• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Trump revealed submarine locations to Philippines president

Angelus

Well-known member
Joined
Jan 31, 2017
Messages
625
Reaction score
382
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Other
Trump revealed submarine locations to Philippines president


“We have a lot of firepower over there,” Trump said in the transcript, an official document of the Philippine Department of Foreign Affairs.

“We have two submarines — the best in the world — we have two nuclear submarines — not that we want to use them at all,” Trump continues. “I’ve never seen anything like they are but we don’t have to use this but he could be crazy so we will see what happens.”

The Defense Department historically does not reveal the locations of its submarines, since keeping the vessels’ movements secret is key to their missions.


The Navy does acknowledge that nuclear submarines are part of deploying strike groups — allowing the public a general idea of the deployment schedule and destination. To this end, the service announced April 25 the USS Michigan Ohio-class ballistic missile submarine was in Busan, South Korea, on a “routine visit” and on May 2 said the USS Cheyenne Los Angeles-class attack submarine arrived at a Navy base in Sasebo, Japan.

Pentagon officials are alarmed by Trump’s disclosure. Revealing that submarines are in the region is not the same as addressing how many there are and that they are near North Korea, as Trump did.

hogans_heroes_facepalm.jpg

They are called submarines...sub=below and marine+water. They stay below the water so they can't be seen. It's like he needs some sort of penis metaphor to prove he's the biggliest bad guy. By announcing the presence of nuclear submarines he gives away the element of surprise — an irony given his repeated declarations during the campaign that the US announces far too many of its military plans when it comes to combating ISIS. Also China is developing their anti-sub capability. Knowing that two US submarines are in the region can allow them to test their own military capabilities. Just what we need.
 

Attachments

  • 8369759.jpg
    8369759.jpg
    46 KB · Views: 70
Last edited by a moderator:
Revealing that submarines are in the region is not the same as addressing how many there are and that they are near North Korea, as Trump did
I see. So it is okay to say that I have assets in South Korea, but not okay to say that I have assets near North Korea. Gotcha :roll:
 
Trump revealed submarine locations to Philippines president


“We have a lot of firepower over there,” Trump said in the transcript, an official document of the Philippine Department of Foreign Affairs.

“We have two submarines — the best in the world — we have two nuclear submarines — not that we want to use them at all,” Trump continues. “I’ve never seen anything like they are but we don’t have to use this but he could be crazy so we will see what happens.”

The Defense Department historically does not reveal the locations of its submarines, since keeping the vessels’ movements secret is key to their missions.


The Navy does acknowledge that nuclear submarines are part of deploying strike groups — allowing the public a general idea of the deployment schedule and destination. To this end, the service announced April 25 the USS Michigan Ohio-class ballistic missile submarine was in Busan, South Korea, on a “routine visit” and on May 2 said the USS Cheyenne Los Angeles-class attack submarine arrived at a Navy base in Sasebo, Japan.

Pentagon officials are alarmed by Trump’s disclosure. Revealing that submarines are in the region is not the same as addressing how many there are and that they are near North Korea, as Trump did.

View attachment 67218011

They are called submarines...sub=below and marine+water. They stay below the water so they can't be seen. It's like he needs some sort of penis metaphor to prove he's the biggliest bad guy. By announcing the presence of nuclear submarines he gives away the element of surprise — an irony given his repeated declarations during the campaign that the US announces far too many of its military plans when it comes to combating ISIS. Also China is developing their anti-sub capability. Knowing that two US submarines are in the region can allow them to test their own military capabilities. Just what we need.

Maybe I am missing something, but if that level of informatiin helps the enemy, they are rather poorly informed. The only question it answers it two not three.
 
I see. So it is okay to say that I have assets in South Korea, but not okay to say that I have assets near North Korea. Gotcha :roll:

Actually revealing sub locations period is not O.K. The advantage to subs is their ability to conceal.

Trump is an idiot.
 
Maybe I am missing something, but if that level of informatiin helps the enemy, they are rather poorly informed.
Very poorly informed given that this information was available publicly on the Navy website, in much more detail.

The only question it answers it two not three.
It doesn't even answer that. There could five in the region for all we/they know.
 

Try reading the article - The Navy does acknowledge that nuclear submarines are part of deploying strike groups — allowing the public a general idea of the deployment schedule and destination. To this end, the service announced April 25 the USS Michigan Ohio-class ballistic missile submarine was in Busan, South Korea, on a “routine visit” and on May 2 said the USS Cheyenne Los Angeles-class attack submarine arrived at a Navy base in Sasebo, Japan. Pentagon officials are alarmed by Trump’s disclosure. Revealing that submarines are in the region is not the same as addressing how many there are and that they are near North Korea, as Trump did.
 
Very poorly informed given that this information was available publicly on the Navy website, in much more detail.


It doesn't even answer that. There could five in the region for all we/they know.


Link - something that tells me exactly where each nuclear sub is.
 
Try reading the article - The Navy does acknowledge that nuclear submarines are part of deploying strike groups — allowing the public a general idea of the deployment schedule and destination. To this end, the service announced April 25 the USS Michigan Ohio-class ballistic missile submarine was in Busan, South Korea, on a “routine visit” and on May 2 said the USS Cheyenne Los Angeles-class attack submarine arrived at a Navy base in Sasebo, Japan. Pentagon officials are alarmed by Trump’s disclosure. Revealing that submarines are in the region is not the same as addressing how many there are and that they are near North Korea, as Trump did.
See post #2.
 
See post #5.

Saw it - no Navy website link that show where all the nuclear subs are located. Just an article that was already addressed in the article I printed.

Gtta say - if this is your best, I am not impressed. How about the link you promised me? Or do you agree that unless the Pentagon makes a public announcement, the exact locations are not published.
 
Try reading the article - The Navy does acknowledge that nuclear submarines are part of deploying strike groups — allowing the public a general idea of the deployment schedule and destination. To this end, the service announced April 25 the USS Michigan Ohio-class ballistic missile submarine was in Busan, South Korea, on a “routine visit” and on May 2 said the USS Cheyenne Los Angeles-class attack submarine arrived at a Navy base in Sasebo, Japan. Pentagon officials are alarmed by Trump’s disclosure. Revealing that submarines are in the region is not the same as addressing how many there are and that they are near North Korea, as Trump did.

Don't bother. If they had their way, we'd all be eating caviar and drinking vodka.
 
Well, at least he didn't tip off anyone that Japan was near Korea, that could be prime information in the wrong hands.
 
Trump revealed submarine locations to Philippines president


“We have a lot of firepower over there,” Trump said in the transcript, an official document of the Philippine Department of Foreign Affairs.

“We have two submarines — the best in the world — we have two nuclear submarines — not that we want to use them at all,” Trump continues. “I’ve never seen anything like they are but we don’t have to use this but he could be crazy so we will see what happens.”

The Defense Department historically does not reveal the locations of its submarines, since keeping the vessels’ movements secret is key to their missions.


The Navy does acknowledge that nuclear submarines are part of deploying strike groups — allowing the public a general idea of the deployment schedule and destination. To this end, the service announced April 25 the USS Michigan Ohio-class ballistic missile submarine was in Busan, South Korea, on a “routine visit” and on May 2 said the USS Cheyenne Los Angeles-class attack submarine arrived at a Navy base in Sasebo, Japan.

Pentagon officials are alarmed by Trump’s disclosure. Revealing that submarines are in the region is not the same as addressing how many there are and that they are near North Korea, as Trump did.

View attachment 67218011

They are called submarines...sub=below and marine+water. They stay below the water so they can't be seen. It's like he needs some sort of penis metaphor to prove he's the biggliest bad guy. By announcing the presence of nuclear submarines he gives away the element of surprise — an irony given his repeated declarations during the campaign that the US announces far too many of its military plans when it comes to combating ISIS. Also China is developing their anti-sub capability. Knowing that two US submarines are in the region can allow them to test their own military capabilities. Just what we need.

Listen up Angelus, carrier strike groups often times contain subs in the group. The good guys and bad guys know this. Trump conveyed common knowledge, hell, Wikipedia even describes such.

Non story.
 
Haven't we learned that just because Trump says there are Naval vessels in an area doesn't mean they are actually there? :)
 
Don't bother. If they had their way, we'd all be eating caviar and drinking vodka.

Caviar and vodka is pretty good. :mrgreen:
 
Caviar and vodka is pretty good. :mrgreen:

Vodka was OK back in my drinking days, but caviar sucs, you're welcome to my share.
 
Trump Revealed Location Of U.S. Nuclear Subs In Call With Duterte

This is treason on the part of obama moles inside the intelligence agencies and the NY Times

They should be hunted down and put in jail

It is even worse than the crime of leaking information the US received from the Brits over the Manchester bombing


Trump Revealed Location Of U.S. Nuclear Subs In Call With Duterte | HuffPost

U.S. President Donald Trump told his Philippine counterpart that Washington has sent two nuclear submarines to waters off the Korean peninsula, the New York Times said, comments likely to raise questions about his handling of sensitive information
.
 
Re: Trump Revealed Location Of U.S. Nuclear Subs In Call With Duterte

This is treason on the part of obama moles inside the intelligence agencies and the NY Times. They should be hunted down and put in jail. It is even worse than the crime of leaking information the US received from the Brits over the Manchester bombing.

Do you know more than the article states? It appears Duterte's government circulated a transcript of the conversation and a senior TRUMP administration official confirmed the content.

Not sure how a reasoned man would lay this on 'unnamed Obama moles'... :peace
 
Re: Trump Revealed Location Of U.S. Nuclear Subs In Call With Duterte

Yes you are right. Trump should be charged with treason.

Why?

Please explain if you can
 
Back
Top Bottom