• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Sotomayor draws praise from GOP critics

tlmorg02

DP Veteran
Joined
Nov 27, 2007
Messages
3,347
Reaction score
1,078
Location
Louisville, Ky
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Slightly Liberal
Sotomayor draws praise from GOP critics - Yahoo! News

WASHINGTON – Supreme Court nominee Sonia Sotomayor drew praise from GOP skeptics as well as Democratic supporters Thursday on the final day of Senate questioning that's expected to lead to her confirmation.

Sen. Lindsey Graham, R-S.C., described Sotomayor's judicial record as "generally in the mainstream" and said he thought she would keep an open mind on gun rights. He proclaimed her "not an activist."

Graham, who earlier predicted Sotomayor would be confirmed barring a "meltdown," said the 55-year-old appeals court judge had "said some things that just bug the hell out of me," but he added that he thought she could separate those views from her job as a justice.

"You have been very reassuring here today and throughout this hearing that you're going to try to understand the difference between judging and whatever political feelings you have about groups or gender," Graham said.

Sotomayor, President Barack Obama's choice to become the first Hispanic woman on the court, was on her third and final day of questioning, having avoided taking clear stands under repeated prodding on a range of hot-button issues, from campaign finance law to guns and abortion.

Graham was not in the Senate when Sotomayor was confirmed for the appeals court in 1998, but several other Republican senators were.

Among them, Sens. Robert Bennett of Utah, Thad Cochran of Mississippi, Susan Collins of Maine, Judd Gregg of New Hampshire, Orrin Hatch of Utah, Richard Lugar of Indiana and Olympia Snowe of Maine all voted in favor of her confirmation.

Apparently, she isn't the racist activist that many have made her out to be. Thoughts?
 
Last edited:
So this is really the best candidate we could find to serve on the Supreme Court.......really?

LOL
 
So this is really the best candidate we could find to serve on the Supreme Court.......really?

LOL

I would not go that far, but she has more experience on the federal bench than any currently on the Supreme Court.
 
Sotomayor draws praise from GOP critics - Yahoo! News



Apparently, she is the racist activist that many have made her out to be. Thoughts?



You mean she isn't the racist activist, right?
I think the GOP has made a big mistake going after her the way some have.

Also, I think Graham (and others, but not all GOPers) will probably vote for her confirmation, altho I think his 'bully' line of questioning of her was tinged with sexism.
 
You mean she isn't the racist activist, right?
I think the GOP has made a big mistake going after her the way some have.

Also, I think Graham (and others, but not all GOPers) will probably vote for her confirmation, altho I think his 'bully' line of questioning of her was tinged with sexism.

Thanks, correction made.

They have to badger her a bit. How else do you politically grand stand, unless you accuse a long-time federal judge of being racist?;)
 
Thanks, correction made.

They have to badger her a bit. How else do you politically grand stand, unless you accuse a long-time federal judge of being racist?;)


Welcs .... and :lol: good point on the strategy .
 
Among them, Sens. Robert Bennett of Utah, Thad Cochran of Mississippi, Susan Collins of Maine, Judd Gregg of New Hampshire, Orrin Hatch of Utah, Richard Lugar of Indiana and Olympia Snowe of Maine all voted in favor of her confirmation.

Okay... we're taking names... it's not only a bunch of Democrats who have to go in 2010. How about flushing a few misguided, bottom-feeding Republicans down the crapper to keep them company. Of course, they will be a drop in the bucket next to the crapload of Democrats.
 
So this is really the best candidate we could find to serve on the Supreme Court.......really?

LOL

Who were your picks? And why are they more qualified??

...LOL
 
Okay... we're taking names... it's not only a bunch of Democrats who have to go in 2010. How about flushing a few misguided, bottom-feeding Republicans down the crapper to keep them company. Of course, they will be a drop in the bucket next to the crapload of Democrats.

Good to know that Conservatives abandon their "liberal activist" brethren when they're trying to support bi-partisanship.
 
Sotomayor draws praise from GOP critics - Yahoo! News



Apparently, she isn't the racist activist that many have made her out to be. Thoughts?


Lindsey Graham is only a GOP Senator because we haven't gotten the right man to run against him yet here in SC. His political days are numbered.

He got one right during the questioning, when he pointed out that if HE had said something like Sotomayor's "wise latina" remark, reversed of course, that "they would have had his head."

As my father used to say, "even a blind hog finds an ear of corn once in a while."

Lindsey's endorsement means less than nothing to actual conservatives.
 
Lindsey Graham is only a GOP Senator because we haven't gotten the right man to run against him yet here in SC. His political days are numbered.

He got one right during the questioning, when he pointed out that if HE had said something like Sotomayor's "wise latina" remark, reversed of course, that "they would have had his head."

As my father used to say, "even a blind hog finds an ear of corn once in a while."

Lindsey's endorsement means less than nothing to actual conservatives.

What? You guys don't like Lindsey Graham?
 
As a white male, I can hope that my experience and judgment would be better than a latina woman......
 
Okay... we're taking names... it's not only a bunch of Democrats who have to go in 2010. How about flushing a few misguided, bottom-feeding Republicans down the crapper to keep them company. Of course, they will be a drop in the bucket next to the crapload of Democrats.

A quick look at your hit list includes a lot of Moderates. Are you suggesting the Republicans should flush them from the party just because they don't always vote along party lines?
 
So this is really the best candidate we could find to serve on the Supreme Court.......really?

She's infinitely more qualified than the assclown Clarence Thomas.
 
She's infinitely more qualified than the assclown Clarence Thomas.

I can't get passed the fact that Sotomayor ruled in favor of reverse racism.

I find this action unacceptable. She is an old school bigot who has no place on the SCOTUS.
 
So this is really the best candidate we could find to serve on the Supreme Court.......really?

LOL

Of course not, but "we" don't get to pick the nominee.

If you're a traditional conservative, then of the entire list that Obama was considering, she's probably one of the best.

She's infinitely more qualified than the assclown Clarence Thomas.

And you're basing this on...? Can you share some of his opinions that you find particularly flawed?

See, 95% of people who say things like this are just parroting the passively-racist trope about how Thomas is stupid and just votes however Scalia tells him. Since this is a terribly uninformed position, I'm hoping that you are part of that 5% that actually has an educated critique of Thomas's jurisprudence. I look forward to your response.
 
What? You guys don't like Lindsey Graham?


Is that a suprise?

Other than being a lying, disloyal, self-aggrandizing, misrepresenting, arrogant ass... he sucks.
 
Is that a suprise?

Other than being a lying, disloyal, self-aggrandizing, misrepresenting, arrogant ass... he sucks.

Now I'm curious. Are there really reasons to hate him other than apparently being a moderate?
 
Now I'm curious. Are there really reasons to hate him other than apparently being a moderate?

If you want to call him a moderate...

He ran as a actual conservative, to the base here in SC. He had hardly settled in to Washington before he secured his position as one of the "aisle-crossers", the "gang of 14" who tried to make themselves powerbrokers of the Bush judicial nominations. He's consistently ignored the will of his constituency in more issues than I can remember. He's got his nose so far up John McCain's @** its a wonder he can breathe.

He's not a "moderate", he's a self-aggrandizing power-broker who has demonstrated he is NOT the man he claimed to be when he originally ran for Senate.
 
She's infinitely more qualified than the assclown Clarence Thomas.
Infinitely? Infinitely??? The insanity never ends around here. :doh
 
Back
Top Bottom