• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!
  • Welcome to our archives. No new posts are allowed here.

Why does God care? The Moral Problem

I know guys, I know, it's easy to answer this question using the basic tenants of religious text and the empirical world we see as many religionist often reminds us of our biological nature, to sustenance, to miracles. But setting all theological findings aside, why would God care? According to Astrophysicists there are about roughly 300 to 400 billion stars in our galaxy alone, but estimates on how many galaxies show that there is roughly 100 to 200 billion galaxies. That figure to me is incomprehensible because I am so small in such a vast universe and if some creature in a vast unknown galaxy dies I wont shed a tear, not because I'm incapable of mourning for that creature or because I don't care, but because it has no effect on my life because I don't know that creature and even if I did , I haven't established enough feelings to care. I personally feel like when a human being dies in comparison to the universe it is as if a fire ant somewhere in South America has died. I personally feel no significance to this planet nor to the universe so my question is why would God care about the affairs of various beings? If you believe in aliens then this question also applies as well. It's hard to fathom why such a deity that is beyond comprehension and who, designed this universe would care about the morality of mere coporeal beings.

Why would God care whether I help an elderly lady across the street, or shoot a small child in the face? If mean if you strip the religious moral text away from this question then you come to a type of pragmatic agnosticism. I cannot fathom why or how a deity would create all these galaxies, billions of them with the possibility of life yet would hold a mere microbe called a "human being" in contempt for some moral deviance. I mean, let us assume there is intelligent life in its own peculiar form, it is impossible to know that these beings would have the same moral code as humans and if so then their set of moral standards are obviously different but seeing out moral codes may vary in the midst of all things I have to ask again why would God care?

Again strip away your religious beliefs for a moment and try to answer this question.
What can I say?

I guess God is a little more godlike than you are.
 
I know guys, I know, it's easy to answer this question using the basic tenants of religious text and the empirical world we see as many religionist often reminds us of our biological nature, to sustenance, to miracles. But setting all theological findings aside, why would God care? According to Astrophysicists there are about roughly 300 to 400 billion stars in our galaxy alone, but estimates on how many galaxies show that there is roughly 100 to 200 billion galaxies. That figure to me is incomprehensible because I am so small in such a vast universe and if some creature in a vast unknown galaxy dies I wont shed a tear, not because I'm incapable of mourning for that creature or because I don't care, but because it has no effect on my life because I don't know that creature and even if I did , I haven't established enough feelings to care. I personally feel like when a human being dies in comparison to the universe it is as if a fire ant somewhere in South America has died. I personally feel no significance to this planet nor to the universe so my question is why would God care about the affairs of various beings? If you believe in aliens then this question also applies as well. It's hard to fathom why such a deity that is beyond comprehension and who, designed this universe would care about the morality of mere coporeal beings.

Why would God care whether I help an elderly lady across the street, or shoot a small child in the face? If mean if you strip the religious moral text away from this question then you come to a type of pragmatic agnosticism. I cannot fathom why or how a deity would create all these galaxies, billions of them with the possibility of life yet would hold a mere microbe called a "human being" in contempt for some moral deviance. I mean, let us assume there is intelligent life in its own peculiar form, it is impossible to know that these beings would have the same moral code as humans and if so then their set of moral standards are obviously different but seeing out moral codes may vary in the midst of all things I have to ask again why would God care?

Again strip away your religious beliefs for a moment and try to answer this question.



I am not a religious person but I believe for those who are perhaps it is because he is the Creator. He created everyone and everything and is therefore linked to each and every being. We tend to project human emotions onto the God we create so his care or concern is seen as parental. I could have 20 children but because they came from me and are of me I care about each and every one equally. So if a God did exist who was capable of creating ALL then he would be capable and committed to ALL.

There are really two questions here. The second is about how he views individual morality. I think the notion is that we are happier more complete beings when we exist in love. When our actions and our beings are centered in love. When you act out aggressively or in hate against another creature you pollute yourself, your spirit. Because he is the Father he wishes the best for us, that being freedom from such things. That need for purity is present in us because we were created in his image.
 
Back
Top Bottom