• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!
  • Welcome to our archives. No new posts are allowed here.

The Tax Policy Center

TurtleDude

warrior of the wetlands
Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Oct 12, 2005
Messages
281,619
Reaction score
100,389
Location
Ohio
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Libertarian - Right
Is constantly quoted by Obama Inc as a non partisan entity and it is cited for support for the Obunny attack ads on Romney. But how non-partisan is it and how accurate is that Center's claims

well first of all its a joint venture of the Urban Institute and the Brookings Institute . Now the BI is left leaning though not as biased as say the New york times, the white house (yeah Obunny claims have cited the White House as authority), Paul Krugman or other common sources of Obunny spin.

but here is a good counter to the TPC's ASSumptions

Mitt Romney's Tax Plan and Tax Policy Center's Skewed Analysis

The Tax Policy Center (TPC) conducted an analysis of Governor Mitt Romney’s tax reform plan. Governor Romney’s plan follows all four requirements of tax reform. However, the report’s authors conspicuously chose to ignore the requirement for distributional neutrality. The results of their analysis have garnered much attention because they erroneously claim that the plan would necessarily cut taxes for the rich, whom their report defines as those with incomes over $200,000, and raise taxes on middle-income and low-income taxpayers (all other taxpayers).
 
I guess none of the Obama supporters want to counter this. ALMOST every bit of support for the Obunny ads comes from this "analysis"
 
We "Obama supporters" just dont want to discuss conspiracy theories. There is a sub forum for that stuff.
 
We "Obama supporters" just dont want to discuss conspiracy theories. There is a sub forum for that stuff.

you obama supporters pretend there are no biased sources of information when it comes to providing Obunny propaganda
 
You seem to have a problem with TPC because you claim it's biased, and your response is to cite a fairly substanceless article from the right wing Heritage Foundation? Interesting.

More interesting, the Heritage article seems to be complaining that Romney's plan, while a lie, doesn't necessarily lie in the precise way that TPC assumes. Romney has made a bunch of promises that he can't keep. TPC's analysis assumed that he would keep the promise to deliver a 20% rate reduction and revenue neutrality. If he keeps those promises he can't keep his promise not to raise middle class taxes. BUT ... he could instead break his promise to deliver a 20% rate reduction! Or he could be lying about not increasing the deficit!

This is most reassuring.
 
You seem to have a problem with TPC because you claim it's biased, and your response is to cite a fairly substanceless article from the right wing Heritage Foundation? Interesting.

More interesting, the Heritage article seems to be complaining that Romney's plan, while a lie, doesn't necessarily lie in the precise way that TPC assumes. Romney has made a bunch of promises that he can't keep. TPC's analysis assumed that he would keep the promise to deliver a 20% rate reduction and revenue neutrality. If he keeps those promises he can't keep his promise not to raise middle class taxes. BUT ... he could instead break his promise to deliver a 20% rate reduction! Or he could be lying about not increasing the deficit!

This is most reassuring.


both sides have assertions that require several assumptions to come true in order for their promises to also come true. What we do know is that Obunny claimed that if his stimulus was passed, the unemployment rate would be 3 or so points lower than it has been

what we know about Obunny is that his promises in 08 have not been delivered. and to claim that the TPC is unbiased is not exactly honest
 
both sides have assertions that require several assumptions to come true in order for their promises to also come true. What we do know is that Obunny claimed that if his stimulus was passed, the unemployment rate would be 3 or so points lower than it has been

what we know about Obunny is that his promises in 08 have not been delivered. and to claim that the TPC is unbiased is not exactly honest

Yes, I've seen that claim here many times, and in Romney Super PAC ads. That claim is a lie, of course, just like Romney's tax plan is a lie.

Obama's unemployment projections were projections -- not promises. They were stated to have a high degree of uncertainty.
 
you obama supporters pretend there are no biased sources of information when it comes to providing Obunny propaganda

Oh there is bias, but it is dwarfed by the right wing bias and attempts to rewrite history, facts and reality.
 
Oh there is bias, but it is dwarfed by the right wing bias and attempts to rewrite history, facts and reality.


LOL-yoru post does not conform to known reality
 
Back
Top Bottom