I see. When it comes to a health care plan we can't use MA as an example because what worked there might not work in someplace like Wyoming but we can apply an economic policy to the vastly larger and more complex U.S. economy that originates there. You conservatives spin in circles so much I'm surprised you can stand up. Why not just admit all you care about is getting more tax cuts and be done with it? BTW, the article mentions that it is somewhat difficult to predict the results of Romney's actions because there are so many unexplained " A wizard did it" aspects to his plan. That's why they looked at multiple scenarios none of them worst case. If Obama was hiding behind this kind a vague proposition the right would be all over him for essentially saying "Elect me and then I'll explain it".
LMFAO... that's because economies are economies...
You realize the reason MA healthcare model made sense for MA right?
You probably aren't aware of this, but MA healthcare plan was in reaction to a specific problem MA had, that was going into effect if they did nothing... MA was slated to lose $400M dollars it was getting from the federal government, if they didnt find a way to overhaul their uncompensated care pool, and use the funds they were recieving from Medicare in a more responsible way... So they had to do something, to prevent a tripling of MA healthcare expenditures at a time when they were just recovering from a $3B deficit, the largest in state history...
What they came up with is a plan which would increase coverage to nearly all, and decrease spending on healthcare by the state...
However, in order for that to be the case, it required a low number of uninsured, and for people to be working, and recieving their own plans from their employers, or buying into pool coverage, and hospitals and private insurance companies in place that were willing to offer those plans...
MA had 92/93% insured prior to Romney's plan... and 97/98% insured after Romney's plan... and 4.7% unemployment at the time Romney's plan was instituted... We also have the hospitals and insurance companies that were willing to create plans to facilitate this... Tufts, Blue Cross Blue Shield, Harvard Pilgrim... you know, small companies you may or may not have heard about that are based in MA... and have large city hospitals theyre associated with...
If you look at the other states... they don't necesarily have that...
Here is a map, that breaks up states by the % of uninsured they have...
Where the Uninsured Live - Jobs & Economy - The Atlantic Cities
"Nationwide, 17.1 percent of Americans lacked health insurance in 2011, according to the Gallup Healthways Well-Being Index, which also produced the map below. But there are stark differences between the states. More than one in five people are uninsured in roughly a dozen states, starting with Texas (27.6 percent), Mississippi (23.5 percent), Florida (22.9 percent), Oklahoma (22.1 percent), California (22.0 percent), and Nevada (21.9 percent). Compare those figures with Massachusetts, which boasts the lowest rate of uninsured people in the nation, at less than five percent. Massachusetts, of course, already has an individual mandate thanks to the health-care reform efforts of former governor Mitt Romney."
Other similar maps are here on these sites...
The Uninsured: Rates By State And Congressional District : NPR
The Map Scroll: Where the Uninsured Are
Compare that map, and those states which high amount of uninsured, with this map of the states with high unemployment rates...
Map: LA
Alabama - 8.5
Alaska - 7.8
Arizona - 8.3
Arkansas - 7.3
California - 10.6
Colorado - 8.2
Connecticut - 9.0
Delaware - 6.9
District of Columbia - 8.8
Florida - 8.8
Georgia - 9.2
Hawaii - 6.1
Idaho - 7.4
Illinois - 9.1
Indiana - 8.3
Iowa - 5.5
Kansas - 6.2
Kentucky - 8.5
Louisiana - 7.4
Maine - 7.6
Maryland - 7.1
Massachusetts - 6.3
Michigan - 9.4
Minnesota - 5.9
Mississippi - 9.1
Missouri - 7.2
Montana - 6.3
Nebraska - 4.0
Nevada - 12.1
New Hampshire - 5.7
New Jersey - 9.9
New Mexico - 6.5
New York - 9.1
North Carolina - 9.7
North Dakota - 3.0
Ohio - 7.2
Oklahoma - 5.1
Oregon - 8.9
Pennsylvania - 8.1
Rhode Island - 10.7
South Carolina - 9.6
South Dakota - 4.5
Tennessee - 8.5
Texas - 7.1
Utah - 5.8
Vermont - 5.3
Virginia - 5.9
Washington - 8.6
West Virginia - 7.5
Wisconsin - 7.5
Wyoming - 5.7
You can go down that list, and find several of the states with high amounts of uninsured, that also have high amounts of unemployment right now…
Also, many states aren’t receiving the funds from the government as MA is… So it would further complicate the issue…
Additionally, many states in the South and Southwest also have high numbers of elderly people, who don’t work, don’t contribute, but do have high rates of medical dependencies…
Then there is the access to the care, with the hospitals who can cover those patients, and the large insurance companies that can create those pool plans that they expect losses on, and the associations those companies already have in place with those hospitals, and the doctors within those networks, that agree to work for those rates, etc.
So you can see, that Romney's plan would likely work well up in the northeast... but awfully in the Southeast and Southwest...
Romney’s plan truly was meant for a MA only problem… and could work in other states, but should not be applied to the nation as a whole…
Furthermore, Obama’s plan isn’t Romney’s plan… Obama’s plan is far worse, in terms of the steepness of the penalties on both individuals who don’t get health insurance and companies that don’t provide it… The employee requirement in MA is 100 employees (for much larger companies only), whereas Obama’s is on companies with 50 employees… far too low, and prevents small businesses that truly can’t afford to provide health insurance from expanding… There are also far too many government administrators in ObamaCare, Romney vetoed those provisions out of the bill… it was the Demorcrats in the legislature that added those provisions back into CommonwealthCare, adding to its costs… Also, Obama didn't do the work to set up the connector or to find the private companies that are willing to create these pool coverages for the low income people... So we don't even know that its going to be able to work that way... Whereas, Romney brought those companies into the establishment of the plan, and to make sure they were in place and the connector was, before the plan would go into effect... It all ran smoothly... With ObamaCare, it's going into effect shortly, and most of that is still up in the air...