• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

President Trump May Pitch Comprehensive Immigration Reform in Address

For instance, kids brought here by parents who grow up and are otherwise law abiding members of society contributing to it.

They are not contributing enough if they are on welfare
 
Come on, not everybody is on welfare.

And not everyone will be deported

But being on welfare should automatically disqualify them from amnesty
 
And not everyone will be deported

But being on welfare should automatically disqualify them from amnesty
Come to think about it, undocumented people should not be able to get on welfare in the first place. Doing so is just another law breaking and further disqualifying act.
 
For instance, kids brought here by parents who grow up and are otherwise law abiding members of society contributing to it.

This is exactly true, So the "Parents" take the risk, being an illegal, bringing and or bearing a child in the US. And when the laws become enforced, they are dealt with a moral dilemma, And then a matter of Law.

Am I supposed to feel bad that the parent and child get separated, became they made the choice to violate the law?


Non Citizens coming to this country to get medical attention because their country is lack luster........ Is America the only country accepting citizens and providing top notch medical care? Asian Countries like, Japan, Hong Kong, Euro countries, like Britain, Germany other countries, Australia etc etc...

Why is it a big deal, if we want to enforce our rules and protect our people.... from those that violated our nations laws.
 
Come to think about it, undocumented people should not be able to get on welfare in the first place. Doing so is just another law breaking and further disqualifying act.

its usually through their children or using fake id's
 
Suddenlty the terribly urgent migrant ban which was a crisis matter of national security has been quietly postponed. Could it be that the SCROTUS wants to bask in the warm glow of a positive headline or two for a little longer?
 
An illegal alien female with a child born in American can quqlify for welfare
That may be, I am not that familiar with welfare qualifications and that is why tweaking is needed as is a case by case evaluation. The underlying principle that law braking can not be rewarded is sound.
 
For illegal aliens citizenship should never happen

A lifetme greencard is more than generous for immiogration cheats

I can live with that.
 
You know there a chinese women who fly to America just to have their baby and obtain citizenship

That has to stop

Why? How many are there?
 
I know some ICE people. Here's one of my buddy's favorite lines.

Illegal: "Oficial, this is unfair. I've been living here for 20 years. I have two daughters here and a job."

Agent: "Do you remember when you jumped the border? Yes? Did you ever think that there might come a day when the US federales showed up at your door to deport you?"

Illegal: "Si, senor."

Agent: "Well, today is that day. Put your shoes on and let's go."
 
Why? How many are there?

Enough to catch the attention of the LA Times

Asian 'anchor babies': Wealthy Chinese come to Southern California to give birth - LA Times

It's called "maternity tourism."

Pregnant women travel to the United States, usually on tourist visas, so that their children will be born U.S. citizens. In Southern California, they often live with other pregnant women in suburban homes.

Maternity tourism is particularly popular with wealthy women from China.
 
Back
Top Bottom