• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Spy chief: We risk a police state

danarhea

Slayer of the DP Newsbot
DP Veteran
Joined
Aug 27, 2005
Messages
43,602
Reaction score
26,256
Location
Houston, TX
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Conservative
A surprising statement, considering that the person who made that statement the other day is no less than the former head of MI5 in Britain, and what she said applies just as much to America. The issue of terrorism can be used in 2 ways to deprive us of our cherished liberties:

1) Thugs can use the security issue in order to gain power. Adolph Hitler was a prime example.

2) However, just as dangerous, as well as much more common is the good-intentioned nation which becomes a nanny in order to "protect us". This is even more insidious because we won't see it coming until it is too late. At least Hitler made no bones about his agenda. Seemingly nice leaders here at home, believing they are doing a "good deed" for their countrymen, have the capability of instituting a police state too, and once the deed is done, it is very difficult to reverse.

Benjamin Franklin had it right all along, but do we? If we should ever get to the point where we deserve neither liberty nor safety, then we are no longer Americans, and this is no longer America.

Article is here.
 
What do you mean risk? We're mostly there already.
 
A definition of police state should be given here. One could say we are one now. Smile, your on Candid Camera!
 
Our insistence on a liberal application of civil liberties does wonders for those who wish to spy on us. It gives them the justification they need.
 
A definition of police state should be given here. One could say we are one now. Smile, your on Candid Camera!
You could say it, but it wouldn't be true.
 
A surprising statement, considering that the person who made that statement the other day is no less than the former head of MI5 in Britain, and what she said applies just as much to America. The issue of terrorism can be used in 2 ways to deprive us of our cherished liberties:

1) Thugs can use the security issue in order to gain power. Adolph Hitler was a prime example.

2) However, just as dangerous, as well as much more common is the good-intentioned nation which becomes a nanny in order to "protect us". This is even more insidious because we won't see it coming until it is too late. At least Hitler made no bones about his agenda. Seemingly nice leaders here at home, believing they are doing a "good deed" for their countrymen, have the capability of instituting a police state too, and once the deed is done, it is very difficult to reverse.

Benjamin Franklin had it right all along, but do we? If we should ever get to the point where we deserve neither liberty nor safety, then we are no longer Americans, and this is no longer America.

Article is here.

I'd say that the U.K. already is a police state.

Used to be that when the people of the U.K. had weapons the police didn't, now the police have been issued weapons and the people don't have them.

On top of that London has the most government video cameras in the world "protecting" its citizens.
 
Having been raised in the UK, I would tend to agree that that society is as heavily over supervised as is the US wherein I now dwell.
To decide whether a society is or is not free, simply discover the magnitude of that Nations Prison population.
 
Orwell could have told you this.

For Example: Politics and the English Language.
 
Our insistence on a liberal application of civil liberties does wonders for those who wish to spy on us. It gives them the justification they need.

So a good reason that people spy on us is because we complain about them taking the initiative to initially spy on us.... :idea: GENIUS.
 
Back
Top Bottom