• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Driver records CHP officer punching woman[W:195]

Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

I don't want to see lies, and so I don't see them, that's true. I don't see racism, I don't see excessive force. I see a woman walking on a freeway and resisting a cop trying to stop her. That's all there is to it.

Alright guys, one guy is Blind! Time to packup all sense and debate! He's clearly right as he refuses reason! :roll:

Unless, as a new meme introduced to me in the Basement, he's a Poe.

In which case? Very ****ing well done Jerry, the best I've ever seen.
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

" cop delivers a few more hits"
I count 8 punches start to finish. 2, she still resisted, another 2, she still resisted, then 4, then she's cuffed.

 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

The official narrative from CHP is that the officer was protecting and trying to subdue the woman so that she wouldn't walk out into the freeway traffic and get hurt. BS.

I defy ANYONE to watch that video and tell me he looks like he is trying to protect this woman.
He was intent on punishing her... nothing else.

Then he did an absolutely horrid job of it since she wasn't injured by his assaults.
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

I count 8 punches start to finish. 2, she still resisted, another 2, she still resisted, then 4, then she's cuffed.



Define resistance.

If I resist an officer hitting me in the Goddamn face or other bodily parts, is that resistance? In which case the Pig definition of resistance requires a national outcry, or as I posited at the begining of this thread a complete genocide against pretender "Law Enforcement" of America.
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

Hmm..

If "resisting" = "instinctual protection of my face from punches", then whoever came up with that bull**** definition....words fail.
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

Well, they didn't get their asses kicked because they were behaving...that's just reality.

There's always a reason. That doesn't mean it's always an acceptable reason.
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

Hmm..

If "resisting" = "instinctual protection of my face from punches", then whoever came up with that bull**** definition....words fail.

Running from the cop, pushing against his effort to get you off the freeway, not letting him cuff you...
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

I don't want to see lies, and so I don't see them, that's true. I don't see racism, I don't see excessive force. I see a woman walking on a freeway and resisting a cop trying to stop her. That's all there is to it.

We just disagree then. Please don't tell me you are a police officer?
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

Running from the cop, pushing against his effort to get you off the freeway, not letting him cuff you...
All that would be a form of resistance.

Covering your face against punches is not.

If you're going to argue that covering of the face while a cop punches it = not letting the cop cuff you, I'm going to laugh directly in your face.
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman


"the refusal to accept or comply with something; the attempt to prevent something by action or argument."

The refusal to "the refusal to accept or comply with something", something equalling getting your face getting beaten in!

WOW, GREAT LINK!

Thanks for Supporting My Argument :D!
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

Since you've never had your ass kicked by a cop, do you think it might have something to do with you not giving them a reason to kick your ass?

Ya know. I thought maybe it was me. I thought maybe I failed to post my question. But, no, no, I checked three times the question is clearly there.

Take three...

Do you give the same "innocent until proven guilty" consideration to all, or just the police?
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

All that would be a form of resistance.

Covering your face against punches is not.

If you're going to argue that covering of the face while a cop punches it = not letting the cop cuff you, I'm going to laugh directly in your face.
I never argued that covering of the face was resistance. I was referring to her not letting him cuff her.
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

I never argued that covering of the face was resistance. I was referring to her not letting him cuff her.
Since the only thing in my post (which you were responding to) was me specifically referencing her covering her face, I assumed you were responding to that.

Apparently my post was just a convenient springboard.

My mistake.
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

Ya know. I thought maybe it was me. I thought maybe I failed to post my question. But, no, no, I checked three times the question is clearly there.

Take three...

Do you give the same "innocent until proven guilty" consideration to all, or just the police?

ok, the police and the women are both innocent. :mrgreen:

Let's turn your question around and back to you:

Do you give the same "innocent until proven guilty" consideration to all, or just anyone not a police officer?

We don't know the full story. What we know is what the media has reported. I prefer to wait until the investigation is done.
Even then investigations need to be looked at with a critical eye to ensure it represents just the facts and the conclusions are supported by the facts.
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

"the refusal to accept or comply with something; the attempt to prevent something by action or argument."

The refusal to "the refusal to accept or comply with something", something equalling getting your face getting beaten in!

WOW, GREAT LINK!

Thanks for Supporting My Argument :D!

Except that wasn't really what happened, given that the woman received no injuries, even to her face. He stopped punching her as soon as her guard dropped. This seems to indicate that he was using the punches to break her defensive stance so he could actually get a hold of her in order to arrest her. Otherwise, a 190 lb man (who likely has some pretty decent punching strength) punching a 140lb woman (estimating both weights, just know the guy was bigger than that woman) would have caused actual injuries to her by punching her in the face or the head about 10 times.

The outrage to this is honestly due to the "shocking the public consciousness". This is not something the public thinks about happening, so it is "shocking" to see something like this.

I asked before and didn't get an answer from anyone. What if the cop had only hit her one or two times? What if it was a man rather than a woman in the same circumstances? What if the genders were switched completely? What if it was a civilian (of either gender) who was trying to "save" the woman, who then started hitting the civilian "helper" and that civilian did the same thing to the woman? Would the reaction from the public have been so bad if the same thing had resulted, no actual injury to the person?
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

Except that wasn't really what happened, given that the woman received no injuries, even to her face. He stopped punching her as soon as her guard dropped. This seems to indicate that he was using the punches to break her defensive stance so he could actually get a hold of her in order to arrest her. Otherwise, a 190 lb man (who likely has some pretty decent punching strength) punching a 140lb woman (estimating both weights, just know the guy was bigger than that woman) would have caused actual injuries to her by punching her in the face or the head about 10 times.

The outrage to this is honestly due to the "shocking the public consciousness". This is not something the public thinks about happening, so it is "shocking" to see something like this.

I asked before and didn't get an answer from anyone. What if the cop had only hit her one or two times? What if it was a man rather than a woman in the same circumstances? What if the genders were switched completely? What if it was a civilian (of either gender) who was trying to "save" the woman, who then started hitting the civilian "helper" and that civilian did the same thing to the woman? Would the reaction from the public have been so bad if the same thing had resulted, no actual injury to the person?
So far as I am aware, we don't know the answers to most of that yet.

I
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

Except that wasn't really what happened, given that the woman received no injuries, even to her face. He stopped punching her as soon as her guard dropped. This seems to indicate that he was using the punches to break her defensive stance so he could actually get a hold of her in order to arrest her. Otherwise, a 190 lb man (who likely has some pretty decent punching strength) punching a 140lb woman (estimating both weights, just know the guy was bigger than that woman) would have caused actual injuries to her by punching her in the face or the head about 10 times.

The outrage to this is honestly due to the "shocking the public consciousness". This is not something the public thinks about happening, so it is "shocking" to see something like this.

I asked before and didn't get an answer from anyone. What if the cop had only hit her one or two times? What if it was a man rather than a woman in the same circumstances? What if the genders were switched completely? What if it was a civilian (of either gender) who was trying to "save" the woman, who then started hitting the civilian "helper" and that civilian did the same thing to the woman? Would the reaction from the public have been so bad if the same thing had resulted, no actual injury to the person?

50lbs pounds of pure muscle makes a big difference.

When I was ~142 pounds I held a guy's arms (individual) who EASILY weighed 250+ pounds in my hands, who was on top of me and willing to smash my face in arm-to-arm and he couldn't touch me because I held his fists as bay. Not because I was smarter, not because I was braver, not because of superior technique, but because my body had learned to from previous experience (getting jumped by +10 people) to dump ENERMOUS amounts of adrenline in my system.

To this very day I cannot THINK, sincerely, I'm going to get into a fight and then the opposition backs down without getting a tremendous down-swing of adrenline causing me to be sick, puke and angry for 30-90 minutes.

I would literally rather get the **** kicked out of me by 4 guys than have some punk bitch make me think I'm about to get in a fight, have my adrenline pump (and it always does full stream when I start) AND THEN back out. I cannot describe it to you, but it's like getting the severity of the flu crunched into an extremely short time horizon (30-90 minutes, as I said).

ANYWAYS:

"I asked before and didn't get an answer from anyone. What if the cop had only hit her one or two times?"

He didn't. So how does that have absolutely any ****ing bearing on this discussion? I can understand why No One responded to it. It's ****ing stupid.

"What if the genders were switched completely?"

Then the weight difference probably would have justified the additional use of force.

But to put it in a Feminist perspective:

#Biologyisn'treal-creationismftw!

"What if it was a civilian (of either gender) who was trying to "save" the woman, who then started hitting the civilian "helper" and that civilian did the same thing to the woman? "

What if a Pixy flew in and turned the Police Officer into a Pig!??!

Stupid Questions.

You should learn to Think before you type.
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

So far as I am aware, we don't know the answers to most of that yet.

I

Most of what yet? We know that the woman was not injured. This has been reported already.

Video shows California Highway Patriol officer punching woman on Los Angeles freeway - WXYZ.com

"O'Quinn says the woman, who would not give her name, was not injured and is undergoing psychiatric evaluation."

The questions were actually looking for what the reactions would have been had those other things been part of the situation or what occurred. It is to show that this is much more about the "shock" factor to the public than about what actually occurred. It may very well have been unwarranted, but the majority of the public reaction isn't really even taking into account the actual event and saying from just the bit of video we have that this was unwarranted. They aren't even taking into account the fact that the cop could not possibly have been throwing full force punches if she wasn't injured at all. That means he didn't just "lose control", because he had to be controlling at least a little to have not thrown punches that would do injury.
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

Moderator's Warning:
Moderator action is pending.

In the meantime, the trolling, personal comments and baiting need to stop now. Those who make off-topic and baiting remarks after this point, risk being booted, possibly with points.
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

Moderator's Warning:
Moderator action is pending.

In the meantime, the trolling, personal comments and baiting need to stop now. Those who make off-topic and baiting remarks after this point, risk being booted, possibly with points.

Oh yes, because expressing our opinions we're trolling.

Hell, I'll probably be banned for trolling an admin:

Ignoring the fact I can just scramble my IP and come back up a different name and avatar :roll:
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

50lbs pounds of pure muscle makes a big difference.

When I was ~142 pounds I held a guy's arms (individual) who EASILY weighed 250+ pounds in my hands, who was on top of me and willing to smash my face in arm-to-arm and he couldn't touch me because I held his fists as bay. Not because I was smarter, not because I was braver, not because of superior technique, but because my body had learned to from previous experience (getting jumped by +10 people) to dump ENERMOUS amounts of adrenline in my system.

To this very day I cannot THINK, sincerely, I'm going to get into a fight and then the opposition backs down without getting a tremendous down-swing of adrenline causing me to be sick, puke and angry for 30-90 minutes.

I would literally rather get the **** kicked out of me by 4 guys than have some punk bitch make me think I'm about to get in a fight, have my adrenline pump (and it always does full stream when I start) AND THEN back out. I cannot describe it to you, but it's like getting the severity of the flu crunched into an extremely short time horizon (30-90 minutes, as I said).

ANYWAYS:

"I asked before and didn't get an answer from anyone. What if the cop had only hit her one or two times?"

He didn't. So how does that have absolutely any ****ing bearing on this discussion? I can understand why No One responded to it. It's ****ing stupid.

"What if the genders were switched completely?"

Then the weight difference probably would have justified the additional use of force.

But to put it in a Feminist perspective:

#Biologyisn'treal-creationismftw!

"What if it was a civilian (of either gender) who was trying to "save" the woman, who then started hitting the civilian "helper" and that civilian did the same thing to the woman? "

What if a Pixy flew in and turned the Police Officer into a Pig!??!

Stupid Questions.

You should learn to Think before you type.

I thought about these very thoroughly.

The first one points out that many of those punches didn't hit her face or head, but rather her hands and arms, and still did not cause injury even to those. Any punches to her head and face also did not cause injury (as is being reported right now) eventhough we can see that he would have been able to injure her severely given the size difference, the mental awareness differences, and the physical ability differences between them, yet he didn't. He stopped as soon as it appeared that he could actually restrain her, even when she hit him a few more times as the other officer showed up.

The next one is to point out that a scrawny, crazy man isn't going to be any more likely to have an advantage over a CHP officer (or this CHP officer at least) than this woman.

The last one, which you completely ignored was pointing out that the public outrage to this is more due to this being a male police officer (not sure which is more "shocking") than the repeated punching itself.
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

I thought about these very thoroughly.

The first one points out that many of those punches didn't hit her face or head, but rather her hands and arms, and still did not cause injury even to those. Any punches to her head and face also did not cause injury (as is being reported right now) eventhough we can see that he would have been able to injure her severely given the size difference, the mental awareness differences, and the physical ability differences between them, yet he didn't. He stopped as soon as it appeared that he could actually restrain her, even when she hit him a few more times as the other officer showed up.

The next one is to point out that a scrawny, crazy man isn't going to be any more likely to have an advantage over a CHP officer (or this CHP officer at least) than this woman.

The last one, which you completely ignored was pointing out that the public outrage to this is more due to this being a male police officer (not sure which is more "shocking") than the repeated punching itself.

"even when she hit him a few more times as the other officer showed up. "

Self-Defense = Illegal in the United States.

God, I can't wait to dump all my college loan debts on this ****hole and move back to Nicaragua.

As ****ed up as we are, at least you can defend yourself.

"The last one, which you completely ignored was pointing out that the public outrage to this is more due to this being a male police officer (not sure which is more "shocking") than the repeated punching itself."

I'm sorry, I have an Actual Constitution about me that Precludes me from Beating Women but allows me to Beat the Dog **** out of Full Grown Men.

Must be My Piss-Poor Up-Bringing. :roll:

Anyways, I'll probably get banned from this thread since the admins seem to have a hard-on for me.
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

ok, the police and the women are both innocent. :mrgreen:

Let's turn your question around and back to you:

Do you give the same "innocent until proven guilty" consideration to all, or just anyone not a police officer?

We don't know the full story. What we know is what the media has reported. I prefer to wait until the investigation is done.
Even then investigations need to be looked at with a critical eye to ensure it represents just the facts and the conclusions are supported by the facts.
That's great, but the person I was interacting with and I have already been through all that. I'm just trying find out if he routinely and reflexively gives suspects the same noble-sounding benefit of the doubt that he gives police officers as he is doing in this case.
 
Re: Driver records CHP officer punching woman

I'm not at all convinced that she is not injured.
Marlene Pinnock. is being held for psychiatric and physical observation and they will not even let her family see her.
CHP is saying she was not injured.
 
Back
Top Bottom