- Joined
- Dec 13, 2015
- Messages
- 9,594
- Reaction score
- 2,072
- Location
- France
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Centrist
OK. But you don't seriously think that a Constitutional amendment gets voted on in a vacuum, do you? The public will have PLENTY of time to learn how three or four states' population is going to control the entire country from then on. And each state will vote individually...
It may not be mission impossible, but I'd say it would be close to it.
Aint gonna happin, Maggie.
When it comes to the separation of powers, it is fundamentally NOT the right of states to determine either the timing or pattern of voting. (And I mean by the latter "who votes where").
Fundamental to any democracy is that "all citizens have the right (and duty) to vote and no state-rendered qualification will obviate that right.
That only four states determine who wins is certainly a statistical probability, but there is no reason to believe that it is an unavoidable consequence. Because it isn't statistically probable when the national vote is distributed across the county.
If the Electoral College vote is warped today the reason is specifically because the voter-numbers in the college was tampered with in order to give supposedly "lesser populated, weaker states" more votes. Where in the Constitution is that tampering permitted and on what grounds?!? By what right does your vote in your state (in a national election) have more weight than mine in some other state?
Sorry but this sort of tampering with the national voting process is quite simply UNACCEPTABLE in any real democracy.
Which means that we must stop "tinkering" with the voting circumstances in each state. If states want to tamper with the way Governors are elected, that's their business (and perhaps eventually of the Supreme Court). But national elections should be conducted according to a Federal Law - and the constitution be damned if employed to hinder "fair voting" fundamental to any True Democracy!
NB: And I would be arguing the very same were EC-voting to have favored Hillary over the Dork. Dubya won his seat in the Oval Office in exactly the same manner - he lost the popular vote against Gore. Enough IS enough!
Last edited: