• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Business owners stand by decision to fire workers who protested

Praxas

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Sep 10, 2016
Messages
22,399
Reaction score
11,866
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
(CNN)Jim Serowski said his employees told him they planned to skip work on Thursday to participate in "A Day Without Immigrants," the nationwide day of protest.

Serowski, founder of JVS Masonry in Commerce City, Colorado, said his message to them was clear and unwavering:
"If you're going to stand up for what you believe in you have to be willing to pay the price."
As promised, when his foreman and some 30 brick layers failed to show up for work he fired them all with no regrets, he said.
He insisted it had nothing to do with politics and everything to do with business.
"I stand by what I believe in. I didn't do anything wrong," he said in a phone interview Sunday.
"They were warned, 'if you do this you're hurting the company, and if you go against the team you're not a member of the team.'"
As US President Donald Trump continues his tough stances on immigration, people skipped work on Thursday and businesses closed to show how much immigrants contribute to the nation's economy.
Others, including Serowski, responded with pink slips to employees who took the day off.
His foreman told CNN affiliate KDVR that it was important for him and his workers to join the protest. Some of his masonry workers have relatives who are afraid to leave their homes out of fear they may get arrested or deported, he said.
But Serowski said it was a slap in the face to people like him who have long supported immigrant labor. He's known many of his employees for nearly two decades, ensuring they were paid when he did not have work for them.
"I've gone above and beyond for these people," he said, seemingly distraught. "No one is going to dictate how my company is run."
Bill McNally, owner of "I Don't Care Bar and Grill" in Catoosa, Oklahoma, said his 12 line cooks gave him no heads up that they planned to participate in the day of action. They didn't even call to say they were not coming in.
Consequently, he said they were fired just like anyone else who's a no-show for work.
"I'm on their side but we have rules at "I Don't Care Bar and Grill." If you're going to be late call in. If you're not coming to work call us. That's the American way," he said.

Six of the fired Hispanic immigrant workers told CNN affiliate KTUL they felt they had been unfairly terminated. They wanted to stand in solidarity with other immigrants but they did not think it would cost them their jobs, a translator for the group told KTUL.

Under US labor law, workers can be fired with no warning and no reason given.

McNally also insisted it had nothing to do with politics. Had he known about the protests he said he would have closed the restaurant in solidarity.

Why fire them, then?

"They just forgot about the 50 other people who work here," he said. "If the cooks don't show up then servers don't have jobs and customers can't eat."

Business owners stand by decision to fire protesters - CNN.com

Can't say I blame the owners on this one at all. I understand the need that some people have to protest but when it's done like this you also have to be prepared to accept the consequences.
 
Getting back to the topic I doubt if any business will close because latinos refuse to show up for work

But we may see stories in coming days of tearful Latinos who were fired for not showing up for fork

He shoots...he scores. The prediction...beautiful.

Bravo!
 
It was a hot mess of a protest and nothing was accomplished. If you skipped work without getting the okay to take the day off, then you also have to face tue consequences.
 
Yep. I support the workers' right to protest. And I support the employers' right to fire them. And I support the customers' right to boycott or patronize an establishment for doing the firing. Free market beeyatches. :)
 
Protests are a very important part of a free society and likewise a check on over reach and or abuse. More people should protest that which deprives them o what they feel they have a right to. However no protest should be done at anyone else's expense.
 
curious about the 30 terminated brick layers
wonder how many of their names appear on the e-verify database
ditto for the names of their 30 replacements
 
When I attend protest its always on my scheduled day off, as do most folks. Looking forward to the next two scheduled protest, already booked my time off!!
 
Any of the employees who are illegal immigrants will be pushed to the front of the line for welfare so I doubt they're going to suffer to harshly.
 
When I attend protest its always on my scheduled day off, as do most folks. Looking forward to the next two scheduled protest, already booked my time off!!

And that's fine, you're doing it exactly right. I commend you for being responsible in your actions.
 
And that's fine, you're doing it exactly right. I commend you for being responsible in your actions.

Peaceful protest, letters to our elected officials, and voting in Nov 2018 are the proper way to protest Trumps policies. Sen Warren has quite a collection of letters from me, and I have a couple of hers.
 
I would love to see follow up reports on who gets hired to replace the fired workers. It's probably a long shot that it will ever be reported.
 
Protests are a very important part of a free society and likewise a check on over reach and or abuse. More people should protest that which deprives them o what they feel they have a right to. However no protest should be done at anyone else's expense.

Unfortunately, if something is gained at someone else's expense then it can't be a right. It is a privilege. If you replace the word "right" in your post with "privilege", then it will make sense.
 
Peaceful protest, letters to our elected officials, and voting in Nov 2018 are the proper way to protest Trumps policies. Sen Warren has quite a collection of letters from me, and I have a couple of hers.

The protest wasn't peaceful?
 
Unfortunately, if something is gained at someone else's expense then it can't be a right. It is a privilege. If you replace the word "right" in your post with "privilege", then it will make sense.
You did not understand the post. It needs no correction. I did not advocate anything at someone's expense.
 
When I attend protest its always on my scheduled day off, as do most folks. Looking forward to the next two scheduled protest, already booked my time off!!

Damn, forward thinking. It's amazing how good it works, isn't it?
 
Damn, forward thinking. It's amazing how good it works, isn't it?

Uhm ya I guess, if I want time off I book it off, my boss knows I am politically active, and he works with me.
 
Uhm ya I guess, if I want time off I book it off, my boss knows I am politically active, and he works with me.

What someone does after work isn't the boss's business, as long as it's legal.
 
I will disagree with you, but that's for another topic.

You would disagree with me that it is your own business with what you do with your private time? That's baffling.
 
And that's fine, you're doing it exactly right. I commend you for being responsible in your actions.

To me it's a no brainer. The protest are arranged weeks, sometimes months in advance, no different than if you want any other requested time off.
 
You would disagree with me that it is your own business with what you do with your private time? That's baffling.

I would have to examine each case on its merits, I will not give a blanket judgment.
 
Back
Top Bottom