• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!
  • Welcome to our archives. No new posts are allowed here.

Obama's Team Responds to "2016 Obama's America"

President Obama was not raised in typical American fashion. That's quite clear from the movie. It's also clear that he fully embraced his father's philosophy. Why do you assume that I think he is trying to dismantle the "American Empire?"



It's not clear in the movie...it's not documented. It's a fable that has been going on ever since the right wingers changed from Obama being a Christian with a racist pastor to these lies.

His helping the poor makes him far more Christian than the born again evangelicals in this nation.
 
This isn't a documentary..it's a fantasy based on what the right winger puts down about Obama in 2016.

Facts versus propaganda.

Truth versus lies.

Documentary versus fantasy.

Not much in the line of critical reasoning these days.

It's all taken right out of Obama's book, so maybe you're right.
 
A local theater reportedly showed this for awhile, but never advertised it, put it on the Now Showing list or anything else. I am not exactly sure how you got into the multiplex speakeasy, but I never had a desire to find out anyway.

I had to laugh when I saw a link of Tea Party propaganda that bragged the movie was "still in the top 10" last week. Umm... how many movies are generally in circulation at one time?
 
It's not clear in the movie...it's not documented. It's a fable that has been going on ever since the right wingers changed from Obama being a Christian with a racist pastor to these lies.

His helping the poor makes him far more Christian than the born again evangelicals in this nation.

What does it make Romney that he donated $4 million to the poor?
 
I had to laugh when I saw a link of Tea Party propaganda that bragged the movie was "still in the top 10" last week. Umm... how many movies are generally in circulation at one time?


LOL. Hollywood can barely keep them in theaters 3 weeks these days. I bought that Michael Moore movie with a desire to keep an open mind. That thing was so over the top insanely bad that I have vowed I will never watch another election movie ever on either side. I don't care if it is something I agree with or don't agree with, but please be at least somewhat realistic with facts.
 
President Obama was not raised in typical American fashion. That's quite clear from the movie.
That he traveled? That he wasn't raised in the cookie-cutter Nuclear Family fashion? So? It might be unsettling to you but this country is not some sort of monolith, there are differences between people's experiences, and that should'nt be something to be fearful of.
It's also clear that he fully embraced his father's philosophy.
Embraced as in made it his own, that his father's agenda is his agenda now? That seems a lot less clear, as President he has acted as a proponent for his country. His country very clearly being the United States, and promotion of the interests its citizens his job.
Why do you assume that I think he is trying to dismantle the "American Empire?"
I don't assume that but it is D'Souza's assertion. Weaken America, weaken America's place in the world, overthrow America. What do you think that means?
 
Last edited:
President Obama was not raised in typical American fashion

SO WHAT!?!?!?!

What the hell is a "typical American fashion" either?

I'm gonna be pretty harsh here because you should know better.

The whole idea that because his father wasn't American, that he lived in another country for awhile makes him not very American is ludicrous beyond belief.

I was not born in Canada, I was born all the way over in Africa. Lived in England for many years but I am as Canadian as they come and enriched by my past in that sense, taking the best qualities of each.

The whole notion of him not being American enough is a far right attempt to portray him as "the other".

"not one of us".

It's idiotic.
 
LOL. Hollywood can barely keep them in theaters 3 weeks these days. I bought that Michael Moore movie with a desire to keep an open mind. That thing was so over the top insanely bad that I have vowed I will never watch another election movie ever on either side. I don't care if it is something I agree with or don't agree with, but please be at least somewhat realistic with facts.
LOL, I'm happy that I managed to avoid 'learning the hard way' and encouraging hucksters like that.
 
It's all taken right out of Obama's book, so maybe you're right.

No it's not...it's twisted to fit the birther lies...and to satisfy the racist heart of those who see it.

Hedges vs. D

. . .

Hedges: I don’t support Obama. You know, I wish somebody would make a documentary on what Obama’s done. I just sued the president in federal court over the National Defense Authorization Act, the assault on civil liberties under the Obama administration. This should not be a left-right divide. It has been far worse under Obama than it was under George W. Bush. And yet none of that is in the film. Obama’s refusal to restore habeas corpus. Obama’s supporting of the FISA Amendment Act, which retroactively makes legal what under our constitution—and I assume Dinesh is a constitutionalist — has traditionally been illegal. Warrantless wiretapping, monitoring, and eavesdropping of tens of millions of Americans. The use of the Espionage Act, six times, to shut down whistleblowers who have exposed, in some cases, war crimes committed by the U.S. government. And finally, the NDAA, Section 1021, which authorizes the U.S. military to carry out detentions, seizures, on American soil, strip American citizens of due process, and hold them in their offshore penal colonies. None of that’s in the film. The craven sort of obsequiousness on the part of the Obama administration to Wall Street. The expansion of our imperial wars. Our proxy wars in Pakistan, Somalia, Yemen. I think these are pretty good criticisms of Obama. And in fact, a lie of omission is still a lie. And we can’t, you know, the fact that a young kid in college gravitates towards a Marxist professor is hardly fodder, I think, for discrediting someone, when you look closely at how obsequious the president has been to serving the military-industrial complex and Wall Street. I care about what he does. I don’t care about, I mean I actually think gravitating toward Marxist professors or reading Edward Said is a good thing. And I wish that Obama had kept that kind of commitment to the other, to the outsider, to those kinds of voices on the margin. But in fact, he has not.

. ..

Hedges: “Because I’ve spoke to Edward about it before he died and he was not close to Obama at all. That’s just not true, Dinesh. I don’t know where you got it from. He hardly knew Obama. As far as this idea that Obama is serving the interest of, I assume you mean, developing countries in the third world, it just doesn’t play out in Obama policies. We have uprisings throughout the Muslim world because of the expanded occupation and reign of terror that has been visited upon Muslims. Hundreds of thousands of Muslims killed in Iraq, millions displaced in Afghanistan and Iraq, the drone strikes in Pakistan, the cross-border raids are disintegrating Pakistan as a country. The inability on the part of the Obama administration to do anything to alter the Israeli policies towards the Palestinians in particular in Gaza, the largest open air prison in the world. The facts don’t lay it out. I mean, what people’s rhetoric are, and i don’t trust Obama’s rhetoric anymore than I trust Romney or any other politician’s rhetoric.

We have to look at what they do and what Obama does is serve the centers of power, I think one could argue, in many ways more efficiently than Bush. You talk about energy and Obama has expanded drilling. He has supported half of the XL pipeline and i have a pretty good suspicion that once he’s elected, he’ll build the other half. The jobs bill, you talk about redistributing wealth. The jobs bill went nowhere. They cut unemployment benefits for hundreds of thousands of Americans. We now have 47 million Americans who live in poverty. Tens of millions who live in a category called near-poverty. The Obama administration has done nothing to address the foreclosures, the bank repossessions. Obama care is a cooked-up version of Romney care, which came out of the Heritage Foundation. 447 billion dollars in subsidies to the pharmaceutical and insurance industries. If you’re talking about re-distributing wealth, Obama’s done what Bush does, which is the largest transference of wealth upwards in American history. I mean, those are the facts.”

. . .

A film was created filled with the racist fantasies and fiction of a group of people who would spend money and make this reight wing pundit rich...NO facts were given...just feeding the pundits zeal and desire for racism.
 
LOL. Hollywood can barely keep them in theaters 3 weeks these days. I bought that Michael Moore movie with a desire to keep an open mind. That thing was so over the top insanely bad that I have vowed I will never watch another election movie ever on either side. I don't care if it is something I agree with or don't agree with, but please be at least somewhat realistic with facts.


Yeah, facts do kinda go right over the head of right wingers who will believe a fantasy movie as facts.
 
What does it make Romney that he donated $4 million to the poor?



He didn't donate $4 million to the poor. He donated it to the Mormon Church...know what they did with that?

LDS Church buys farmland, Haun's Mill, Far West, Kirtland property from Community of Christ | Deseret News

The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints confirmed Saturday that it purchased 6,000 acres of Missouri farmland and three historical sites from the Community of Christ — the group formerly known as the Reorganized Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints.

“The Church recently acquired operating farmland and several other non-farmland properties located in Missouri and Ohio from the Community of Christ," LDS Church spokesperson Scott Trotter said. "Non-farm sites include the Haun’s Mill and the Far West Burying Ground in Missouri as well as the Joseph Smith Sr. home in Kirtland, Ohio."

Trotter specified that no plans exist to develop the properties; farm operations will continue and historic sites will be maintained.

Situated in Caldwell County, Mo., Haun's Mill is remembered in LDS history as the place where at least 18 Mormons were massacred on Oct. 30, 1838, when Caldwell County sheriff William Jennings led an armed militia of more than 200 men into the small settlement and had them open fire without warning.

Also located in Caldwell County, Far West is the settlement Mormons founded in 1836 that served as the church's headquarters during most of 1838. It's estimated that more than 200 early Latter-day Saints are buried at the Far West Burial Grounds, including original apostle David W. Patten.

Joseph Smith Sr. resided in Kirtland from 1831-38, and was living there at the time he was called in 1833 to be the church's first Presiding Patriarch.
 
That he traveled? That he wasn't raised in the cookie-cutter Nuclear Family fashion? So? It might be unsettling to you but this country is not some sort of monolith, there are differences between people's experiences, and that should'nt be something to be fearful of.

Embraced as in made it his own, that his father's agenda is his agenda now? That seems a lot less clear, as President he has acted as a proponent for his country. His country very clearly being the United States, and promotion of the interests its citizens his job.

I don't assume that but it is D'Souza's assertion. Weaken America, weaken America's place in the world, overthrow America. What do you think that means?

I think he wasn't raised in the "United States." He was mentored by people who were absolutely not capitalists. He was raised by people who fully embraced his father's vision of the world. And. How can you even go there? Romney's too rich! He's out of touch with "the real America."
 
He didn't donate $4 million to the poor. He donated it to the Mormon Church...know what they did with that?

LDS Church buys farmland, Haun's Mill, Far West, Kirtland property from Community of Christ | Deseret News

Is that what you say about Catholics who donated to their church? He donated $4 million. Yes, money is fungible. But I just don't understand the hatred people have for Romney. He's done wonderful things in his life -- with his money. More than you've done. More than I've done. More than, probably, all of the people on this board put together.
 
Is that what you say about Catholics who donated to their church? He donated $4 million. Yes, money is fungible. But I just don't understand the hatred people have for Romney. He's done wonderful things in his life -- with his money. More than you've done. More than I've done. More than, probably, all of the people on this board put together.

Well, maybe for starters you should talk to those workers whose business he bought,whose pension funds he stole and whose jobs he shipped overseas.

Then, maybe you should show us all those wonderful things he has done with his life.

BTW, where is his birth certicate? his father was born in Mexico, you know. Do we know if he was born here, really? He has REFUSED to show his birth certificate.
 
Is that what you say about Catholics who donated to their church? He donated $4 million. Yes, money is fungible. But I just don't understand the hatred people have for Romney. He's done wonderful things in his life -- with his money. More than you've done. More than I've done. More than, probably, all of the people on this board put together.



Where did the Catholic thing come in? Ryan is a Ayn Rand worshiper, not really Catholic at all.
 
I think he wasn't raised in the "United States." He was mentored by people who were absolutely not capitalists. He was raised by people who fully embraced his father's vision of the world. And. How can you even go there? Romney's too rich! He's out of touch with "the real America."


Your proof? Sounds like more of the fantasies about the fake film maker using nonsense to spread political propaganda before an election...the right wing is FAMOUS for this.
 
Well, maybe for starters you should talk to those workers whose business he bought,whose pension funds he stole and whose jobs he shipped overseas.

Then, maybe you should show us all those wonderful things he has done with his life.

BTW, where is his birth certicate? his father was born in Mexico, you know. Do we know if he was born here, really? He has REFUSED to show his birth certificate.

I'm not going to discuss this with you. It's all been posted here many times before -- the wonderful things he's done through Bain -- through his personal generosity. You're never going to vote for him. Never going to respect him as a human being. I'm not going to waste my time. Get educated and come back some time.
 
Your proof from the writer of the film?

Obama himself is heard reading passages of his book in the movie several times to back up what is being said.

It would be obvious to you had you seen the movie.
 
"2016: Obama's America" has become a hot topic of the election season. It is the documentary by right wing pundit Dinesh D'Souza that attempts to explain Obama's world view. My review of the movie is here:

LowDown -- 2016: Obama's America

Obama's campaign team came out with a response after having tried to ignore it for some weeks.

2016: Obama's America� is a deliberate distortion of President Obama's record and world view

The response is heavy with huffing and puffing and with ad hominem attacks, as might be expected. They claim that D'Souza is a right wing hack who has committed all sort of right wing hackery, and they have plenty of quotes from other Obama supporters to prove it. So much for that.

But they do lay out some factual claims from the movie to show why D'Souza is wrong. (These points are fleshed out more at the above link.)

  • D'Souza attacks Obama for trying to reduce nuclear stockpiles. D'Souza claims this is part of Obama's effort to weaken America. The Obama team points out that these efforts have bipartisan support.
  • D'Souza claims that Obama does not believe in American exceptionalism. The Obama team claims that he does.
  • D'Souza claims that Obama funded a 2 billion Brazilian oil exploration. The Obama team says that Obama had nothing to do with that.
  • D'Souza claims that Obama backed the release of the Lockerbie bomber. The Obama teams says that's not true.
  • D'Souza claims that Obama signed the bank bailout bill into effect when it was Bush who signed the law. Obama just ran most of the bailout after he took office.

Having presented this list I should point out that many of the claims D'Souza makes remain unchallenged. Since much of the movie is based on Obama's own words it would be hard to challenge those parts. In fact, in much of the movie Obama himself is heard quoting from his own book, "Dreams of My Father", to support the most damning charges D'Souza makes, e.g., that Obama has preferred the company of and has sympathized with the ideas of hard left wing radicals dedicated to the overthrow of American "colonialism" for many years. Obama makes it very clear in his book that this was in response to his father's ideas as Obama understood them. If Obama made the transition to a more mainstream ideology along the way Obama has provided no explanation for why or how that happened.

Many left wingers will see the movie and find that they agree with much of what Obama thinks even as filtered by a right wing pundit. The thing is, though, that most Americans, even most Obama supporters, are not aware of these issues.

Obama's first response:

obama-flag.jpg
 
Your proof? Sounds like more of the fantasies about the fake film maker using nonsense to spread political propaganda before an election...the right wing is FAMOUS for this.

Sorry. If you didn't see the film, I'm not going to educate you about it. He had three mentors in his life as a young man -- they've been posted here ad infinitum. If you haven't read them, nor seen the movie? Makes no nevermind to me. You're never going to vote for him anyway. And I don't care what you think. At least not tonight. ;)
 
I'm not going to discuss this with you. It's all been posted here many times before -- the wonderful things he's done through Bain -- through his personal generosity. You're never going to vote for him. Never going to respect him as a human being. I'm not going to waste my time. Get educated and come back some time.


So, you have no proof, just the fantasies you hear from the right wing pundits. I kinda suspected as much, but thought I'd give you a chance to reveal a TRUE source.
 
Obama himself is heard reading passages of his book in the movie several times to back up what is being said.

It would be obvious to you had you seen the movie.



Yeah, and Breitbart made a KILLING retouching youtube videos to make them into something they were not. Sorry...that's not good enough when you have a right wing political pundit who wrote the fantasy himself during an election year.
 
So, you have no proof, just the fantasies you hear from the right wing pundits. I kinda suspected as much, but thought I'd give you a chance to reveal a TRUE source.

I don't choose to waste my time, Muddy. Go look it up yourself and stop reading/believing the left wing spins. There's plenty of sources. You're just too lazy to go find out for yourself. I've done my homework through independent sources. You?? Never mind, I already know the answer.
 
I think he wasn't raised in the "United States."
He did spend time outside the US, yes, but...
He was mentored by people who were absolutely not capitalists. He was raised by people who fully embraced his father's vision of the world.
He was raised in no small part by, and in adulthood remained close to his grandparents, in the United States (his mother too in the US for a few of those years). His grandparents were a salesman and an honest-to-goodness bank VP. You are trying to tell me they weren't capitalists?

But all that dancing about and speculated what this or that influence in his childhood means gets trumped by decades of tangible evidence of his adulthood. We aren't defined by our environment, we are defined by our choices, and he's shown himself to be well within the range of any salient definition of 'capitalist'.
And. How can you even go there? Romney's too rich! He's out of touch with "the real America."
WTF is that coming from?
 
Back
Top Bottom