• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Canadian citizen denied entry to United States told she needed visa to get in

Somerville

DP Veteran
Joined
Apr 29, 2012
Messages
17,867
Reaction score
8,345
Location
On an island. Not that one!
Gender
Undisclosed
Political Leaning
Socialist
It looks like some border patrol agents have a 'thing' for people of colour. This case involves a woman born in Canada after her parents emigrated to Canada in the 60s.

Canadian citizen denied entry to United States told she needed visa to get in

MONTREAL -- A Montreal woman who is a Canadian citizen says she was barred from entering the United States and told to get a visa.
Manpreet Kooner says she was turned away at a crossing along the Quebec-Vermont border on Sunday and informed she needed a valid visa.
Kooner, 30, is of Indian descent and was born in Montreal to parents who came to India from Canada in the 1960s.
She says she's perplexed given she was travelling on a Canadian passport and has no criminal record. Kooner says she was travelling with two friends -- both white -- who were not questioned by border officials.

Since when have Canadians been required to have a visa before traveling to the US?
 
Since when have Canadians been required to have a visa before traveling to the US?

It's been required for a few years that I know of.
 
It looks like some border patrol agents have a 'thing' for people of colour. This case involves a woman born in Canada after her parents emigrated to Canada in the 60s.



Since when have Canadians been required to have a visa before traveling to the US?

Based on the article, it seems American Border Agents chose to profile Ms. Kooner. Fortunately, her incident garnished publicity with powerful Canadians who appear intent on inquiring deeper into her incident.
 
It looks like some border patrol agents have a 'thing' for people of colour. This case involves a woman born in Canada after her parents emigrated to Canada in the 60s.



Since when have Canadians been required to have a visa before traveling to the US?

It's been that way for at least 20 years as far as I know. I had a guy that worked for me that had to go back and get his visa renewed twice during his employment. Canada is not a country on the Visa Waiver Program list: https://travel.state.gov/content/visas/en/visit/visa-waiver-program.html
 
It looks like some border patrol agents have a 'thing' for people of colour. This case involves a woman born in Canada after her parents emigrated to Canada in the 60s.



Since when have Canadians been required to have a visa before traveling to the US?

They don't. I suspect, we don't have the whole story.
 
It's been that way for at least 20 years as far as I know. I had a guy that worked for me that had to go back and get his visa renewed twice during his employment. Canada is not a country on the Visa Waiver Program list: https://travel.state.gov/content/visas/en/visit/visa-waiver-program.html

Your employee had to have a visa to work in the US. Canadians traveling to the US as tourists or who cross the border for shopping are not normally required to have a visa.

Citizens of Canada traveling to the United States do not require a nonimmigrant visa, except for the travel purposes described below.

  • Foreign government officials (A); officials and employees of international organizations (G); and NATO officials, representatives, and employees assigned to the United States (NATO)
  • Treaty traders (E-1)
  • Treaty investors (E-2)
  • Fiancé(e)s (K-1)
  • Children of fiancé(e)s (K-2)
  • Spouse of a U.S. citizen traveling to the United States to complete the immigration process (K-3)
  • Children of a foreign citizen spouse (K-4) described above
  • Informant supplying critical information relating to a criminal organization (S-5)
  • Informant supplying critical information relating to terrorism (S-6)

Qualified family member (S-7) of an S-5 or S-6 visa holder described above
 
According to the US Embassy they don't need Visas to just come to the US to visit:

In most circumstances, Canadian citizens do not require visitor, business, transit or other visas to enter the United States, either from Canada or from other countries. There are, however, some exceptions to this situation. These exceptions (and the visa category they require) include:
•Treaty traders and investors (requires E Visa);
•Foreign citizen fiancé(e) (K-1 Visa), as well as the fiancé(e)’s children (K-2 Visa);
•A U.S. citizen’s foreign citizen spouse traveling to reside in the U.S. while awaiting final completion of the process of immigration (K-3 Visa), as well as the spouse’s children (K-4 Visa);
•Spouses of lawful permanent residents (V-1 Visas), as well as the spouse’s children who are traveling to reside in the U.S. while awaiting final completion of the process of immigration (V-2 Visas);
•Non-immigrants travelling to the United States for work (Non-Immigrant Visas), including: •Canadian government officials (A Visas), if entering the U.S. for temporary or permanent assignment;
•Officials and employees of international organizations (G Visas), if entering the U.S. for temporary or permanent assignment; and
•NATO officials, representatives, and employees, only if they are being assigned to the U.S. (as opposed to an official trip).



https://ca.usembassy.gov/visas/do-i-need-a-visa/
 
In Vermont there is a very special library, the Haskell Free Library. It is the only library in the world which has an international border running through it.

image.jpg
See the line running across the floor? That is the border between the US and Canada.

For nearly 200 years Derby Line, Vermont, and Stanstead, Quebec, essentially functioned as one town. Citizens drank the same water, worked in the same tool factory, played the same sports (primarily curling), fought in the same world wars, and were born in the same hospital in nearby Newport, Vermont. They also shared the same cultural center, the Haskell Free Library and Opera House, an ornate Victorian edifice built deliberately on top of the international border in 1901 by the Canadian wife of a wealthy American merchant.

In the last 15 years, though, the common culture of the two towns has been eroded, largely due to the increased emphasis on securing the U.S. border in the years following 9/11. Gone are the days when a local resident could walk across the dividing line with a smile and a wave. But against all logic, the Haskell Free Library and Opera House continues to serve both Vermonters and Quebecers, and remains a transnational space that residents from both the U.S. and Canada can enter without a passport. Today, it is the only library in the world that exists and operates in two countries at once.

If you read the article you will find the tale of Buzzy Roy, a local who walked across the border in 2010 to buy a pizza and was arrested when he returned home for failing to stop at one of the checkpoints that had been erected following the 9/11 attacks.
 
As a single white male I was searched and detained trying to enter Canada for about 2 hours, and I'm grateful they do such things to protect their citizens. I actually thanked the border guards after it was all over.
 
Your employee had to have a visa to work in the US. Canadians traveling to the US as tourists or who cross the border for shopping are not normally required to have a visa.

That only applies to white Canadians.











snark off
 
It looks like some border patrol agents have a 'thing' for people of colour. This case involves a woman born in Canada after her parents emigrated to Canada in the 60s.



Since when have Canadians been required to have a visa before traveling to the US?

Since Jan 20, 2017 apparently...if they happen to be brown-skinned.
 
As a single white male I was searched and detained trying to enter Canada for about 2 hours, and I'm grateful they do such things to protect their citizens. I actually thanked the border guards after it was all over.

This doesn't just protect American citizens, but also decent law-abiding non-citizens staying in the country - like you.

Not being a haven of violent illegal riff raff (like some countries are) makes the US a nice place to live and visit.
 
Back
Top Bottom