Neil Gorsuch on abortion ruling in Roe v. Wade: It’s been repeatedly reaffirmed[W:44]

Harshaw said:

You're arguing that Gorsuch was wrong because he was outnumbered. It's what you said. And that is a fallacy - Appeal to Popularity or Appeal to Numbers. That's a fact.

Click to expand...

Gaius46 said:

I read your comments regarding Gorsuch siding with "corporations over the little guy" as you preferring outcomes that favored the little guy despite what the law may actually be. If that's a wrong reading then my apologies.

On you believing him evil - I making that statement because you made it personal by calling him a "douche bag," which I read as saying - he's siding with the corporation, not because he actually believes his interpretation is correct but because he wants to **** the little guy.

Believe it or not I don't agree with his interpretation. I think he was splitting hairs too finely. But that doesn't mean I think he's a douche or an asshole. I save those for the corporation.

Click to expand...

prometeus said:

You should revisit your understanding of it. If he would have been right the decision would have been according to his position. By your logic, expert testimony would also be a fallacy since it is appeal to authority.

Click to expand...

Harshaw said:

This is piffle.

You argued that he was wrong because he was outnumbered.

Own your fallacy.

Click to expand...

prometeus said:

No, my argument was that he was and is wrong. Proof is that he was also outnumbered.

Click to expand...

prometeus said:

But it clearly does. He was alone in his opinion while the majority said the opposite. That makes him wrong.

Click to expand...

Harshaw said:

:roll:

No. You said being outnumbered is what makes him wrong.



Bored now. Bye.

Click to expand...

prometeus said:

Facts bore you? How typical.

Click to expand...