• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Proof Geek Squad is a Scam!

The Giant Noodle

DP Veteran
Joined
Mar 22, 2010
Messages
7,332
Reaction score
2,011
Location
Northern Illinois
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Independent
Ive said this a million times.... Best Buys Geek Squad is utter crap. They seem to break more crap than they fix and the fees are INSANE. They lie about what they know and push fees and crap you dont need. I wouldnt let them even TOUCH my computer

Consumerist reader K. recently ended his 4.5 year tenure as a Geek Squad member at Best Buy. And while he says that he considers his time there to be "generally a positive experience," K. did feel that there is some backstage info the public might want to know.
K. writes:

1. A high percentage of Geek Squad employees lack basic troubleshooting skills such as correctly identifying malfunctioning components. This stems from inadequate and outdated training materials, such as the Best Buy Learning Lounge.

2. People are hired or promoted from other departments to Geek Squad simply to sell services. Specifically, individuals who have no experience working on computers are given the appearance of being a technician.

3. Selling services and warranties are pushed more than actually completing repairs. I remember one instance where my GM said that selling a new computer with services was more important than completing a customer's unit that they had already paid for.

4. Employees are taught situational tactics to extract as much money as possible from a potential customer. If an individual had a small software issue that could simply be resolved, then we were taught to charge $200.

5. Although this changed shortly before I left, Geek Squad employees at the store I worked at were required to track each individual sale. Before the end of your shift, you were required to get a manager to look at your sales sheet and sign it. If you weren't doing so well, then the manager "coached" you on how to sell more services.

6. Best Buy Credit Cards were pushed to customers at every available opportunity. More than once, I witnessed Best Buy employees talking to people about signing up for a credit card, only to find out they were not old enough. Also, we were taught in Geek Squad to push the credit card even if the customer was already paying with another form of tender.

7. There is no chance for advancement within the Geek Squad department. The only position an employee could move up to is the Manager.

8. Best Buy does not encourage Geek Squad employees to get certifications or reimburse or pay for part of taking a certification. I specifically remember inquiring about this, and apparently there exists such a program for the GS Auto Techs in which they also get paid more for each certification passed, but not for GS Computer Techs.

9. Geek Squad City, the repair center for repairs we could not do in-store (any repair that was not a hard drive, memory, or power supply replacement), routinely completed unsatisfactory repair work. There were times I would send off a computer 3 times for a verified issue and the unit would come back with the same issue un-repaired. The worst example I can remember was a laptop that had its screen replaced and where the webcam was supposed to be on the screen bezel was instead a screw that held the LCD together.

9 Confessions Of A Former Geek Squad Geek - The Consumerist
 
I would never use them! They are a ripoff:(
 
They charge a boatload for simple software installation as well. On OS X, many times you literally can drag one icon into another icon within the same installation folder to complete the installation. The Geeks' input would last for about, 2 seconds maximum, with your Mac doing the rest. For more "complicated" installs, we are talking clicking ok, typing in your user password, and telling it where to install. That is clearly worth a ton of dough. They also are known to charge 30 bucks for PS3 firmware updates that essentially boil down to user connecting to the internet via wired connection or wireless connection, okaying the update, go through terms of service and okay it, then wait a few minutes and it's done. But perhaps that is clearly the fault of an uneducated computer populace? Not necessarily to me.

Then there's stuff like this http://www.kptv.com/technology/19514587/detail.html and it just blows your sanity. Then you consider the fact that they dramatically overcharge for the cables in said Best Buy locations, just in case you need them.
 
Last edited:
They charge a boatload for simple software installation as well. On OS X, many times you literally can drag one icon into another icon within the same installation folder to complete the installation. The Geeks' input would last for about, 2 seconds maximum, with your Mac doing the rest. For more "complicated" installs, we are talking clicking ok, typing in your user password, and telling it where to install. That is clearly worth a ton of dough. They also are known to charge 30 bucks for PS3 firmware updates that essentially boil down to user connecting to the internet via wired connection or wireless connection, okaying the update, go through terms of service and okay it, then wait a few minutes and it's done. But perhaps that is clearly the fault of an uneducated computer populace? Not necessarily to me.

Then there's stuff like this FOX 12 Investigators: Computer Repair Shops Put To Test - Technology News Story - KPTV Portland and it just blows your sanity. Then you consider the fact that they dramatically overcharge for the cables in said Best Buy locations, just in case you need them.

On the other hand, some people are so technology illiterate that they are unable to accomplish this task themselves. They're a captive market.

Monster cables are a very similar Stupid Tax.
 
On the other hand, some people are so technology illiterate that they are unable to accomplish this task themselves. They're a captive market.

Monster cables are a very similar Stupid Tax.

I didn't want to completely eliminate the possibility that it was deserved on their part, but certainly....questionable. This is the sort of thing that makes you wish you could scold them for telling your grandmother that this was the only way something could be done.

Monster Cables are amazing....double helix.....isolated cables.....and...shiny.... it completely takes digital and makes it like...analog again! Yeah, Monster Cables are the snake-oil products of the audio/video industry.
 
Last edited:
On the other hand, some people are so technology illiterate that they are unable to accomplish this task themselves. They're a captive market.

Monster cables are a very similar Stupid Tax.

I have monster cables living under my bed :(
 
You're better off taking it to your local computer store. I take my broken computers to people at work, but they say all the time Geek Squad is terrible. Not only because the people are inexperienced, and if there is a problem with the computer that is above putting the stupid geek squad disk in and pressing a button, they send your system out of the building to someone who actually knows how to fix it. They also have ridiculously overinflated prices.
 
Take it to Radio Shack, or I should say, this used to be the thing to do. They'd fix it for free most times. Now, Radio Shack is run by the same people that drove BlockBuster into the ground. Wonder why RS is doing so poorly, there is your answer.


Tim-
 
I consider myself fairly computer literate, so I never used services like these. However, when I bought my last laptop at Best Buy, a Geek Squad employee came to me (the Geek Squad is part of my local Best Buy) and offered to set my computer up for "only $70."

I was amazed at the price so I asked what they would do for $70. They said that they would "nstall a security program, and Microsoft Office 2010, and that they would create a backup partition on my hard drive. It was ridiculous, a ten-year-old can do all that; who would pay $70 for that?
 
You're better off taking it to your local computer store. I take my broken computers to people at work, but they say all the time Geek Squad is terrible. Not only because the people are inexperienced, and if there is a problem with the computer that is above putting the stupid geek squad disk in and pressing a button, they send your system out of the building to someone who actually knows how to fix it. They also have ridiculously overinflated prices.

I've always taken mine to the town geek - he's great, doesn't charge an arm and a leg - and he's truly involved and knowledgable. Computers interest him - he enjoys what he does. . . he's awesome.
 
I consider myself fairly computer literate, so I never used services like these. However, when I bought my last laptop at Best Buy, a Geek Squad employee came to me (the Geek Squad is part of my local Best Buy) and offered to set my computer up for "only $70."

I was amazed at the price so I asked what they would do for $70. They said that they would "nstall a security program, and Microsoft Office 2010, and that they would create a backup partition on my hard drive. It was ridiculous, a ten-year-old can do all that; who would pay $70 for that?

Someone who is 60 years old and has no idea what those words even mean.
 
As one time Best Buy Employee I will say there is a REASON I quit working there, and why if I am forced to make a purchase there, I do so only if it's on a big sale (cause that hurts their bottom line) and I NEVER sign Warranties or "Protection Plans". I just tell them "I'm a former employee, save your breath I know better".

The Geek Squad was a joke, I sold Computer Equipment... what drove me over the edge? (this was 2006 btw), I sold a PC to a gentleman of limited resources, I did a decent sales pitch but he had a budget and that was that. When I inquired about ISP's he said he was just going to sign up with AOL Dial Up because he lived out in the boonies. I offered one of our $15 AOL disks we carried at the time, that came with the first month paid, he declined and said he'd use the AOL that came with the PC. (There was an AOL Logo on the box).

So I sold the PC and prepared to go back to work, my "supervisor" grabbed, me took me to the back training area and ripped me a new one for that. "You tell them next time, "Sir, you have to buy the AOL disc to get AOL with your PC, it won't work otherwise". I told him I refused to lie to a customer. Two days later he "followed" me around the store with a little clip board and "rated" my sales, and basically rated me the worst employee in the store and reduced my hours from 40 to 29 for failure to "understand my job".

I filed a complaint with HR and ten days later walked off the job.

What made me laugh was his golden boy "super seller" who would routinely send people out the door with WAY more PC then they needed, loaded down with crap they didn't need and every warranty we offered had a return rate of over 60%. My return rate was 8.3%
 
What made me laugh was his golden boy "super seller" who would routinely send people out the door with WAY more PC then they needed, loaded down with crap they didn't need and every warranty we offered had a return rate of over 60%. My return rate was 8.3%
Sometimes, I s'pose, you have to choose if you would rather have customers or sales.
 
Back
Top Bottom