• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Scientists identify potential birth control 'pill' for men

Anomalism

Banned
DP Veteran
Joined
Dec 2, 2013
Messages
3,237
Reaction score
2,159
Location
Florida
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Libertarian - Left
Scientists identify potential birth control 'pill' for men

Two drugs that help suppress the immune system in organ transplant patients may have a future as the long-sought birth control "pill" for men, new research suggests. The drugs - cyclosporine A (also known as CsA) and FK506 (also known as tacrolimus) - are given to transplant recipients to reduce the risk that the patient's body will reject its new organ. They work by preventing the immune system from making a protein that would otherwise mobilize T-cells to attack. Specifically, they do this by inhibiting an enzyme called calcineurin. By studying mice, researchers in Japan identified a version of calcineurin that is found only in sperm. This particular version contains a pair of proteins, called PPP3CC and PPP3R2.

To figure out what these proteins do, the researchers created male mice that were unable to make the PPP3CC protein (and thus produced less of the PPP3R2 protein). Then they studied the "knockout" animals to see how they were different from regular mice. The knockout mice still had sex with female mice, but the females didn't become pregnant. The absence of PPP3CC must be making the males infertile, the researchers figured. So they set about figuring out why.

They found that sperm from the knockout mice were able to reach the part of the ovary where eggs are usually fertilized. Although the number of sperm that completed the journey was lower than in regular mice, it wasn't low enough to explain the infertility. So they performed in vitro fertilization using sperm from the knockout mice. The sperm were unable to fertilize an egg as long as the egg was covered by its usual layer of cumulus cells. But it wasn't the cumulus cells that were the problem. In further tests, the researchers found that the sperm could make their way through these cells and bind to the zona pellucida, or ZP, the membrane that surrounds the egg. But that was as far as they could go.
 
So it crippled the sperm? I'm not exactly sure that making drugs that cripple sperm is a great idea.
 
So it crippled the sperm? I'm not exactly sure that making drugs that cripple sperm is a great idea.

That depends, now doesn't it. Does the effect stay when the drug is not being made, or does it alter the DNA? If the answer is now, then , why not.

I
 
The utility of the drug will depend on whether or not the effects only last as long as the drug is taken and go away when it isn't. That is what is needed, right? A pill that can allow a man to turn his fertility off when he doesn't want to be a father and then turn it back on by ceasing use of the drug.

We need to be certain, though, that there aren't any lasting effects that might cause congenital defects in any child the man fathers later down the road.

I hope it pans out. Many women have medical issues with birth control pills. And not everyone wants to go the semi-permanent route of surgery. And sorry, but if you are in a monogamous relationship condoms are a drag.
 
So it crippled the sperm? I'm not exactly sure that making drugs that cripple sperm is a great idea.

imagine how much it would improve society if it was a required additive in beer, wine, and booze


almost as good as requiring a 'fishing' license to have a kid
 
Scientists identify potential birth control 'pill' for men

Two drugs that help suppress the immune system in organ transplant patients may have a future as the long-sought birth control "pill" for men, new research suggests. The drugs - cyclosporine A (also known as CsA) and FK506 (also known as tacrolimus) - are given to transplant recipients to reduce the risk that the patient's body will reject its new organ. They work by preventing the immune system from making a protein that would otherwise mobilize T-cells to attack. Specifically, they do this by inhibiting an enzyme called calcineurin. By studying mice, researchers in Japan identified a version of calcineurin that is found only in sperm. This particular version contains a pair of proteins, called PPP3CC and PPP3R2.

To figure out what these proteins do, the researchers created male mice that were unable to make the PPP3CC protein (and thus produced less of the PPP3R2 protein). Then they studied the "knockout" animals to see how they were different from regular mice. The knockout mice still had sex with female mice, but the females didn't become pregnant. The absence of PPP3CC must be making the males infertile, the researchers figured. So they set about figuring out why.

They found that sperm from the knockout mice were able to reach the part of the ovary where eggs are usually fertilized. Although the number of sperm that completed the journey was lower than in regular mice, it wasn't low enough to explain the infertility. So they performed in vitro fertilization using sperm from the knockout mice. The sperm were unable to fertilize an egg as long as the egg was covered by its usual layer of cumulus cells. But it wasn't the cumulus cells that were the problem. In further tests, the researchers found that the sperm could make their way through these cells and bind to the zona pellucida, or ZP, the membrane that surrounds the egg. But that was as far as they could go.

This is brilliant! If they can successfully prevent unwanted pregnancy with such a drug, there will be no more argument for abortions out of convenience. I would totally support this!

Fact #8: Less than 1% of all abortions are performed to save the life of the mother.
 
Last edited:
Scientists identify potential birth control 'pill' for men

Two drugs that help suppress the immune system in organ transplant patients may have a future as the long-sought birth control "pill" for men, new research suggests. The drugs - cyclosporine A (also known as CsA) and FK506 (also known as tacrolimus) - are given to transplant recipients to reduce the risk that the patient's body will reject its new organ. They work by preventing the immune system from making a protein that would otherwise mobilize T-cells to attack. Specifically, they do this by inhibiting an enzyme called calcineurin. By studying mice, researchers in Japan identified a version of calcineurin that is found only in sperm. This particular version contains a pair of proteins, called PPP3CC and PPP3R2.

To figure out what these proteins do, the researchers created male mice that were unable to make the PPP3CC protein (and thus produced less of the PPP3R2 protein). Then they studied the "knockout" animals to see how they were different from regular mice. The knockout mice still had sex with female mice, but the females didn't become pregnant. The absence of PPP3CC must be making the males infertile, the researchers figured. So they set about figuring out why.

They found that sperm from the knockout mice were able to reach the part of the ovary where eggs are usually fertilized. Although the number of sperm that completed the journey was lower than in regular mice, it wasn't low enough to explain the infertility. So they performed in vitro fertilization using sperm from the knockout mice. The sperm were unable to fertilize an egg as long as the egg was covered by its usual layer of cumulus cells. But it wasn't the cumulus cells that were the problem. In further tests, the researchers found that the sperm could make their way through these cells and bind to the zona pellucida, or ZP, the membrane that surrounds the egg. But that was as far as they could go.

This claim is made every few years, and so far none of them have worked out. I'll believe it when I see a product that is actually brought to market.
 
This is brilliant! If they can successfully prevent unwanted pregnancy with such a drug, there will be no more argument for abortions out of convenience. I would totally support this!

Fact #8: Less than 1% of all abortions are performed to save the life of the mother.

If contraception for women doesn't always work, what makes you think this will? Even vasectomies and tubals sometimes fail. There is no such thing as "perfect," and probably never will be.

Beyond that, I don't think people deserve to be forced into children, as though kids were a punishment, simply for making a mistake.

If $250,000, your health, and your future is just a matter of "convenience" to you, then you're hopeless.
 
Last edited:
This claim is made every few years, and so far none of them have worked out. I'll believe it when I see a product that is actually brought to market.

Yeah, this is where I'm at. I really would love to see something else out there for men. I know lots of men who would love to have something like this, and I feel their pain. Because I can't be on hormones or have IUD's, I was in the same position men are for years: condoms or sterilization. That's it.

I'm childfree, so fortunately a tubal was an option for me once I found a doctor to do it, and I have. But it's a really disappointing array of options, especially if you actually do want kids. Then you've got nothing but a barrier method, which, let's be honest, is just a drag if you're in a monogamous relationship.

It's 2015 and I feel like we should have figured this out by now. I hope this does make it to market, but like you said, I'm not going to get excited until they announce that it's in final trials and coming soon.
 
Last edited:
But it's a really disappointing array of options, especially if you actually do want kids. Then you've got nothing but a barrier method, which, let's be honest, is just a drag if you're in a monogamous relationship.

Yeah, I'm in a position where I don't want more kids right now, but haven't decided if I'm done having them entirely. So something like this would be great for me, especially since my wife has some problems with hormonal birth control.

And condoms are just terrible. Our sex life got so much better when we stopped using them, and we haven't gone back. They're bad enough she's willing to put up with the side effects of the birth control to avoid them.
 
That depends, now doesn't it. Does the effect stay when the drug is not being made, or does it alter the DNA? If the answer is now, then , why not.

I

I want to know exactly how it works. Is there any chance at all that sperm could still fertilize the egg? If it does impregnate the egg does it raise the chances of birth defects or miscarriage? If so, by how much? Why is the sperm count of the mice that use it lower? Does it affect production of sperm? If so, what affect does that cause to the testes? I'm not really interested in something that could negatively impact my testicles, so if that is at all possible, the answer is no.

Either way, from the experiences my mother has had with new drugs I have found that it is best to not use drugs until all the side effects are known, which sadly is many years after the fact.
 
Scientists identify potential birth control 'pill' for men

Two drugs that help suppress the immune system in organ transplant patients may have a future as the long-sought birth control "pill" for men, new research suggests. The drugs - cyclosporine A (also known as CsA) and FK506 (also known as tacrolimus) - are given to transplant recipients to reduce the risk that the patient's body will reject its new organ. They work by preventing the immune system from making a protein that would otherwise mobilize T-cells to attack. Specifically, they do this by inhibiting an enzyme called calcineurin. By studying mice, researchers in Japan identified a version of calcineurin that is found only in sperm. This particular version contains a pair of proteins, called PPP3CC and PPP3R2.

To figure out what these proteins do, the researchers created male mice that were unable to make the PPP3CC protein (and thus produced less of the PPP3R2 protein). Then they studied the "knockout" animals to see how they were different from regular mice. The knockout mice still had sex with female mice, but the females didn't become pregnant. The absence of PPP3CC must be making the males infertile, the researchers figured. So they set about figuring out why.

They found that sperm from the knockout mice were able to reach the part of the ovary where eggs are usually fertilized. Although the number of sperm that completed the journey was lower than in regular mice, it wasn't low enough to explain the infertility. So they performed in vitro fertilization using sperm from the knockout mice. The sperm were unable to fertilize an egg as long as the egg was covered by its usual layer of cumulus cells. But it wasn't the cumulus cells that were the problem. In further tests, the researchers found that the sperm could make their way through these cells and bind to the zona pellucida, or ZP, the membrane that surrounds the egg. But that was as far as they could go.

It ought to be banned.
 
why, since the desire is NOT to proceed with conception

Because it is unnatural. It is contrary to the natural purpose of Hunan sexuality.
 
Because it is unnatural. It is contrary to the natural purpose of Hunan sexuality.

it is the desire of the two consenting adults engaging in sexual activity
what has authority above their consent?
 
it is the desire of the two consenting adults engaging in sexual activity
what has authority above their consent?

The state, which is the institutionalized aspect of the community, has the authority to regulate relations between members of the community.
 
The state, which is the institutionalized aspect of the community, has the authority to regulate relations between members of the community.

you believe the state should be able to trump a decision between two consenting adults, which decision imposes no harm on anyone
so much for personal liberty within your realm
 
you believe the state should be able to trump a decision between two consenting adults, which decision imposes no harm on anyone
so much for personal liberty within your realm

It involves moral harm to the parties.
 
If contraception for women doesn't always work, what makes you think this will? Even vasectomies and tubals sometimes fail. There is no such thing as "perfect," and probably never will be.

Beyond that, I don't think people deserve to be forced into children, as though kids were a punishment, simply for making a mistake.

If $250,000, your health, and your future is just a matter of "convenience" to you, then you're hopeless.

Technically, abstinence is perfect.

rekt :cool:
 
Technically, abstinence is perfect.

rekt :cool:

Not necessarily. Rape.

Also, I don't think it's humane to expect adult humans to never have intimacy unless they want to be saddled with children.
 
Technically, abstinence is perfect.

rekt :cool:

Technically, absence is sexual repression, and can cause a lot of psychological problems
 
Technically, absence is sexual repression, and can cause a lot of psychological problems

And some people have psychological problems from sexual over stimulation and activity.
 
And some people have psychological problems from sexual over stimulation and activity.

And, quite often, the sexual over stimulation and activity was a response to sexual repression in their childhood.
 
This is brilliant! If they can successfully prevent unwanted pregnancy with such a drug, there will be no more argument for abortions out of convenience. I would totally support this!

Fact #8: Less than 1% of all abortions are performed to save the life of the mother.

Are you going to force men to use it? LOL If what you say is true, it would be the case now with the female Pill and other birth control. (None of which, including this proposed pill for men, works 100% of the time).
 
Back
Top Bottom