling for the lynching of those who would deface statues. Maybe you disagree, but to me, calling for lynchings in Missouri carries certain race connotations with it. As the article states, it's a terrorist act specifically associated with white supremacists and the KKK.

Of course, he 'denies' that's what he meant.



But the issue still remains - this kind of sentiment, the sentiment that I would expect from white supremacists, is something that pervades American society at every level to a far greater degree than the rhetoric of antifa. This is exactly why the threat posed to Americans by white supremacist far outweigh the threat posed by Antifa or BLM. There exist people in power structures who hold biases that align with those of white supremacy.

To add, I don't think there is an excuse for violence but this is also a key reason why those who try to fight oppression often turn to violence. It's much harder for a group like BLM to make change within the confines of the law when there are people like this who help control the law.

Of course, this is simply the actions of one man, but it's one man who holds a fair amount of power, and it's indicative of a far more deep rooted problem.

BLM could do more within the black community to make change there.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

He wasn't literally calling for the lynching of anyone, any more than Leonard Freeman, Ted Post, and Clint Eastwood were:

MPW-24962

Didn't they hang a lot of people in that movie?
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

What "sentiment," specifically, do you have in mind here? Specifically?



I don't think it quite rises to the level of the Missouri state senator who recently tweeted that she hopes Trump is assassinated. This guy was using a turn of phrase. She was quite literal.

Yes, it does at that. Calling for multiple murders.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

Yes, it does at that. Calling for multiple murders.

You guys are going waaaaaay out of your way to get that from what he said.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

You guys are going waaaaaay out of your way to get that from what he said.

Regardless, he was wrong, just as tat other one calling for Trump to be assassinated was wrong. thing is both are despicable. No party crap here, both are despicable
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

Regardless, he was wrong, just as tat other one calling for Trump to be assassinated was wrong. thing is both are despicable. No party crap here, both are despicable

He said that people vandalizing public property should be found and punished. He said it hyperbolically, but the idea is certainly not despicable. The one who said she hopes he's assassinated said it and meant it literally.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

He said that people vandalizing public property should be found and punished. He said it hyperbolically, but the idea is certainly not despicable. The one who said she hopes he's assassinated said it and meant it literally.

Did he state hung from a tall tree?? He then back tracked on this blaming it on watching to many westerns.
Is that correct?
Critics demand Missouri lawmaker resign after saying vandals should be 'hung from a tall tree with a long rope' | Political Fix | stltoday.com
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

Dude. He did not mean it literally.

It should have been "a short rope". Hang me from the highest tree (-roger Miller), but use a rope twice a long. -me

Life must be really hard for those Ozarkians.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

Dude. He did not mean it literally.

Comments like that just inflame a situation. Man is an idiot
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

Comments like that just inflame a situation. Man is an idiot

Well maybe the sheep need to stop being over reactionary dweebs, lol.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

https://shareblue.com/hung-from-a-t...alls-for-lynching-critics-of-white-supremacy/

Critics demand Missouri lawmaker resign after saying vandals should be 'hung from a tall tree with a long rope' | Political Fix | stltoday.com

Missouri lawmaker posts hope that monument vandal be 'hung' | Nation | stltoday.com



So over the past few weeks there have been many arguments about how antifa are just as bad as white supremacists. Many of the equivocations point to the fact that both are just fringe extremist groups.

Aside from the fact that we have seen many Charlottesville marchers associating with Republican senators, we now get actual sitting representatives ultimately calling for the lynching of those who would deface statues. Maybe you disagree, but to me, calling for lynchings in Missouri carries certain race connotations with it. As the article states, it's a terrorist act specifically associated with white supremacists and the KKK.

Of course, he 'denies' that's what he meant.



But the issue still remains - this kind of sentiment, the sentiment that I would expect from white supremacists, is something that pervades American society at every level to a far greater degree than the rhetoric of antifa. This is exactly why the threat posed to Americans by white supremacist far outweigh the threat posed by Antifa or BLM. There exist people in power structures who hold biases that align with those of white supremacy.

To add, I don't think there is an excuse for violence but this is also a key reason why those who try to fight oppression often turn to violence. It's much harder for a group like BLM to make change within the confines of the law when there are people like this who help control the law.

Of course, this is simply the actions of one man, but it's one man who holds a fair amount of power, and it's indicative of a far more deep rooted problem.

The whole article is indicative of the times as I look at it.
There is nothing wrong with someone mentioning such a punishment for such crimes as assaulting someone over a difference of opinion, or for defacing a monument that people may hold dear. They are criminals, and there was a time in history when such a treatment of the same kind of criminal was necessary. Its common knowledge to anyone who went through history class that such a thing happened.

Yes it was barbaric, and uncivilized, but so were those times. I think it makes a statement that if such a group of terrorist are willing to be so barbaric in their actions. That they should be ready for such a response in kind, and I honestly don't care how the sentiment hurts someone else's sensibilities.

The fact they are digging so hard to get a racist meaning out of what he said, is proof that they are trying to ruin him. Despite the fact of him saying something questionable or not, this amount of political spin has no place here.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

Comments like that just inflame a situation. Man is an idiot

Gross overreactions do, too. Climb down.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

I'm not sure why you don't quite get the old trope in Westerns of forming a posse, finding the bad guys, bringing them to face justice, and then hanging them.

Lmao, I've heard a lot of stupid argument on this forum, but this is a new one. Yup, telling people you'll hang them for perceived insults to confederate icons is a Western movie trope!
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

I think it should be "hanged" from a tall tree.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

Lmao, I've heard a lot of stupid argument on this forum, but this is a new one. Yup, telling people you'll hang them for perceived insults to confederate icons is a Western movie trope!

:shrug: People unable to understand metaphors often reflexively call them "stupid," rather than accept they just don't get it. Run along, now.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

:shrug: People unable to understand metaphors often reflexively call them "stupid," rather than accept they just don't get it. Run along, now.

Watching you conflate comparisons with metaphors just solidifies my statement. Yes, it was stupid for you to claim it as, there is no such movie trope as hanging people for trying to destroy/remove confederate icons.

This is a racist trope.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

:shrug: People unable to understand metaphors often reflexively call them "stupid," rather than accept they just don't get it. Run along, now.

I laugh at this though, 'you're calling my arguments stupid because you don't understand them'! No Harshaw, sometimes things are just stupid. Saying that this guy was just using a Western movie metaphor is stupid because there is no such movie trope as hanging people for trying to remove confederate iconography.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

Watching you conflate comparisons with metaphors just solidifies my statement. Yes, it was stupid for you to claim it as, there is no such movie trope as hanging people for trying to destroy/remove confederate icons.

This is a racist trope.

I laugh at this though, 'you're calling my arguments stupid because you don't understand them'! No Harshaw, sometimes things are just stupid. Saying that this guy was just using a Western movie metaphor is stupid because there is no such movie trope as hanging people for trying to remove confederate iconography.

:yawn: It's not I who apparently doesn't recognize a metaphor when he reads one, or doesn't want people to think he does.

Try harder next time. Bye, now.
 
Re: “Hung from a tall tree”: Second Republican calls for lynching critics of white su

Well maybe the sheep need to stop being over reactionary dweebs, lol.

As I said, no need for commentary of his type.
 
Back
Top Bottom