• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Trump Tells Freshman Congresswomen to ‘Go Back’ to the Countries They Came From

His tweet isn't racist but it is stupid, I'll say that much. The president really should have professional staff manage his social media accounts.

Nonetheless I'll take a stupid tweet over the vastly more stupid tweets coming from AOC and her ilk because in their cases they are also proposing idiotic policies and rhetorical extremism on things ranging from abolishing ICE or calling detention centers for those needing detention due to illegally crossing the border "concentration camps."

Problems are- he is the President, AOC ain't.
How many times does one hear from him tweet after tweet/speech/press conference, where he spins this crap

And then we have the Trump is being Trump crowd, just ignore it, nothing there.
 
The tweet doesn't mention race or any kind of "white superiority" at all. Trump's tweet was stupidly, poorly constructed, and not beneficial to him in my opinion but it was not racist.
And yet you admit he specifically targeted non-white congresswomen. Even if you wanted to pretend it's not racist, you would at least have to cede xenophobia and prejudice. How can you defend the sentiment of "go back to your country" as merely stupid? It's clearly hateful.
 
Sounds like good advice. They have a LOT of work to do in those countries. The United States is lightyears ahead of those places. If they truly want to make a difference in the world, go fix your homeland.
 
I'm sure a lot of Trump supporters agree with him, they should be deported back to wherever, even if they were born here.

Where in the awkwardly and badly thought out Trump tweet posted below, did Trump say he wanted anyone deported?

Oh that's right... he didn't. :lol:


So interesting to see “Progressive” Democrat Congresswomen, who originally came from countries whose governments are a complete and total catastrophe, the worst, most corrupt and inept anywhere in the world (if they even have a functioning government at all), now loudly......
and viciously telling the people of the United States, the greatest and most powerful Nation on earth, how our government is to be run. Why don’t they go back and help fix the totally broken and crime infested places from which they came. Then come back and show us how........it is done. These places need your help badly, you can’t leave fast enough. I’m sure that Nancy Pelosi would be very happy to quickly work out free travel arrangements!

https://mobile.twitter.com/realDonaldTrump
 
His tweet isn't racist but it is stupid, I'll say that much. The president really should have professional staff manage his social media accounts.

Nonetheless I'll take a stupid tweet over the vastly more stupid tweets coming from AOC and her ilk because in their cases they are also proposing idiotic policies and rhetorical extremism on things ranging from abolishing ICE or calling detention centers for those needing detention due to illegally crossing the border "concentration camps."

If you can’t see why that tweet was unbelievably racist, you probably don’t see anything at all as racist.
 
Trump uses his twitter account to 'trigger' radical progressives....He's very successful at it...

Just gonna double down on the stupid? Nice
 
Are you proud or happy that Trump is using his position as President to troll the country?

I wouldn't say proud...I classify it as unimportant in my life...But, you think that liberal Democrats are "the country"?
 
Yep, he is a troll online....Just as liberals, progressives, and so called Independents, along with anti Trumpers are right here in this board....So, I guess you people can dish it out, but just can't take it....
Calling someone a troll is generally considered an insult. It's odd that you consider that either a defense or an admirable quality.
 
And yet you admit he specifically targeted non-white congresswomen. Even if you wanted to pretend it's not racist, you would at least have to cede xenophobia and prejudice. How can you defend the sentiment of "go back to your country" as merely stupid? It's clearly hateful.

Nope.
Sorry, no racism, no xenophobia, no prejudice.

These four congresswomen have said the most hideous, hyperbolic things about ICE officers and ICE detention camps and even the POTUS, the latter implying he is HITLER.
Their despicable condemnations and actions are not above reproach and their gender, their race, and ethnicity do not get them off the hook.
 
Sounds like good advice. They have a LOT of work to do in those countries. The United States is lightyears ahead of those places. If they truly want to make a difference in the world, go fix your homeland.
Please name these countries that you think are their "homeland" (I'll give you a hint, the correct answer for most of them is the United States of America)
 
I wouldn't say proud...I classify it as unimportant in my life...But, you think that liberal Democrats are "the country"?

Is it an admirable thing that Trump is using his position as President to troll the people he was put in office to lead?
 
Trump uses his twitter account to 'trigger' radical progressives....He's very successful at it...

Jesus christ you people are insane.

The cruelty it seems is the ****ing point
Sad
 
Nope.
Sorry, no racism, no xenophobia, no prejudice.
What separates it from xenophobia in your mind? How would you assume that people born in the US were not from the US without using some kind of prejudice?
 
If you can’t see why that tweet was unbelievably racist, you probably don’t see anything at all as racist.

The world would be a better place if everyone was like that. Its more healthy to not see racism than to see racism everywhere including where there isnt any. Morgan Freeman said the way to end racism is to stop talking about it. I agree.
 
Please name these countries that you think are their "homeland" (I'll give you a hint, the correct answer for most of them is the United States of America)

Somalia for one.


Its funny....if you tell a liberal your nationality is American...and youre white...then they say yEr NoT nAtIvE aMeRiCaN but when a precious brown/black says it they are apple pie. Colored people are pets to liberal whites.
 
Yep, he is a troll online....Just as liberals, progressives, and so called Independents, along with anti Trumpers are right here in this board....So, I guess you people can dish it out, but just can't take it....
The bolded is racist and clear as day
Why make excuses
Trump Tells Freshman Congresswomen to ‘Go Back’ to the Countries They Came From - The New York Times
Mr. Trump added: “Why don’t they go back and help fix the totally broken and crime infested places from which they came. Then come back and show us how it is done.”
 
Nope.
Sorry, no racism, no xenophobia, no prejudice.

These four congresswomen have said the most hideous, hyperbolic things about ICE officers and ICE detention camps and even the POTUS, the latter implying he is HITLER.
Their despicable condemnations and actions are not above reproach and their gender, their race, and ethnicity do not get them off the hook.

The POTUS uses cruel tactics specifically as a means of deterrence to other refugees. Is that admirable?
 
Then why did he aim it at only four American citizen-representatives who happen to have non-white skin, three of whom were born here and one, like his wife, who wasn't?

Why didn't he aim it at everyone who takes issue with the way he treats illegals as compared to past presidents?

The simple fact is that what he said is racist, and intentionally so. It's just his version of identity politics. You should be condemning it whole-heartedly, not half-assedly.


PS: the "it isn't what you say, but it's stupid" isn't a convincing defense when you still support the sentiment. It's as transparent as anything can be. Yes, it was racist. Yes, you know it. And the only reason you won't say it is you don't want to be seen to in some way undermine the far right's (I notice you changed your lean) claim that there is no racism outside of the literal KKK and that everything else is just liberals playing the race card; on the other hand, you want to try to retain the appearance of credibility, so you reach for some negative sounding word - stupid - and apply it to what Trump said.

That way you can embrace the sentiment, appear to criticize it, and further support the dishonest theme aimed at the left (of "race card" playing).

To be fair, he doesn't explicitly name anyone but it's 99% likely he's pointing to AOC, Omar, and Tliab, none of which are white and each tend to play the race card or "women of color" crap constantly when criticized (mainly AOC). I can't think of a white left-wing extremist congresswoman with social media followings like they do constantly bellowing lies intended to attack the president and our institutions like ICE. The tweet doesn't mention race or any kind of "white superiority" at all. Trump's tweet was stupidly, poorly constructed, and not beneficial to him in my opinion but it was not racist.

That far-left progressive group may or may not have said a lot of stupid things. It doesn't excuse telling them - 3 of whom were even born here, 1 naturalized - to go back to their countries in response to their criticism of his policies. When he only aims at a subset of people with a certain skin color, again a subset of a far larger group of people taking the same issue with those policies, it gives a pretty clear notion of what he's doing.

The reaction of Trumpists around DP further confirms it: it's universally being played as "oh look, the liberals are playing the race card again". That was the point.

Now you may or may not believe it, but I take great issue with the way identity politics is used by the Democrats. This, however, is identity politics on the right. (In fact, it looks like the Dems might just rip themselves apart and give Trump another 4 years with infighting between Biden and the farther left candidates, who are presently fighting over whether Biden is racist).

Trump's version of the right's identity politics, specifically. He could easily have attacked everyone who doesn't like his Big Beautiful Wall idea, who take issue with locking up and separating illegals when Obama's program - implemented in response to a court order - was working quite well. He didn't. He chose to focus on four politicians with non-white skin, three who were born here and one who like his wife was not but has become a citizen; with foreign-sounding names.

Want to admit it or not, but there is a very real xenophobia amongst his base, his supporters, his defenders. It's real. We only ended legal segregation several decades ago. Much more persisted. America has not come nearly as far as it tells itself, and you know....it's a certain 'side' that does most of the telling. I wonder why



PS: the stance that one has to literally say "I don't like X people" to be racist is absurd in the extreme. It's also transparent.
 
Last edited:
As expected, the board's Trumpists are defending the blatant racism...

Not when you made this comment, they weren't. 4/5 posters at that time were libs :lamo You're trying to stir the pot, so you can say, 'aha! Told you so!'
 
Yep, he is a troll online....Just as liberals, progressives, and so called Independents, along with anti Trumpers are right here in this board....So, I guess you people can dish it out, but just can't take it....

If trump is using his position as President to troll the country he was put in office to lead, then maybe any criticism sent his way is fair and justified, wouldn't you say?
 
Back
Top Bottom