• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors [W:24]

On that front it's really kind of simple...nota already did the research that it isn't law to report in PA, (I don't think that is proper) but be that the case there is an ethical component to this...If a Doctor at PP, was aware that Gosnell was killing live babies in his clinic then as a physician he has an obligation to report it.

We have laws in this country that if you know of a crime being committed and you don't report it, then you are also guilty of a crime....It's called accessory.

You still haven't answered the question: What were they going to report?

PP: "Attention authorities!!! Someone said something bad is going on at Gosnell's clinic"
 
You still haven't answered the question: What were they going to report?

PP: "Attention authorities!!! Someone said something bad is going on at Gosnell's clinic"

Yes. Exactly...That's is how it works.
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

Really...unborn babies are exactly that unborn babies...Dr Mengele would fit right in with those who defend killing them for convenience...

All you are doing is targetting emotion and it's blocking any ability you may have for logic. This is constitutionally settled law as per the Supreme Court and has been for decades. Your beef against PP or Women's health issues and abortion overall is just emotional whining garbage...


It's not murder. It's not Dr Mengele blah blah wahhh... the Supreme Court has told you so.
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

All you are doing is targetting emotion and it's blocking any ability you may have for logic. This is constitutionally settled law as per the Supreme Court and has been for decades. Your beef against PP or Women's health issues and abortion overall is just emotional whining garbage...


It's not murder. It's not Dr Mengele blah blah wahhh... the Supreme Court has told you so.

So the Supreme Court never reverses its decisions? Using that kind of logic, Dred Scott would still be law of the land.
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

So the Supreme Court never reverses its decisions? Using that kind of logic, Dred Scott would still be law of the land.

Have they reversed it? No? Then it's the law of the land. So until it is reversed you just gotta get over it just like I have to do with the People's United ruling.

The thing about this thread is that it's attempting to lie about the constitution (being that it has been determined by the SCOTUS that it is the law of the land) by calling those who abide by the law of the land murderers and genociders and nazi comparisons and all that bull****.
 
Here is a list of 10 reversed SCOTUS rulings...

10. Lochner v. New York (1905) and Adkins v. Children's Hospital (1923)
9.
Chisholm v. Georgia (1793)
8.
Adler v. Board of Education (1952)
7.
Bowers v. Hardwick (1986)
6.
Pace v. Alabama (1883)
5.
Austin v. Michigan State Chamber of Commerce (1990)
4.
Oregon v. Mitchell (1970)
3.
Wolf v. Colorado (1949)
2.
Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857)
1.
Plessy v. Ferguson

HowStuffWorks "10 Overturned Supreme Court Cases"

Overturning SC rulings is not unprecedented....
 
Here is a list of 10 reversed SCOTUS rulings...

10. Lochner v. New York (1905) and Adkins v. Children's Hospital (1923)
9.
Chisholm v. Georgia (1793)
8.
Adler v. Board of Education (1952)
7.
Bowers v. Hardwick (1986)
6.
Pace v. Alabama (1883)
5.
Austin v. Michigan State Chamber of Commerce (1990)
4.
Oregon v. Mitchell (1970)
3.
Wolf v. Colorado (1949)
2.
Dred Scott v. Sandford (1857)
1.
Plessy v. Ferguson

HowStuffWorks "10 Overturned Supreme Court Cases"

Overturning SC rulings is not unprecedented....

Awesome. Who are you talking to?

Also... you could've just pointed to prohibition.
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

So the Supreme Court never reverses its decisions? Using that kind of logic, Dred Scott would still be law of the land.

And maybe someday SCOTUS will say it's not murder to kill the moral fascists who dishonestly call abortion "murder" :roll:

It's not murder. That is the law.

Get over it.
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

Have they reversed it? No? Then it's the law of the land. So until it is reversed you just gotta get over it just like I have to do with the People's United ruling.

Saying that is like saying that no one should oppose this wrongful ruling...Ya know, for an agent promoting social change, you sure show that it is only the change you want that matters....It may be law for now....for now.

The thing about this thread is that it's subverting the constitution (being that it has been determined by the SCOTUS that it is the law of the land) by calling those who abide by the law of the land murderers and genociders and nazi comparisons and all that bull****.

If you think that Gosnell is wrongly on trial after killing 6 born babies by cutting their spines, and one adult woman through malpractice, then all I can say is that I have pity for you.
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

And maybe someday SCOTUS will say it's not murder to kill the moral fascists who dishonestly call abortion "murder" :roll:

It's not murder. That is the law.

Get over it.

So now you want to kill those who disagree with your viewpoints? I don't have to get over it...Free speech remember? Get over it.
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

Saying that is like saying that no one should oppose this wrongful ruling...Ya know, for an agent promoting social change, you sure show that it is only the change you want that matters....It may be law for now....for now.



If you think that Gosnell is wrongly on trial after killing 6 born babies by cutting their spines, and one adult woman through malpractice, then all I can say is that I have pity for you.

The fact is, even if they overturn it, the abortions that have been performed will still not be murder.

IOW, calling it murder is, in fact, a lie. Once again, the abortion banners are trying to prove that they are morally superior by lying about abortion.
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

So now you want to kill those who disagree with your viewpoints? I don't have to get over it...Free speech remember? Get over it.

That's true. There's no law that makes telling a lie a crime.
 
Awesome. Who are you talking to?

Also... you could've just pointed to prohibition.

Prohibition was a Constitutional amendment that was reversed through another Constitutional amendment....See, that is how it is supposed to work....Not a body of 9 unelected judges for life making law from the bench. You should know the difference.
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

That's true. There's no law that makes telling a lie a crime.

I don't believe I have lied about anything, you'll have to point that out....
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

That's true. There's no law that makes telling a lie a crime.

Depends on the circumstances. Ever hear about perjury, libel, and slander?
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

I don't believe I have lied about anything, you'll have to point that out....

I don't believe I said you lied. If I have, you'll have to point that out
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

Depends on the circumstances. Ever hear about perjury, libel, and slander?

Not the same. All of those require more than merely telling a lie, and I'm pretty sure the last two are not crimes.
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

The fact is, even if they overturn it, the abortions that have been performed will still not be murder.

IOW, calling it murder is, in fact, a lie. Once again, the abortion banners are trying to prove that they are morally superior by lying about abortion.

We are not arguing the parameters of when life begins here....This is a case of a Doctor that had the babies born alive, and killed them after birth. Not to mention that the abortion services he was offering after 24 weeks are against the law....Plus, an adult woman died due to his malpractice....Gosnell is a serial killer.
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

I don't believe I said you lied. If I have, you'll have to point that out

Really?

I said

j-mac said:
...Free speech remember? Get over it.

You responded

sangha said:
That's true. There's no law that makes telling a lie a crime.

So, who were you talking to then?
 
Last edited:
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

We are not arguing the parameters of when life begins here....This is a case of a Doctor that had the babies born alive, and killed them after birth. Not to mention that the abortion services he was offering after 24 weeks are against the law....Plus, an adult woman died due to his malpractice....Gosnell is a serial killer.

This post of yours is dishonest. You most certainly did argue that the parameters the law uses is "wrong". You were referring to Roe v Wade, and not the Gosnell case.
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

You just misquoted me, which is dishonest

No, I am afraid not....I quoted the wrong response from you, but then changed it to the correct one...Did you not type what I posted?
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

This post of yours is dishonest. You most certainly did argue that the parameters the law uses is "wrong". You were referring to Roe v Wade, and not the Gosnell case.

I believe the law was decided wrongly. However, this thread is NOT about Roe. That doesn't mean that when the discussion involves Roe, I can respond to it, just as I can try and bring the topic of the thread back to what it is rather than let those dishonestly trying to derail the thread get away with it....So, stay on topic.
 
Re: Planned Parenthood Knew of Gosnell's Abortion Horrors

Saying that is like saying that no one should oppose this wrongful ruling...Ya know, for an agent promoting social change, you sure show that it is only the change you want that matters....It may be law for now....for now.



If you think that Gosnell is wrongly on trial after killing 6 born babies by cutting their spines, and one adult woman through malpractice, then all I can say is that I have pity for you.

don't know Gosnell. Anywhoo... this thread isn't about the SCOTUS ruling. It's about calling people abiding by the SCOTUS ruling criminals. It's a load-a-crap.
 
Back
Top Bottom