• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Bloomberg Wouldn't Let National Guard Into Brooklyn Over Their Possession of Guns

This just keeps getting better and better. Incredible!
 
When I google this, all I get is right-wing sites.

Can I get a link from AP, or PBS?
 
I found out I can get the text-only cache.

Borough President Markowitz and Mayor Bloomberg at odds over National Guard response for Hurricane Sandy • The <b style="color:black;background-color:#ffff66">Brooklyn</b> Paper

Mayor Bloomberg has snubbed Borough President Markowitz’s impassioned plea to bring the National Guard to Hurricane Sandy-scarred Brooklyn — arguing that approving the Beep’s request would be a waste of federal manpower and turn the borough into a police state.

“We don’t need it,” Mayor Bloomberg said on Wednesday during a press update on the city’s ongoing Hurricane Sandy cleanup. “The NYPD is the only people we want on the street with guns.”

Markowitz demanded the National Guard’s help just an hour before Bloomberg’s press conference, claiming that the NYPD and FDNY are “brave — but overwhelmed” by all the challenges Sandy brought when it visited the borough on Monday night: flooding, power outages, and looting.

“All of our resources have been stretched to the limit,” Markowitz said. “In the name of public safety we need to send more National Guard personnel into Coney Island, Manhattan Beach, Gerritsen Beach, Red Hook, and any other locations.”

Markowitz hopes that the sight of an armed soldier would deter criminal activity in the still-unaccessible evacuation zones — such as the rash of break-ins that took place in Coney Island hours after Sandy kissed the borough goodbye — but the Mayor said the NYPD was more than capable of handling the job.

“There are plenty of locations upstate and in surrounding states where they don’t have a police department the size of New York and they can use help [from the National Guard],” said Bloomberg.

Markowitz said he was surprised by the Mayor’s response, but was sticking to his guns.

“We stand by our statement 100 percent,” said Markowitz spokesman John Hill. “We hope the governor will listen to our request.”

The two politicians, who are both in their final terms, often appear together at borough events — but this is not the first time they’ve been at odds.

Markowitz slammed Bloomberg’s decision over a taxi manufacturer — and move Markowitz said would cost the borough an 800 job auto plant — in 2011, and the Mayor has vocally disagreed with Markowitz’s push for casino gambling in Coney Island.

Calls to Gov. Cuomo’s office for comment on Markowitz’s National Guard request were not returned by our midnight deadline.
 
Who said that?

Sounds like somebody is trying to shut it down.

Your previous statement sounds pretty absolute and pre-determined. There could be a number of reasons, most likely lag, perhaps server problems associated with being in an area that has just been hit by a massive storm system. But instead you automatically assume that an individual or group is attempting to remove the site. I question why you are so quick to make such a claim when so little facts are present.
 
Thursday Report: Bloomberg Wouldn't Let Guard Into Brooklyn Over Their Possession of Guns | NewsBusters.org

If he was doing this to protect people from tyranny, ala New Orleans gun grabbing, I would agree. But that definitely isn't his motivation.

If the story is being reported accurately, then this is pretty damning, but not the least bit surprising, given that this is New York, after all.

Mayor Bloomberg has snubbed Borough President Markowitz’s impassioned plea to bring the National Guard to Hurricane Sandy-scarred Brooklyn — arguing that approving the Beep’s request would be a waste of federal manpower and turn the borough into a police state.

“We don’t need it,” Mayor Bloomberg said on Wednesday during a press update on the city’s ongoing Hurricane Sandy cleanup. “The NYPD is the only people we want on the street with guns.”

A perfect expression, here, of Bloombergian idiocy: In order to prevent the area from becoming a “police state”, he wants only the local police to be armed.
 
Last edited:
Your previous statement sounds pretty absolute and pre-determined. There could be a number of reasons, most likely lag, perhaps server problems associated with being in an area that has just been hit by a massive storm system. But instead you automatically assume that an individual or group is attempting to remove the site. I question why you are so quick to make such a claim when so little facts are present.

This is a non issue.
 
Interesting, thank you.

This is just speculation, but I believe the context of the comments (if they were indeed made at all), was that Bloomberg didn't want additional National Guard members to police looters. It wasn't a blanket denial.
 
This is just speculation, but I believe the context of the comments (if they were indeed made at all), was that Bloomberg didn't want additional National Guard members to police looters. It wasn't a blanket denial.

That would fit in, but for now, I'll withhold judgement until a clearer picture presents itself.
 
Didn't happen. Anything reported by Newsbusters can, usually, be dismissed as extreme rightwing lies, anyhow.
 
NYPD has a high corruption rate, I'd trust the NG over them any day.
 
As usual, "I don't dig the news, so it must be a lie".

I seriously doubt that Daily KOS is going to report anything that might make The One look bad.

Submitted for your approval, a list of National Guard aid operations in response to Sandy, several of which are/were in Brooklyn:

Defense.gov News Article: DOD Provides Update for Hurricane Sandy Response

As well as photographic evidence of NG members in Brooklyn:

Twitter / demetria_g: National Guard troops direct ...

There you go adpst
 
Back
Top Bottom