• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms[W:169]

Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

I don't even like going into the unisex bathrooms. Let me guess, this change is to accommodate one person?!

Have you seen those PC U.S. Navy gender friendly commodes yet ?
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

And your argument requires that the casual observer ignore his or her intellect. ;)

Pot meet kettle. Basically I am saying that you are making an argument that just because people believe something against what you believe that it must be nonsense. This is all before we look at the various actual physical and genetic possibility that could cause such a body/internal image conflict. AIS, Chimerism and many other conditions can cause a body to develop differently from the mind. When you have an XY person born with a vagina, is it really wrong from them to want to get the Addadictomy operation? I forget the name, but it's been mentioned in other transsexual/intersex threads where a YY person is born with a penis and testicles, or at least a scrotum. The "balls" are still actually gonads, not having developed. So why shouldn't they want to have the removal operation? And what of the people who actually contain 2 or more sets of DNA? If the mind develops off one gender and the body off the other, which one is right? Both developed according to their blueprints? And before you go off on how rare these things are, how many cases of people claiming GID can you show what the genetic make up is? Answer is none, short of it being part of an article where the person themselves bother to share the info. So you don't know that it is an XY person who is wanting the removal of the penis or an YY person wanting one added.
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

I wish I had a 5 foot long penis, was a dragon with a unicorn wife, could fly through air and space, had a lifetime supply of srirachi. And some people wish they were a girl. Everyone should just work with me and pretend I have a 5 foot penis, am a dragon, have a unicorn wife, can fly, and am the go-to guy for chinese hotsauce.

What IS the best brand of chinese hotsauce?
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

Have you seen those PC U.S. Navy gender friendly commodes yet ?

Honestly, for someone who'll almost certainly never use one, you are absolutely obsessed with the navy's toilets.

As someone who has used one and might do so again in the future, all I have to say is they are probably a hell of a lot better than a funnel, something I saw many a male sailor using while on the carrier, despite having a urinal in the space that normally wasn't in use at those times.
 
Last edited:
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

Why would you want to? If administrators truely believe that these boys are really girls than there should be no need to separate them. This is where the rubber meets the road. If we are going to accept that boys who identify as girls are really girl with a dick, than let them shower with your daughter. If it makes you uncomfortable than you are lying to yourself about where you actually stand on politics vs reality. Not meaning you specifically, iangb, just generally. Building different facilities admits that they are not girls.
I am basing my suggestion on the common beleif, as demonstrated by many people in this thread including the OP, that having trans kids showering with cis kids of a different birth gender would make people uncomfortable. It wouldn't particularly bother me (no more, at least, than enforced communal nudity of children does!) but I realise not everyone shares this opinion. As such, I offer a compromise which would make things OK for both sides of the argument.

In a world of differing opinions, compromise is important.
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

I am basing my suggestion on the common beleif, as demonstrated by many people in this thread including the OP, that having trans kids showering with cis kids of a different birth gender would make people uncomfortable. It wouldn't particularly bother me (no more, at least, than enforced communal nudity of children does!) but I realise not everyone shares this opinion. As such, I offer a compromise which would make things OK for both sides of the argument.

In a world of differing opinions, compromise is important.

One important thing though: the proposed rule change would not have any one showering with any one. The whole story is bogus and the proposed rule change only has to do with who may participate in what sport.
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

One important thing though: the proposed rule change would not have any one showering with any one. The whole story is bogus and the proposed rule change only has to do with who may participate in what sport.

Agreed - it was a response to the hype rather than the story itself.
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

So you're ok with teenage boys with feminine behaviors showering with your daughter?

They could scrub each others backs. We could have the football team helping out the cheerleaders after practice. :roll: Imagine the number of gay football players we'll have after this.
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

I am basing my suggestion on the common beleif, as demonstrated by many people in this thread including the OP, that having trans kids showering with cis kids of a different birth gender would make people uncomfortable. It wouldn't particularly bother me (no more, at least, than enforced communal nudity of children does!) but I realise not everyone shares this opinion. As such, I offer a compromise which would make things OK for both sides of the argument.

In a world of differing opinions, compromise is important.

Do you have children of your own? Daughters perhaps?
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

Honestly, for someone who'll almost certainly never use one, you are absolutely obsessed with the navy's toilets.

As someone who has used one and might do so again in the future, all I have to say is they are probably a hell of a lot better than a funnel, something I saw many a male sailor using while on the carrier, despite having a urinal in the space that normally wasn't in use at those times.


Now this is what real warships have for crappers.


red toilet seat.jpg

And as any real sailor knows, when in rough seas, don't use the seats an either end. :lol:
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

Now this is what real warships have for crappers.


View attachment 67176083

And as any real sailor knows, when in rough seas, don't use the seats an either end. :lol:

Greetings, APACHERAT. :2wave:

Have you taken the "What general you would be" test yet? I'm curious....
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

The world keeps spinning around and keeps getting crazy. After one of the schools allowed a transgender teen (who hasn’t had the surgery yet) to use girl’s toilet, now in Minnesota they consider a possibility of allowing transgenders to use the shower together with the sex they identify themselves.
And while boys might even welcome such changes, I’m not sure that girls or their parents would be extremely glad to see a boy in the girl’s locker.
Seriously, why some doubtful need of one or two people is prevailing over the needs and rights of other people? Give them their own locker, everybody would be happy.
This is why local elections are just as important or more important than federal elections.
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

They could scrub each others backs. We could have the football team helping out the cheerleaders after practice. :roll: Imagine the number of gay football players we'll have after this.

And once more ignorance rears its moronic head. You are obviously clueless on the difference between trans and gay. A gay male still identifies as male and thus would be in the men's locker room/bathroom. Transsexual has nothing to do with what gender the person is attracted to but how they see themselves.

Do you have children of your own? Daughters perhaps?

Why the hell do people keep bringing up the question of if people who support such concepts as allowing trans to use the facilities of their identity have daughters? First off the sexism of never asking if they have sons is just blinding. Secondly why trans girl (i.e. physical male body) be any more of a "threat" to my daughter than a homosexual girl would be?
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

And once more ignorance rears its moronic head. You are obviously clueless on the difference between trans and gay. A gay male still identifies as male and thus would be in the men's locker room/bathroom. Transsexual has nothing to do with what gender the person is attracted to but how they see themselves.



Why the hell do people keep bringing up the question of if people who support such concepts as allowing trans to use the facilities of their identity have daughters? First off the sexism of never asking if they have sons is just blinding. Secondly why trans girl (i.e. physical male body) be any more of a "threat" to my daughter than a homosexual girl would be?

Obviously you didn't get the tongue in cheek, are you gay or something, sounds like you're taking this personally.
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

And once more ignorance rears its moronic head. You are obviously clueless on the difference between trans and gay. A gay male still identifies as male and thus would be in the men's locker room/bathroom. Transsexual has nothing to do with what gender the person is attracted to but how they see themselves.



Why the hell do people keep bringing up the question of if people who support such concepts as allowing trans to use the facilities of their identity have daughters? First off the sexism of never asking if they have sons is just blinding. Secondly why trans girl (i.e. physical male body) be any more of a "threat" to my daughter than a homosexual girl would be?


Thank you. Yes, Transgender is one thing; being gay/lesbian is another. And trans people may be attracted to people of their prior gender or to those of their new gender. Or both. Just like the rest of us.

And yes, why is it everyone shudders at their daughters showering with boys but not their sons showering with girls? do they know how cruel girls can be? It is very sexist.

And at any rate - the story has nothing to do with showers.
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

Moderator's Warning:
Let's not make this personal folks. Stick to the topic, not the posters.
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

Why not girls?

If a kid is trans (and there'll have to be evidence, reports and assessments) they're not sexually interested in people who identify as the same gender.

Actually that isn't true. Someone can be trans and still like the opposite or same sex. Gender identification does not determine sexual preference.
I know of 2 transsexuals that were male and now are female (1 surgically the other still in transition) and they both like females. One of them is even still living with her girlfriend who stayed with them even though they started dating when he was "male".
 
Re: Schools propose: Let boys into girls locker rooms

Obviously you didn't get the tongue in cheek, are you gay or something, sounds like you're taking this personally.

Tounge in cheek is not obvious in written posts. Without some kind of indicator, one shouldn't be surprised it was missed. No can't be gay since I like women so much. Might be bi but I've yet to find the man to tempt me. However, I have many homosexual, and transsexual friends, so yeah these topics do hit close to home.
 
Back
Top Bottom