• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Israel gave birth control to Ethiopian Jews without their consent [W:283,569]

Perhaps the woman quoted was too malnurished to give birth. The immigrants of 1991 weren't exactly in great shape, running from war in Ethiopia.

ONE MORE TIER!

"Those lying black bastards from Ethiopia were simply too malnourished to give birth for 40 years!".
 
You know that physicians will OFTEN try to coax women into doing things that they think are the right choice. Perhaps some of these women had 4, 5, 6 or more children? A lot of times doctors will advise that you not have more children if you have had that many because of many different complications that can arise due to weakening of the uterus and supportive structures. So to assume that there some kind of "population control" at hand is kind of silly IMO.

As first generation immigrants, they were coming from a country with a fertility rate of 6 to one of 3. Their fertility/birth rate coming in line with Israel's ("dropping in half") over 10 years seems reasonable. The average woman going from 6 births to 3 could just be a matter of time, the prevention of having 8 or more children and things omitted from the calculation.
 
Last edited:
Well...



That's probably actually vaccinations and they could not travel to Israel without them. There's no evidence to link this to contraception shots, it's just a disjointed story line that's trying to imply what is not stated.

AND AGAIN!

"Forced contraception preventing little black half Jewish babies were part of the overall vaccination program of the State of Israel for black half Jewish shiksas coming from Ethiopia!"
 
Last edited:
ONE MORE TIER!

"Those lying black bastards from Ethiopia were simply too malnourished to give birth for 40 years!".

The women interviewed spoke of travelling from Ethiopia to Israel. They are from 1991 or earlier? How can we look at figures of "in the past 10 years" unless they are 1991 arrivals? Perhaps they're earlier arrivals, then what do their daughters have to say?
 
You know that physicians will OFTEN try to coax women into doing things that they think are the right choice. Perhaps some of these women had 4, 5, 6 or more children? A lot of times doctors will advise that you not have more children if you have had that many because of many different complications that can arise due to weakening of the uterus and supportive structures. So to assume that there some kind of "population control" at hand is kind of silly IMO.

Let's keep the ball rolling!

"It was those dastardly Israeli doctors from the Israeli Ministry of Health trying to help poor black women with fertile ovaries from being fertile all over the precious white State of Israel!"
 
As first generation immigrants, they were coming from a country with a fertility rate of 6 to one of 3. Their fertility/birth rate coming in line with Israel's ("dropping in half") over 10 years seems reasonable. The average woman going from 6 births to 3 could just be a matter of time, the prevention of having 8 or more children and things omitted from the calculation.

ROOM FOR ONE MORE!

"It's not eugenics, it's MATH!"
 
Let's keep the ball rolling!

"It was those dastardly Israeli doctors from the Israeli Ministry of Health trying to help poor black women with fertile ovaries from being fertile all over the precious white State of Israel!"

Hey, I don't know if that's the reason, but it's certainly no more outrageous than the crap you're spewing. :lamo
 
As first generation immigrants, they were coming from a country with a fertility rate of 6 to one of 3. Their birth rate coming in line with Israel's ("dropping in half") over 10 years seems reasonable. The average woman going from 6 births to 3 could just be a matter of time, the prevention of having 8 or more children and things omitted from the calculation.

I thought about this earlier, but I would say you don't see the same drastic changes in the developing world, with rural people moving into urban centers where the dynamics surrounding birth rates are drastically different. Of course, here the women would be getting introduced to a rather well run state health and education system
 
The women interviewed spoke of travelling from Ethiopia to Israel. They are from 1991 or earlier? How can we look at figures of "in the past 10 years" unless they are 1991 arrivals? Perhaps they're earlier arrivals, then what do their daughters have to say?

THIS ONE MAKES NO SENSE!

"It's not just eugenics, it's GENERATIONAL eugenics, which you know, makes it okay."
 
As first generation immigrants, they were coming from a country with a fertility rate of 6 to one of 3. Their fertility/birth rate coming in line with Israel's ("dropping in half") over 10 years seems reasonable. The average woman going from 6 births to 3 could just be a matter of time, the prevention of having 8 or more children and things omitted from the calculation.

What these women really need is an education on why it is unhealthy for them not only financially but health wise to birth so many children, and they need to be educated not to be afraid of birth control too.
 
I thought about this earlier, but I would say you don't see the same drastic changes in the developing world, with rural people moving into urban centers where the dynamics surrounding birth rates are drastically different. Of course, here the women would be getting introduced to a rather well run state health and education system

WE'RE ON A ROLL!

"it's not eugenics, it's "a well run state health and education system!"
 
My reference was not directed at any one post or poster. It was just intended to soften the rhetoric.

In modern times, we refuse to sterilize rapists and murderers because of some perceived god given right of endless reproduction. Look how well that's working out.

If the Israelis, who I don't support at all costs, decided to slow the growth of these hapless, uneducated immigrants from one of the worst countries in the world, and embraced them to a much more prosperous nation, I say kudos to them.

"Three generations of imbeciles are enough". Thanks for the quote Mr. F.


The following was typed by my cat Bugaboo:
/.......................................................
6\7gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggkm

Ugh, the fact that my ancestors did something means little to my ability to level criticism in the modern world, especially when I can recognize and argue competently why something is wrong.

At the very least you could have pulled out Holmes' infamous quote: ""Three generations of imbeciles are enough" :shock:
 
WE'RE ON A ROLL!

"it's not eugenics, it's "a well run state health and education system!"

Do you have anything intelligent to add, or are you just going to keep spewing nonsense like some crazy bipolar dude?
 
What these women really need is an education on why it is unhealthy for them not only financially but health wise to birth so many children, and they need to be educated not to be afraid of birth control too.

THIS ONE IS EVEN MORE IDIOTIC!

"It's not forced contraception, black women are too dumb to know too many black babies in Israel is BAD FOR THEIR HEALTH!"
 
WE'RE ON A ROLL!

"it's not eugenics, it's "a well run state health and education system!"

yes, clearly it's unheard of that a woman wouldn't want to pop out children like they were pez, an there isn't a reasonable concern on the part of the state to educate people on the issues involved with a high birth rate.

PS and as usual, I really question if your are reading and comprehending what you respond to
 
Last edited:
THIS ONE MAKES NO SENSE!

"It's not just eugenics, it's GENERATIONAL eugenics, which you know, makes it okay."

I'm saying that the statistic you continue to quote (and one not cite) could have many problems involved in the calculation.
 
My reference was not directed at any one post or poster. It was just intended to soften the rhetoric.

In modern times, we refuse to sterilize rapists and murderers because of some perceived god given right of endless reproduction. Look how well that's working out.

If the Israelis, who I don't support at all costs, decided to slow the growth of these hapless, uneducated immigrants from one of the worst countries in the world, and embraced them to a much more prosperous nation, I say kudos to them.

"Three generations of imbeciles are enough". Thanks for the quote Mr. F.


The following was typed by my cat Bugaboo:
/.......................................................
6\7gggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggggkm

EVEN BETTER!

"Let's compare rapists and murderers to innocent black half Jewish women wishing to immigrate to the People's Republic of Israel!"

And Oh Ya, they're IMBECILES to boot!
 
I thought about this earlier, but I would say you don't see the same drastic changes in the developing world, with rural people moving into urban centers where the dynamics surrounding birth rates are drastically different. Of course, here the women would be getting introduced to a rather well run state health and education system

Here they would experience a drop in infant mortality and death rates and thus undergo the demographic transition. Just like everyone else does and always has when those things happen.
 
Back
Top Bottom