• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape[W:170]

Dittohead not!

Dittohead not!

master political analyst
DP Veteran
Joined
Dec 3, 2009
Messages
52,009
Reaction score
33,944
Location
The Golden State
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

I mean what else would you have people say or think? Make the best out of a bad situation; the kid's not at fault.

I get that there are deranged killhappy abortion supporters out there, but no one ever credited them with an abundance of rationality.
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

JayDubya said:
I mean what else would you have people say or think? Make the best out of a bad situation; the kid's not at fault.

I get that there are deranged killhappy abortion supporters out there, but no one ever credited them with an abundance of rationality.
Click to expand...

When will you be adopting a baby conceived from rape?
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

joG said:
No point hating the kid for the father's deed and making it take the rap.
Click to expand...

No point in forcing the woman to bear a seed of rape either.

Abortion should, as always, remain the woman's choice.
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

joG said:
No point hating the kid for the father's deed and making it take the rap.
Click to expand...

No point in making the victim suffer anymore either... Let the person decide what is best for them. Forcing a rape victim to carry a pregnancy could cause them serious trauma in addition to the rape.
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

joG said:
No point hating the kid for the father's deed and making it take the rap.
Click to expand...

true if you dont abort you should not mistreat a child for the actions of its parents but thats no reaosn to out law abortion and while it would be wrong to mistreat a child because of ther parents actions aborting a human before it has a mind to rival are pets and food animals seems ok

no point in defending religiously motivated bull**** thats an atack on the rights of intelligent beings
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

Dittohead not! said:
Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape, According to Missouri Republican Tila Hubrecht




Just thought you'd like to know, in case someone you know has been raped. God will compensate the rape victim with a child (according to this congresswoman at least).
Click to expand...


From the article " the same state that gave us former Republican U.S. Rep. Todd Akin, who in 2012 commented that rape doesn't leave women pregnant, because "if it's a legitimate rape, the female body has ways to try to shut that down."


In another words if the slut gets pregnant it is because she wanted to, right Rep Akin?
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

Captain Adverse said:
No point in forcing the woman to bear a seed of rape either.

Abortion should, as always, remain the woman's choice.
Click to expand...

That is a fine opinion, but it is also no more than that. It is a "Because I want it so!" argument that does not show, why a woman should have the right to terminate the human being.
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

SheWolf said:
No point in making the victim suffer anymore either... Let the person decide what is best for them. Forcing a rape victim to carry a pregnancy could cause them serious trauma in addition to the rape.
Click to expand...

That might be sad for the mother, but that does not really mean that she should be allowed to kill the human being. The trauma of abortion for the kid is terminal, while for the mother it is not.
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

blarg said:
true if you dont abort you should not mistreat a child for the actions of its parents but thats no reaosn to out law abortion and while it would be wrong to mistreat a child because of ther parents actions aborting a human before it has a mind to rival are pets and food animals seems ok

no point in defending religiously motivated bull**** thats an atack on the rights of intelligent beings
Click to expand...

It is the essence of being human and not the level of sensual and intellect that is significant to the question of termination. Otherwise, we could eliminate children till they had the intelligence of a chimp or argue similar. Out culture did think that way and practiced euthanasia in some countries.
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

SheWolf said:
This was a stupid thing the say. She should be embarrassed and never say this again.
Click to expand...

It's what she thinks. She's in Congress. She has a responsibility to say it.
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

I know you vehement pro-abort guys want to be tryhards and all, but no, this won't have legs.

Mr. Akin's comment was scientifically invalid; it insulted the intelligence of the listener and suggested rape pregnancy cannot occur. It can occur. It doesn't occur OFTEN, but what he said was scientifically inaccurate AND worse it basically called a lot of rape victims liars. Nothing in context could help that. It was indefensible.


Mrs. Hubrecht's comments are as follows:

1) She values her kids more than herself and had pregnancy complications at times and always told her OB/GYNs that if it ever came down to her or the kid, save the kid.
2) She has met and talked with people who were conceived in rape and she thinks they have value and a purpose the same as anyone else.
3) Rape is undeniably bad; the kid that may come from that doesn't have to be.
4) It's important to her that we value human life consistently from the beginning of life.
5) She is a hospice nurse and she thinks sanctity of life protections are important all the way to the end of life.

Based only on this soundclip, this woman is great. She has my full-throated and absolute support, and any effort to try and make a fuss about these comments would be so incredibly full of ****.
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

JackA said:
It's what she thinks. She's in Congress. She has a responsibility to say it.
Click to expand...

I think anyone in elected office, or running for an elected office, should say exactly the same kinds of things if that's what they believe.
They should say it loud and proud so we can all see who they really are.

If that kind of vile, disgusting, and moronic insanity is what they believe, we should all have the privileged of knowing it without question.

Do not silence those in office. We deserve to know.
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

joG said:
It is the essence of being human and not the level of sensual and intellect that is significant to the question of termination. Otherwise, we could eliminate children till they had the intelligence of a chimp or argue similar. Out culture did think that way and practiced euthanasia in some countries.
Click to expand...

to you but why should that be so?

or we could give chimps a right to life

but if we are ok with killing chimps why should we not kill ther human intellectual equals?
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

Dragonfly said:
If that kind of vile, disgusting, and moronic insanity is what they believe
Click to expand...

Yeah, respecting the value of human life is "vile, disgusting, and moronic" whereas promoting the cavalier taking of human life must is just great and palatable and intelligent.

:roll: **** every last bit of that noise.
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

JayDubya said:
Yeah, respecting the value of human life is "vile, disgusting, and moronic" whereas promoting the cavalier taking of human life must is just great and palatable and intelligent.

:roll: **** every last bit of that noise.
Click to expand...

when you place dna over the thoughts and feeling and the freedoms of others

ya vile disgusting and moronic is a good fit

and that noise can rightly be ****ed
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

blarg said:
when you place dna over the thoughts and feeling and the freedoms of others

ya vile disgusting and moronic is a good fit

and that noise can rightly be ****ed
Click to expand...

Yes your deceitful and nonsensical words are certainly all of those things.

DNA? The **** crazy **** you on about?

Other human beings are killed every time one of these homicides occur.

"Thoughts and feelings and freedoms" makes no rational sense in this context.
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

JayDubya said:
Yes your deceitful and nonsensical words are certainly all of those things.

DNA? The **** crazy **** you on about?

Other human beings are killed every time one of these homicides occur.

"Thoughts and feelings and freedoms" makes no rational sense in this context.
Click to expand...


other human beings with less going on in ther brains then has ever occurred in ther brains then you me or a pig ther human biologically but we kill living things by the millions and millions with more thoughts and feelings going on in ther heads

so ya your concerned about these animals becase ther dna makes them human

so yes the will of the mother is worth far more then the life of the fetus

if you value human rights for thinking feeling people instead of human rights for dna just becase that suites your thoughts and feelings


pay attention guts
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

blarg said:
other human beings with less going on in ther brains then has ever occurred in ther brains then you me or a pig ther human biologically but we kill living things by the millions and millions with more thoughts and feelings going on in ther heads

so ya your concerned about these animals becase ther dna makes them human

so yes the will of the mother is worth far more then the life of the fetus

if you value human rights for thinking feeling people instead of human rights for dna just becase that suites your thoughts and feelings


pay attention guts
Click to expand...

No the will of some literal scumbag psycho to kill other human beings is not worthy of any kind of respect - it should be noted, of course, as what it is, intent to commit a homicide.

I don't think of it in terms of DNA but the species of organism being killed is not in question, and if you were to question that I suppose you could verify that I am right and you are wrong by using DNA.
 
Re: Pregnancy Is the "Silver Lining" of Rape

JayDubya said:
No the will of some literal scumbag psycho to kill other human beings is not worthy of any kind of respect - it should be noted, of course, as what it is, intent to commit a homicide.

I don't think of it in terms of DNA but the species of organism being killed is not in question, and if you were to question that I suppose you could verify that I am right and you are wrong by using DNA.
Click to expand...

why would abortion make you a scum bag or a psycho?

ya a human fetus is human why is it wrong for the mother to have thta kind of human killed?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom