- Joined
- Oct 1, 2005
- Messages
- 38,750
- Reaction score
- 13,845
- Gender
- Undisclosed
- Political Leaning
- Libertarian - Right
"Those most commonly identified as progressives tend to be very left-leaning economically, socially liberal, against corporatism and against neoconservatism."
You're cherry-picking yourself. You said:
Those most commonly identified as progressives tend to be very left-leaning economically, socially liberal, against corporatism and against neoconservatism. However, since anyone can self-identify, there's literally nothing I can say to disqualify Amy Klobuchar or Hillary Clinton.
Which means the "definition" you claim to have given is qualified to the point of uselessness.
Now, FINALLY, after days and dozens of posts, you've committed yourself to something concrete:
I'll go you further:
*snipped for character limit*
So, I'd say "bravo," but it's something you could have done quite a while ago. Why didn't you?
No, you excluded and refused to recognize definitions which opposed your singular definition. Again, you don't seem to understand these basic concepts, and are not motivated in trying to understand them. Let me make it easy for you:
Modern liberalism in the United States - Wikipedia
"Modern liberalism in the United States is the dominant version of liberalism in the United States. It combines ideas of civil liberty and equality with support for social justice and a mixed economy."
...
"The American modern liberal philosophy strongly endorses public spending on programs such as education, health care and welfare. Important social issues during the first part of the 21st century include economic inequality (wealth and income),[5] voting rights for minorities,[6] affirmative action,[7] reproductive and other women's rights,[8] support for LGBT rights[9][10] and immigration reform.[11][12]"
...
Modern liberalism took shape during the 20th century, with roots in Theodore Roosevelt's New Nationalism, Woodrow Wilson's New Freedom, Franklin D. Roosevelt's New Deal, Harry S. Truman's Fair Deal, John F. Kennedy's New Frontier and Lyndon B. Johnson's Great Society. American liberals oppose conservatives on most but not all issues. Modern liberalism is historically related to social liberalism and progressivism, although the current relationship between liberal and progressive viewpoints is debated.
Get it now? Or rather, what DON'T you get?
"Excluded"? How does this conflict with what I said liberalism is:
Yes, liberal is a definable ideology, involving holding individual rights, civil liberties, free enterprise, limited government, the rule of law dear.
Hmmm? Which of those things do liberals, even as you define them here, not believe in? Please choose all that apply.
You're trying to make "liberalism" synonymous with "progressive," but even here you emphasized that "the current relationship between liberal and progressive viewpoints is debated."
Perhaps I went over your head. To borrow from Colbert, if someone is stabbing you with a knife and ultimately kills you, they don't have to scream, 'Murder! Murder! Murder!' in order for it to be murder.
No, but "murder" does require more than just being stabbed with a knife and ultimately killing you.
The point in my quotes, borrowed from your links, is that billionaires and millionaires, and those who take money from such, are heavily invested in virtually every brand of American centrism. That's the point. Do you get it now?
Do you not get that even if this is so, it doesn't mean the definition of "centrist" -- especially as is commonly understood, which was the point -- involves "corporatism"?
No, you link to definitions, and when these links are used to your disadvantage, you flatly claim that nothing but your variant of the definition is applicable. You've done this repeatedly throughout our so-called discussion.
I didn't "flatly claim" anything. What I do say is that my links consistently gave the primary definition as something other than you'd like, and it was you who had to dig deep to find what you wanted.
I challenged you several times, and I'll do it again: What is the difference between Classical Liberalism and Modern Liberalism? Which is the most commonly recognized version used by non-Libertarians?
As I asked, what part of the definition of "liberalism" that I gave do "modern liberals" not believe in?
Not that my ego is invested in our exchange, but I'm dragging you and you don't realize it.
I'm 100% certain you think that's true.