• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!
  • Welcome to our archives. No new posts are allowed here.

You Didn't Build That! Obama was right.

sharon

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Jan 25, 2012
Messages
11,600
Reaction score
1,344
Location
Georgia
Gender
Female
Political Leaning
Moderate
As I sit at my desk and look around I realize just how little I've
actually done. I didn't build my IPhone, my coffee cup, my
calculator, the pens and pencils, my computer, my desk, chair, TV,
trash can, or write all the books on the shelves. Upstairs, I did
not build all the furniture, the kitchen cabinets and appliances,
dishes, carpet, and sew all our clothing.

In addition, I did not create the shopping centers, the office
buildings, the manufacturing facilities, schools and public
utilities. And, of course, I did not drill the oil wells, purify
the drinking water, build the airplanes, harvest the crops, or
drive the trucks that deliver everything. Oh, and I did not
invent the internet. Al Gore did that.

So, Obama was right. I didn't create 99.999999999+% of what is
out there in the world around me. Everyone did their respective
parts and we are ALL better because of it. Now, back to the very
first thing on my long list of what I didn't create, my IPhone.

It was not created by government or because of government. It was
created by a man with a vision who struggled every day to make the
best products he possible could.

Steve Jobs and Steve Wosniak invested their lives in an idea called Apple. For every success
story like Apple, there are many failures. So, why was Apple
successful and others not? Could it possibly be because of Steve Jobs?

Now, back to the very personal point of this email... I DID CREATE
my business. I started with nothing but $3,000 and an idea. I
knew NOTHING about the industry I got into. In the beginning, it
was just me. I learned. I took the financial risk. I made the
decisions and I lived with those decisions; both right and wrong.

I juggled the needs of my customers, my suppliers, and my
employees. I cultivated my banking relationships so I could
borrow the money I needed to grow my business. I worked 70+ hours
a week and even when I was not officially working, I was still
thinking about how to do it better and smarter. I was
responsible. I hired terrific people and paid them very well.

Together, we built a terrific company. Between me and my
employees, we've paid millions in taxes that the government would
not have received if I had not taken the risk.

So, Mr. President, I take GREAT OFFENSE at your imbecilic
statement that "If you've got a business, you didn't build that.
Somebody else made that happen." It's obvious that you do not
have a clue about the real world.

I did not vote for you four years ago because I thought that being
a community organizer was insufficient experience to be the leader
of the most powerful country in the world. Based on your
performance over the last 4 years, it is obvious that I was right.

However, with regard to your Nobel Peace Prize, I will agree with
you. You did NOT earn that. Somebody else made that happen.

(This letter is personal.. it was written to me by a close friend.. I asked if I could publish it and he said yes.)
 
Obama was talking about roads and bridges. Did your clever friend build any roads and bridges? No? Then tell him to STFU.
 
Obama was talking about roads and bridges. Did your clever friend build any roads and bridges? No? Then tell him to STFU.

He built a business that saves industry billions ...
 
Obama was talking about roads and bridges. Did your clever friend build any roads and bridges? No? Then tell him to STFU.
If that friend pays taxes and votes then they absolutely DID build those roads. AND...in addition to being a 'citizen' that built those roads and schools and other public utilities, that friend THEN invested of his or her own resources and built a business as well. And then paid MORE for those resources...certainly more than MOST. Yes...they 'built' that.

But then...we have already determined...what Obama was doing was merely appealing to the 47%...pleading for their votes by telling them they were entitled to MORE of the success and largess of the wealthy and he was the guy to make it happen for them.
 
Obama was talking about roads and bridges. Did your clever friend build any roads and bridges? No? Then tell him to STFU.

That wasn't the worst part of that speech. The worst part was:

"Look, if you've been successful, you didn't get there on your own," he said. "You didn't get there on your own. I'm always struck by people who think, well, it must be because I was just so smart. There are a lot of smart people out there. It must be because I worked harder than everybody else. Let me tell you something -- there are a whole bunch of hardworking people out there.

There's not one successful businessman who doesn't know he didn't do it on his own. It took hard work...risk-taking...smarts...luck...mentors...being-in-the-right-place-at-the-right-time. But. To say that it isn't because one was willing to work harder and smart enough to take advantage of what it takes to build a business -- to insinuate that "anyone can do it" -- is wrong.

To insinuate that business builders are arrogant assholes is just.plain.wrong.
 
If that friend pays taxes and votes then they absolutely DID build those roads. AND...in addition to being a 'citizen' that built those roads and schools and other public utilities, that friend THEN invested of his or her own resources and built a business as well. And then paid MORE for those resources...certainly more than MOST. Yes...they 'built' that.

But then...we have already determined...what Obama was doing was merely appealing to the 47%...pleading for their votes by telling them they were entitled to MORE of the success and largess of the wealthy and he was the guy to make it happen for them.

My old friend doesn't' begrudge his taxes.. In fact he thinks he is a lucky dog to pay taxes and have tens for thousands to give to charity. The point really is that we ALL use the roads, public utilities etc... and NONE of us individually "Built those".

He grants that Obama is a bright guy... with a blind spot.. and zero practical experience as to how the world works.
 
That wasn't the worst part of that speech. The worst part was:



There's not one successful businessman who doesn't know he didn't do it on his own. It took hard work...risk-taking...smarts...luck...mentors...being-in-the-right-place-at-the-right-time. But. To say that it isn't because one was willing to work harder and smart enough to take advantage of what it takes to build a business -- to insinuate that "anyone can do it" -- is wrong.

To insinuate that business builders are arrogant assholes is just.plain.wrong.

The real insinuation is that businesses owe society something. Because paying wages, creating goods that the public wants, and paying taxes isn't enough...there must be more taxes. The reality is that businesses actually write the checks to the government. Yes, it comes out of our wages, but most of us aren't writing a monthly check to uncle Obama. Our employers are. They generated the revenue that paid our wages and our taxes. Obama didn't do that. The government didn't do that. There would be no roads, bridges, or government buildings without businesses. Hell, government paid businesses to build all of that. You can't have 100% workers...there have to be business owners and there have to be workers. Without the two there is no revenue for government.
 
The real insinuation is that businesses owe society something. Because paying wages, creating goods that the public wants, and paying taxes isn't enough...there must be more taxes. The reality is that businesses actually write the checks to the government. Yes, it comes out of our wages, but most of us aren't writing a monthly check to uncle Obama. Our employers are. They generated the revenue that paid our wages and our taxes. Obama didn't do that. The government didn't do that. There would be no roads, bridges, or government buildings without businesses. Hell, government paid businesses to build all of that. You can't have 100% workers...there have to be business owners and there have to be workers. Without the two there is no revenue for government.

The accusation that "You didn't build that" is myopic..

When we drive down the street and look at "government infrastructure".. like street lights or traffic lights... we should remember that ALL that was built by private industry NOT government.
 
The accusation that "You didn't build that" is myopic..

When we drive down the street and look at "government infrastructure".. like street lights or traffic lights... we should remember that ALL that was built by private industry NOT government.

And paid for with tax revenue generated by businesses.
 
And paid for with tax revenue generated by businesses.

Yes sirree..

IMO its a serious shortcoming that our otherwise brilliant young president doesn't get that.
 
Yes sirree..

IMO its a serious shortcoming that our otherwise brilliant young president doesn't get that.

Brilliant? Sarcasm?
 
Brilliant? Sarcasm?

No.. He has some regard for Obama as an orator.. as I do..

Having come to the conclusion that he is not the right stuff for the job for a variety of reasons.

He doesn't get politics or business...

He's good at campaigning and little else..
 
No.. He has some regard for Obama as an orator.. as I do..

Having come to the conclusion that he is not the right stuff for the job for a variety of reasons.

He doesn't get politics or business...

He's good at campaigning and little else..

I won't argue with that.
 
I won't argue with that.

Obama is in real trouble.. and so are we.

He's not loyal, can't work with others and has alienated his base. He's even alienated the national black chamber of commerce, Oprah, Caroline Kennedy etc..

I'm sorry it hasn't worked out, Barak.. start packing.
 
Got awfully quiet in here after Sharon and I posted.
 
Got awfully quiet in here after Sharon and I posted.

I am all for supporting the President... but it election time and Obama's term just hasn't worked out.
 
About 14k years ago, humanity realized that in order to be surive, people would need to get together and live in communities. It is from back then that we have the first traced of human civilization... that we can call civilization.

At first, communities were small and thus, everybody had to perform the most basic of functions. Each man had to chop wood, go hunting and fishing, build buildings and farm the land. Every woman had to make babies, make clothes and give the men a foot massage after they've been chasing animals all day.

As communities grew larger and larger, people banded together and professions were born. Some became professional hunters, others specialized in woodcutting. And the men divided labors between them so that they could each do whatever they could do for the good of the tribe.
As the village grew even larger, the basic, menial tasks had all been completed and so other men could consider taking up other jobs... and if luck would have it, create new jobs by discovering or inventing new tools. This is how pottery and clayworking was made and such things became part of the community. And as time advanced, stonemasons, craftsmen and other jobs filled the rising community until it was no longer a village, but a town. Then a city.

And this is how our world is today. Some men perform the basic jobs needed for humanity to live. Others, because those lines of work are saturated, perform other duties. And others perform specialized duties. Since the day has only 24h and we only live on average 80 years, we cannot be expected to do everything as individuals. But rather work together. It is however a normal understanding that if I do my job as a farmer and you do your job as a fisherman, we each, according to the community we are part of, have done our duty.

If I become the most successful farmer in the world it is because I managed to do so. Yes, I did it with the help of the new tools that other people created. Yes, I did it using the pen and paper that other people made. But that's the idea. If I didn't work the field with my skill, they would all starve to death and then where would we be? Nowhere.

So no, Obama is wrong. If I created a business, I did it. it is my success. I am certain that if certain things wouldn't be made available to me (pen, paper) I would find substitutes for them and still be successful. If I could not find those substitutes, then probably the idea is not that I cannot be successful farmer... but rather, I can spot the opportunity of becoming succesful in the pen and paper industry.

Bottom line.

If you make a business, yes, you do use the tools that other people made, but if you wouldn't be the one who would know how to best use those tools and have the vision for your business, nobody would ever be able to replace you. If you make a business, it is your success. You built that.
 
Obama was talking about roads and bridges. Did your clever friend build any roads and bridges? No? Then tell him to STFU.

No the person who ought to STFU is Obunny and his crap that those of us who are prosperous somehow owe parasitic assholes like him more of our money
 
Obama was talking about roads and bridges. Did your clever friend build any roads and bridges? No? Then tell him to STFU.

Yeah, he was talking about roads and bridges, but then decided to make it clear to everyone that he was going to devalue human initiative in the building of business. It was just as bastardly as Romney's 47% comment. Enough with the "context" talk.
 
No the person who ought to STFU is Obunny and his crap that those of us who are prosperous somehow owe parasitic assholes like him more of our money

I think the point of this letter to Obama is that when a businessman creates a business, hires employees and both pay taxes, he's entitled to some credit.
 
Obama was talking about roads and bridges. Did your clever friend build any roads and bridges? No? Then tell him to STFU.

Who wakes you up every morning? Who drives you to work? Who gave you your job and your wall hangers? Who dresses you? Who performs your job?

Obviously, you don't.
 
Obama was talking about roads and bridges. Did your clever friend build any roads and bridges? No? Then tell him to STFU.

Did the government pay for those roads and bridges or did they fail to do that? Did they even build the roads? None of that? Oh so basically what they did was take money from someone else and give to another group of people to do the work they wished to be done. Gee, middlemen sure are taking a lot of credit around here.
 
No.. He has some regard for Obama as an orator.. as I do..

Having come to the conclusion that he is not the right stuff for the job for a variety of reasons.

He doesn't get politics or business...

He's good at campaigning and little else..

He really isn't a great orator either, but its true that he knows how to campaign.
 
Back
Top Bottom