• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

America's shifting religious landscape

Masterhawk

DP Veteran
Joined
May 6, 2016
Messages
1,908
Reaction score
489
Location
Colorado
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
You may have heard that America is a Christian nation. Whether it's true or not, it demonstrates that Christianity has been part of American culture since the beginning. In fact, some of the first settlers were Puritans looking to establish base away from the Church of England. There were also Catholics and Quakers looking to escape persecution. Many of the colonies had state churches at one point. Fast forwarding a couple centuries, the fifties were marked not only by an economic boom but also by a rise of conservatism. The vast majority of Americans were Protestant Christian and this remained true up into the 90s.

If Gallup and Pew Research are anything to go by, Protestantism in the US is in decline, primarily felt among Mainline Protestants. Catholicism has been able to maintain its percentage of around 23%, perhaps having something to do with immigration from Latin America, a predominantly Catholic region. Mormons have maintained their percentage at around 1%, perhaps because of their higher fertility rates or maybe they're just that good at keeping people from leaving or good at attracting new members. In 2010, roughly half of Americans identified as Protestants and in 2018, it was 43%. Since 2009, even the Catholics have seen a bit of decline, going down to 20%. The lack of religion has seen a major increase since the 90s, going from 7% to 16% in 2009 and 23% in 2018.

Newer generations are less religious than older generations, indicating a shift away from religion. In fact, 18-29-year-olds are just as likely to not hold any religious affiliation as they are to be Protestant. Furthermore, older generations have gradually become less religious.

This decline is happening in every region of the US but something interesting is happening in this regard. You see, the Southeastern portion of the US has been a historically religious part of the country (in fact, this region is sometimes referred to as the bible belt). From 2009 to 2018, Christianity fell from 82% to 70% (a fall of 12 points) whereas in the Midwest, it was from 77% to 67% (a fall of 10 points). In the south, the unaffiliated rose from 13% to 23% (a rise of 10 points) as opposed to from 18% to 25% like the midwest. In other words, the midwest may one day be more religious than the south. In contrast to the south, the western US has been a bit less religious with 69% being Christian and 21% being unaffiliated in 2009. Although the west became even less religious, the northeast seems to be challenging the west for the least religious region in the US. In 2009, 74% of northeasterners were Christian and 16% were unaffiliated but in 2018, 59% were Christian and 28% were unaffiliated. This is contrasted with the west which was 60% Christian and 32% unaffiliated.

Another thing that's happening is the emergence of other religions (most likely due to immigration from certain regions). In the northeast, other religions went up from 8% to 11% from 2009 to 2018.

In U.S., Decline of Christianity Continues at Rapid Pace | Pew Research Center
If the U.S. had 100 people: Charting Americans' religious affiliations | Pew Research Center
How America Lost Its Religion - The Atlantic
America's Changing Religious Landscape | Pew Research Center
 
You may have heard that America is a Christian nation. Whether it's true or not, it demonstrates that Christianity has been part of American culture since the beginning. In fact, some of the first settlers were Puritans looking to establish base away from the Church of England. There were also Catholics and Quakers looking to escape persecution. Many of the colonies had state churches at one point. Fast forwarding a couple centuries, the fifties were marked not only by an economic boom but also by a rise of conservatism. The vast majority of Americans were Protestant Christian and this remained true up into the 90s.

If Gallup and Pew Research are anything to go by, Protestantism in the US is in decline, primarily felt among Mainline Protestants. Catholicism has been able to maintain its percentage of around 23%, perhaps having something to do with immigration from Latin America, a predominantly Catholic region. Mormons have maintained their percentage at around 1%, perhaps because of their higher fertility rates or maybe they're just that good at keeping people from leaving or good at attracting new members. In 2010, roughly half of Americans identified as Protestants and in 2018, it was 43%. Since 2009, even the Catholics have seen a bit of decline, going down to 20%. The lack of religion has seen a major increase since the 90s, going from 7% to 16% in 2009 and 23% in 2018.

Newer generations are less religious than older generations, indicating a shift away from religion. In fact, 18-29-year-olds are just as likely to not hold any religious affiliation as they are to be Protestant. Furthermore, older generations have gradually become less religious.

This decline is happening in every region of the US but something interesting is happening in this regard. You see, the Southeastern portion of the US has been a historically religious part of the country (in fact, this region is sometimes referred to as the bible belt). From 2009 to 2018, Christianity fell from 82% to 70% (a fall of 12 points) whereas in the Midwest, it was from 77% to 67% (a fall of 10 points). In the south, the unaffiliated rose from 13% to 23% (a rise of 10 points) as opposed to from 18% to 25% like the midwest. In other words, the midwest may one day be more religious than the south. In contrast to the south, the western US has been a bit less religious with 69% being Christian and 21% being unaffiliated in 2009. Although the west became even less religious, the northeast seems to be challenging the west for the least religious region in the US. In 2009, 74% of northeasterners were Christian and 16% were unaffiliated but in 2018, 59% were Christian and 28% were unaffiliated. This is contrasted with the west which was 60% Christian and 32% unaffiliated.

Another thing that's happening is the emergence of other religions (most likely due to immigration from certain regions). In the northeast, other religions went up from 8% to 11% from 2009 to 2018.

In U.S., Decline of Christianity Continues at Rapid Pace | Pew Research Center
If the U.S. had 100 people: Charting Americans' religious affiliations | Pew Research Center
How America Lost Its Religion - The Atlantic
America's Changing Religious Landscape | Pew Research Center

And?

How do you feel about all that? Do you like it? Are you sad? Is it a positive or negative change? (In your humble opinion of course.)
If you could change something, anything, what would you change?


How does what you posted make you feel? Or how does it effect you?

Give us something to go on here other than some basic facts that many of us have posted multiple times already.

Not picking at you, just looking for something to respond to.
 
You may have heard that America is a Christian nation. Whether it's true or not, it demonstrates that Christianity has been part of American culture since the beginning. In fact, some of the first settlers were Puritans looking to establish base away from the Church of England. There were also Catholics and Quakers looking to escape persecution. Many of the colonies had state churches at one point. Fast forwarding a couple centuries, the fifties were marked not only by an economic boom but also by a rise of conservatism. The vast majority of Americans were Protestant Christian and this remained true up into the 90s.

If Gallup and Pew Research are anything to go by, Protestantism in the US is in decline, primarily felt among Mainline Protestants. Catholicism has been able to maintain its percentage of around 23%, perhaps having something to do with immigration from Latin America, a predominantly Catholic region. Mormons have maintained their percentage at around 1%, perhaps because of their higher fertility rates or maybe they're just that good at keeping people from leaving or good at attracting new members. In 2010, roughly half of Americans identified as Protestants and in 2018, it was 43%. Since 2009, even the Catholics have seen a bit of decline, going down to 20%. The lack of religion has seen a major increase since the 90s, going from 7% to 16% in 2009 and 23% in 2018.

Newer generations are less religious than older generations, indicating a shift away from religion. In fact, 18-29-year-olds are just as likely to not hold any religious affiliation as they are to be Protestant. Furthermore, older generations have gradually become less religious.

This decline is happening in every region of the US but something interesting is happening in this regard. You see, the Southeastern portion of the US has been a historically religious part of the country (in fact, this region is sometimes referred to as the bible belt). From 2009 to 2018, Christianity fell from 82% to 70% (a fall of 12 points) whereas in the Midwest, it was from 77% to 67% (a fall of 10 points). In the south, the unaffiliated rose from 13% to 23% (a rise of 10 points) as opposed to from 18% to 25% like the midwest. In other words, the midwest may one day be more religious than the south. In contrast to the south, the western US has been a bit less religious with 69% being Christian and 21% being unaffiliated in 2009. Although the west became even less religious, the northeast seems to be challenging the west for the least religious region in the US. In 2009, 74% of northeasterners were Christian and 16% were unaffiliated but in 2018, 59% were Christian and 28% were unaffiliated. This is contrasted with the west which was 60% Christian and 32% unaffiliated.

Another thing that's happening is the emergence of other religions (most likely due to immigration from certain regions). In the northeast, other religions went up from 8% to 11% from 2009 to 2018.

In U.S., Decline of Christianity Continues at Rapid Pace | Pew Research Center
If the U.S. had 100 people: Charting Americans' religious affiliations | Pew Research Center
How America Lost Its Religion - The Atlantic
America's Changing Religious Landscape | Pew Research Center

Like Clinton (Bill) drove a stake through feminism when the idiots from NOW defended him instead of Monica, the Trumpster Fire will burn Evangelical Christianity to the ground as the so-called religious defend his countless sins.

Hypocrisy kills. And, few groups on this earth are more hypocritical than US Christians.
 
Like Clinton (Bill) drove a stake through feminism when the idiots from NOW defended him instead of Monica, the Trumpster Fire will burn Evangelical Christianity to the ground as the so-called religious defend his countless sins.

Hypocrisy kills. And, few groups on this earth are more hypocritical than US Christians.

The only thing that seems to matter any more is abortion. Its weird.
 

The internet: Where religions go to die.

Anyone can now go and check the veracity of what their preacher is telling them. It doesn't take long to find out that there is only the very flimsiest "evidence" to justify believing in a magical besty, roughly the same as there is to justify believing in Santa Claus, or the Flying Spaghetti Monster. It quickly becomes evident that these are all just tall tales.

For example Noah, and the Flood. God committed genocide, killing babies, animals, etc. Preachers don't mention that, but the internet does. You can't possibly fit every species on the ark, along with the required food, special diets, etc. How could anything survive on an earth that was under thousands of feet of water for a year? When the ark landed, it would land on a completely dead earth, devoid of any food sources for the animals.

It's like this for almost every claim of Christianity, and now anyone can discover this truth about the bible.
 
The only thing that seems to matter any more is abortion. Its weird.

For the vast majority of Evangelicals, I'm sure it's like every other value Evangelical Christians told us they cherished, and then proved they don't give a **** about: They would drop it in a New York minute if there was a profit to be made.
 
Apostasy
It refers to a general defection from the true God, the Bible, and the Christian faith. Every age has its defectors, but the falling away at the end times will be complete and worldwide. The whole planet will be in rebellion against God and His Christ.

Will there be a great apostasy / falling away during the end times? | GotQuestions.org

You can't rebel against an almost certainly imaginary being.

You might as well try to frighten us with talk about rebelling against Santa Claus, and being put on his "naughty list", because there's same chance of it happening as your Christian nonsense.
 
Apostasy
It refers to a general defection from the true God, the Bible, and the Christian faith. Every age has its defectors, but the falling away at the end times will be complete and worldwide. The whole planet will be in rebellion against God and His Christ.

Will there be a great apostasy / falling away during the end times? | GotQuestions.org
IMO, whining about the “defections” from slobbering fealty to sky daddy and earth boy is as stupid as lamenting that island people “fell away” from human sacrifice to the volcano god.
 
IMO, whining about the “defections” from slobbering fealty to sky daddy and earth boy is as stupid as lamenting that island people “fell away” from human sacrifice to the volcano god.

The bible also has human sacrifice, to Yahweh. Good analogy.


No wonder Christianity is dying so quickly. You can go onto almost any forum, and quickly learn so much about the bible that the preachers never told their sheep. Like human sacrifice to Yahweh, just like the pagan island gods demanded.
 
Last edited:
Nearly all American Christians expect peace, tranquility and reunion with relatives in an afterlife. Belief in heaven has stayed over eight in ten since the late 1960s, while belief in life after death remains roughly in the range of seven in ten, regardless of any belief in God. Belief in hell is somewhat lower still. When John Lennon was asked if he believed in utopia he answered "Isn't this it?" Long term planning: Where will you be 200 yrs from now?

What Americans Believe about the Afterlife – The Last Frontier

Paradise Polled: Americans and the Afterlife | HuffPost

I am just a carbon point in E=Mc2. My energy will carry on. I will not. No soul. No consciousness. The depth of non-cognizant nothingness. Most of you, based on the above stats, think otherwise.
 
Apostasy
It refers to a general defection from the true God, the Bible, and the Christian faith. Every age has its defectors, but the falling away at the end times will be complete and worldwide. The whole planet will be in rebellion against God and His Christ.

Considering most of the planet is not currently "christian", and considering most of the planet has never been "christian", why should anyone really believe that nonsense?
 
You can't rebel against an almost certainly imaginary being.

You might as well try to frighten us with talk about rebelling against Santa Claus, and being put on his "naughty list", because there's same chance of it happening as your Christian nonsense.

"almost certainly" means you don't believe your own words....as disrespectful as they were.
 
Considering most of the planet is not currently "christian", and considering most of the planet has never been "christian", why should anyone really believe that nonsense?

I was only offering reasoning for the question at hand. Take it or leave it.
 
IMO, whining about the “defections” from slobbering fealty to sky daddy and earth boy is as stupid as lamenting that island people “fell away” from human sacrifice to the volcano god.

You're such a rebel. How do you think you'll smell on fire?
 
The bible also has human sacrifice, to Yahweh. Good analogy.


No wonder Christianity is dying so quickly. You can go onto almost any forum, and quickly learn so much about the bible that the preachers never told their sheep. Like human sacrifice to Yahweh, just like the pagan island gods demanded.

As opposed to Leftist heathens who demand and support human sacrifice as a plank in their ideology.
 
As opposed to Leftist heathens who demand and support human sacrifice as a plank in their ideology.

Are you referring to fetuses? I guess to some people on the Right they are more valuable than women.
 
We've been in a generational trend of decline for awhile, not yet complete, but the data is already starting to show predictions favouring a coming reversal, muted perhaps by the overall lower demographics but with inevitability of time tested truths.

Reality is non-religious types tend to avoid having having kids, likely a consequence of their more apocalyptic/nihilistic world view, for as a group they share more beliefs then do "believers". So wether by ethic/cultural change or consequence of reproductive choice. In the long term America will be a more religious nation and likely a Christian one. Even if in the short term, the trend is toward more secularism.

It's a old story, on yet another cycle.
 
You may have heard that America is a Christian nation. Whether it's true or not, it demonstrates that Christianity has been part of American culture since the beginning. In fact, some of the first settlers were Puritans looking to establish base away from the Church of England. There were also Catholics and Quakers looking to escape persecution. Many of the colonies had state churches at one point. Fast forwarding a couple centuries, the fifties were marked not only by an economic boom but also by a rise of conservatism. The vast majority of Americans were Protestant Christian and this remained true up into the 90s.

If Gallup and Pew Research are anything to go by, Protestantism in the US is in decline, primarily felt among Mainline Protestants. Catholicism has been able to maintain its percentage of around 23%, perhaps having something to do with immigration from Latin America, a predominantly Catholic region. Mormons have maintained their percentage at around 1%, perhaps because of their higher fertility rates or maybe they're just that good at keeping people from leaving or good at attracting new members. In 2010, roughly half of Americans identified as Protestants and in 2018, it was 43%. Since 2009, even the Catholics have seen a bit of decline, going down to 20%. The lack of religion has seen a major increase since the 90s, going from 7% to 16% in 2009 and 23% in 2018.

Newer generations are less religious than older generations, indicating a shift away from religion. In fact, 18-29-year-olds are just as likely to not hold any religious affiliation as they are to be Protestant. Furthermore, older generations have gradually become less religious.

This decline is happening in every region of the US but something interesting is happening in this regard. You see, the Southeastern portion of the US has been a historically religious part of the country (in fact, this region is sometimes referred to as the bible belt). From 2009 to 2018, Christianity fell from 82% to 70% (a fall of 12 points) whereas in the Midwest, it was from 77% to 67% (a fall of 10 points). In the south, the unaffiliated rose from 13% to 23% (a rise of 10 points) as opposed to from 18% to 25% like the midwest. In other words, the midwest may one day be more religious than the south. In contrast to the south, the western US has been a bit less religious with 69% being Christian and 21% being unaffiliated in 2009. Although the west became even less religious, the northeast seems to be challenging the west for the least religious region in the US. In 2009, 74% of northeasterners were Christian and 16% were unaffiliated but in 2018, 59% were Christian and 28% were unaffiliated. This is contrasted with the west which was 60% Christian and 32% unaffiliated.

Another thing that's happening is the emergence of other religions (most likely due to immigration from certain regions). In the northeast, other religions went up from 8% to 11% from 2009 to 2018.

In U.S., Decline of Christianity Continues at Rapid Pace | Pew Research Center
If the U.S. had 100 people: Charting Americans' religious affiliations | Pew Research Center
How America Lost Its Religion - The Atlantic
America's Changing Religious Landscape | Pew Research Center

There are many factors that have contributed to this decline, some of which you have noted. One other factor is the decline of the American middle class family. More and more middle class Americans are not having children, and it's families that by and large go to church. Another factor is that many Americans have adopted different aspects of Eastern religions to fill their spiritual desires. The popularity of Yoga is one aspect of that.
 
I think this trend will see a reversal. As climate change continues to increase the dangers on our planet, and man/science proves less and less able to contain or reverse the devastation, we will turn more to religion and God to give us the hope our own inaction for thirty years denied us. Desperation leads to more radical responses, and that leads to cults, and cult-like fervor in major religious traditions. We are going to try to pray away the hurricanes, the droughts, the firestorms, the floods, the famines, the pestulance and the contagions that are going to wreck our cities and countrysides.

When that does not work, we will listen to priests and clerics who tell us which infidels we should fight and kill to gain God's forebearance and forgiveness.
 
Last edited:
"almost certainly" means you don't believe your own words

Nope, it means I was being accurate and honest. It means that I don't think I can prove your god, or Santa Claus, or the FSM, don't exist. There is a possibility they might, however remote.

....as disrespectful as they were.

They weren't disrespectful in the slightest. I explained that you can't scare atheists with threats of what an almost certainly imaginary being might do to them.

Answer this question honestly please: Are you afraid of Santa Claus putting you on the "Naughty List"? (That's how afraid I am of Jesus/Yahweh sending me to hell.)
 
Last edited:
In the long term America will be a more religious nation and likely a Christian one. Even if in the short term, the trend is toward more secularism.

It's a old story, on yet another cycle.

Nope. Doubt it highly.

Information is now easily accessible. Honest information. True and real information.

Myths, dogma, lies, and silly traditions will continue to die.

Personal spirituality might be safe, but organized religion in general will decline.
 
As opposed to Leftist heathens who demand and support human sacrifice as a plank in their ideology.

What does that have to do with Human Sacrifices to Yahweh?
 
I think this trend will see a reversal. As climate change continues to increase the dangers on our planet, and man/science proves less and less able to contain or reverse the devastation, we will turn more to religion and God to give us the hope our own inaction for thirty years denied us. Desperation leads to more radical responses, and that leads to cults, and cult-like fervor in major religious traditions. We are going to try to pray away the hurricanes, the droughts, the firestorms, the floods, the famines, the pestulance and the contagions that are going to wreck our cities and countrysides.

When that does not work, we will listen to priests and clerics who tell us which infidels we should fight and kill to gain God's forebearance and forgiveness.

How do you come up with a silly scenario like that?
Where does that come from?

Climate change will result in increased religious beliefs, and eventually religious wars?????

:screwy
 
Back
Top Bottom