• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

U.S. Ends El Salvador's Protected Status, Affecting 200,000 Residents

truthatallcost

DP Veteran
Joined
Aug 1, 2014
Messages
26,719
Reaction score
6,278
Location
California
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Other
The Trump administration says it will end the temporary protected status that has allowed some 200,000 natives of El Salvador to live in the U.S. without fear of deportation for nearly 17 years, the Department of Homeland Security says.

In a news release about its decision, Homeland Security said that Salvadorans should use the 18-month delay to either leave the U.S. or "seek an alternative lawful immigration status in the United States, if eligible." The agency also called on Congress to act, saying that only a change to U.S. law would provide a "permanent solution" for people who have for years been living and working in the U.S.

https://www.npr.org/sections/thetwo...-protected-status-affecting-200-000-residents

Despite the gloom and doom attempt by some media (NYT especially), it sounds like the 200k won't actually be required to leave, if they can make other arrangements legally.

I have mixed feelings. On the one hand, these people were supposed to only live in the US temporarily, and then leave once circumstances back home hand changed. An earthquake from 2001 isn't what's still keeping them here.

On the other hand, our govt failed to send them home in a timely manner, and they've lived in the US 17 years now, so its really the fault of the previous 2 administrations.
 
Despite the gloom and doom attempt by some media (NYT especially), it sounds like the 200k won't actually be required to leave, if they can make other arrangements legally.

I have mixed feelings. On the one hand, these people were supposed to only live in the US temporarily, and then leave once circumstances back home hand changed. An earthquake from 2001 isn't what's still keeping them here.

On the other hand, our govt failed to send them home in a timely manner, and they've lived in the US 17 years now, so its really the fault of the previous 2 administrations.

Exactly zero Salvadorans were involved with the events of 9/11.
 
Exactly zero Salvadorans were involved with the events of 9/11.

WTH does 9/11 have to do with this topic? :confused: You do know that the Salvadorans being talked about in this case are here as a result of an earthquake right? Did you not read the article linked in the OP? (answer is obvious so that's a rhetorical question in case you didn't get it)
 
WTH does 9/11 have to do with this topic? :confused: You do know that the Salvadorans being talked about in this case are here as a result of an earthquake right? Did you not read the article linked in the OP? (answer is obvious so that's a rhetorical question in case you didn't get it)

That's right, and times up. Ding!
 
Despite the gloom and doom attempt by some media (NYT especially), it sounds like the 200k won't actually be required to leave, if they can make other arrangements legally.

I have mixed feelings. On the one hand, these people were supposed to only live in the US temporarily, and then leave once circumstances back home hand changed. An earthquake from 2001 isn't what's still keeping them here.

On the other hand, our govt failed to send them home in a timely manner, and they've lived in the US 17 years now, so its really the fault of the previous 2 administrations.

Pretty much my views on the situation. If it's temporary, kick them out after a year or so. If you let them stay nearly 20 years it's cruel to kick them out now and it's on the previous administrations for letting them stay.
 
Despite the gloom and doom attempt by some media (NYT especially), it sounds like the 200k won't actually be required to leave, if they can make other arrangements legally.

I have mixed feelings. On the one hand, these people were supposed to only live in the US temporarily, and then leave once circumstances back home hand changed. An earthquake from 2001 isn't what's still keeping them here.

On the other hand, our govt failed to send them home in a timely manner, and they've lived in the US 17 years now, so its really the fault of the previous 2 administrations.

So? Send them home anyway.

I am personally sick and tired of all the ways people justify allowing exceptions to immigration which only serve to encourage more illegal immigration.

The idea being that "Americans are soft and feel guilty about all their wealth, so if we can just get there and manage to stay under the radar long enough they will let us stay forever."

They are right. The Left never gives a thought to the fact we already have millions upon millions of American citizens unemployed, under-employed, and on welfare programs as things are.

That our population is growing and we don't have enough jobs for our own citizens, but apparently plenty of opportunity for people who aren't citizens to work somehow at jobs "Americans don't want?"

The logical disconnect between arguments for American's being out of work and yet still having jobs we somehow don't want to do so illegal migration is okay amazes me.
 
Last edited:
So? Send them home anyway.

I am personally sick and tired of all the ways people justify allowing exceptions to immigration which only serve to encourage more illegal immigration.

The idea being that "Americans are soft and feel guilty about all their wealth, so if we can just get there and manage to stay under the radar long enough they will let us stay forever."

They are right. The Left never gives a thought to the fact we already have millions upon millions of American citizens unemployed, under-employed, and on welfare programs as things are.

That our population is growing and we don't have enough jobs for our own citizens, but apparently plenty of opportunity for people who aren't citizens to work somehow at jobs "Americans don't want?"

The logical disconnect between arguments for American's being out of work and yet still having jobs we somehow don't want to do so illegal migration is okay amazes me.

Actually, your lean says to the left so at least there's one lefty out there thinking of those facts. ;)


I have to disagree to send them home. After almost 20 years here, I would imagine most of them consider this home now.
 
So? Send them home anyway.

I am personally sick and tired of all the ways people justify allowing exceptions to immigration which only serve to encourage more illegal immigration.

The idea being that "Americans are soft and feel guilty about all their wealth, so if we can just get there and manage to stay under the radar long enough they will let us stay forever."

They are right. The Left never gives a thought to the fact we already have millions upon millions of American citizens unemployed, under-employed, and on welfare programs as things are.

That our population is growing and we don't have enough jobs for our own citizens, but apparently plenty of opportunity for people who aren't citizens to work somehow at jobs "Americans don't want?"

The logical disconnect between arguments for American's being out of work and yet still having jobs we somehow don't want to do so illegal migration is okay amazes me.

I wasn't saying I think they should stay, just that the 2 previous Presidential administrations are responsible for them still being here. And now we have ****hole-gate to contend with, which is really just the left's attempt to get these people to be able to stay.
 
Back
Top Bottom