- Joined
- Jun 10, 2005
- Messages
- 26,589
- Reaction score
- 12,250
- Location
- Highlands Ranch, CO
- Gender
- Male
- Political Leaning
- Independent
Not really... most Islamic Caliphates were tolerant of other religions. Jews, Christians, and Muslims lived at peace in the Islamic world for centuries for the most part. It was in fact the Christian world that was the murdering bastards when it came to other religions and even other Christian sects.. the UK went through centuries of Catholic vs Protestant wars as did much of Europe.
The Christian reformation. Something the Islamic world has failed to do, which is why it is in the state it is in. Imagine Christianity today without a protestant movement. But slaughter on the European continent was more a European thing than a Christian thing. Or did Europeans need Christianity to create two world wars? In the end, violence on the European continent was about tribe. You all have proven to merely be the Middle East Lite.
But you seem to be glossing over the very real blood shed and oppression between Islamic tribes down through the centuries across the region. There were plenty of occasions where violence was sparked between rival caliphates. Plenty of occassion where tribes within Islam were suppressed for the greater good of Arab empire. Of course, then there were the "purification jihads" on the Arabian peninsula where religious structures were destroyed and non-adherents to Sunni Islam were slaughtered. And are you aware that Islamic extremists for a century have murdered far more of their own Muslims than Westerners? By all means, enjoy criticizing Christianity, but don't do it while glorifying an ignorant perception of Islam.
Living in "peace" in the Islamic world meant certain taxes for being non-Islamic. It also meant certain restrictions on religious freedom and structures. In other words, as long as they behaved and followed the rules, they were "tolerated." Did you know that in Saudi Arabia today, the Shia are denied the right to name their children certain names that might offend the Sunni tribe? And that they are denied certain religious freedoms? And that they are held to different laws than the Sunni? And that the House of Saud is famous for funding thousands of schools throughout the world and the fundamental base of these schools is to legitimize the Sunni school of thought? Some would call such things oppression or age old colonialism within the Islamic world. I guess others call it "peace."