- Joined
- Jul 31, 2014
- Messages
- 4,230
- Reaction score
- 1,605
- Location
- San Diego
- Gender
- Undisclosed
- Political Leaning
- Undisclosed
Barely and only circumspectly a response to the post (reposted below). That is pretty desperate.
So, still cannot honestly come out and defend your apparently indefensible opinion with a direct answer.
I have answered your question: The rights of both citizens need to be observed, both the one perceived to be committing the crime and the one perceived to be the victim of the crime. If there is a need for justice, let the justice system be the arbiter not the vigilante.
In a sense, yes. It helped to determine who my parents were, it helped to build the hospital I was born in, it helped to educate the doctor who performed my birth, etc.When you were born, did the government tell you when to enter the world?
I am a product of society.
I'm not even sure why you decided to use that completely irrelevant analogy, but good luck with it. No one was murdered. An officer or citizen that kills their attacker, it's not murder. It's JUSTIFIABLE HOMICIDE. It is legal in all 50 states and federally. It means you have the right to defend yourself with lethal force, when someone is already attacking you with lethal force. Grabbing and trying to shoot a police officer with their gun is 100% that category. It means the savage criminal (brown) caused his own death.
I hope this helped clear up your confusion/ignorance of the way our society works.
I understand what the law considers "justifiable homicide." This isn't an argument over me not having a basic understanding of our law, it's a difference of opinion on the validity of the law.
He knows and believes that law is unConstitutional. This is what he believes and he makes no attempt to deny it:
He believes that it is a miscarriage of justice and that the attacker should be allowed to kill and THEN be tried in the courts.
I don't believe the attacker should be allowed to kill, I just disagree about what constitutes self defense.
She can be defended without killing citizens.At the point that some (bleep!) attacks a woman and someone is near enough to help her.