• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Should Prostitution Remain Illegal?

Should Prostitution Remain Illegal In Most States?

  • Yes.

    Votes: 5 11.9%
  • No.

    Votes: 37 88.1%

  • Total voters
    42

Devil505

Banned
Joined
Apr 13, 2009
Messages
3,512
Reaction score
315
Location
Masschusetts
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Moderate
I can see absolutely no good reason to not legalize/Tax & regulate it.
Since we all know it's a victimless crime & impossible to end legislatively, why not legalize it?
 
I can see absolutely no good reason to not legalize/Tax & regulate it.
Since we all know it's a victimless crime & impossible to end legislatively, why not legalize it?
I agree, and they should start with a buy one and get one free promo
 
I'm sorry I meant to vote "no" in this poll (I read the question the opposite way).

I agree with the OP, let's tax it.
 
I'm sorry I meant to vote "no" in this poll (I read the question the opposite way).

I agree with the OP, let's tax it.
traitor it hasnt got options
 
I can see absolutely no good reason to not legalize/Tax & regulate it.
Since we all know it's a victimless crime & impossible to end legislatively, why not legalize it?

As a crime prostitution is not victimless.

It's illegality creates a dark underbelly that is rife with victims, whether it be human smuggling, a pimp beating up his hoe, a john beating up his hoe, an std being brought home to an unsuspecting spouse, taxpayers, or hell even the government for non reported income.

These victims are not from a consensual act between 2 adults, these victims are because that act is illegal.
 
Last edited:
It should absolutely be legal. Though on questions of morality, I am almost always on the side of debauchery and/or individual freedom!!
 
Your failed comment re another devil poll

I'm amazed that I actually understood your post Zeebub, that grammar is confusing.

Anyway, this was more of an absolute question, and plus I had no intention of voting "other" here anyway. But yes I agree that this poll should have an "other" option as well.
 
It should absolutely be legal. Though on questions of morality, I am almost always on the side of debauchery and/or individual freedom!!
prostitution is legal in the UK mate:)
 
As a crime prostitution is not victimless.

It's illegality creates a dark underbelly that is rife with victims, whether it be human smuggling, a pimp beating up his hoe, a john beating up his hoe, an std being brought home to an unsuspecting spouse, taxpayers, or hell even the government for non reported income.

These victims are not from a consensual act between 2 adults, these victims are because that act is illegal.

If I'm understanding your argument, you are saying that the fact that is still is a crime is what creates a victim?
So if we legalize it, that would end the creation of any victims? (if that's your point...I would agree)
 
If I'm understanding your argument, you are saying that the fact that is still is a crime is what creates a victim?
So if we legalize it, that would end the creation of any victims? (if that's your point...I would agree)

Yes, when we make a victimless act a criminal act it ceases to be victimless. It is its criminality that is victimizing.

Making it criminal creates the victims, not the act.

to split hairs even further, the term "victimless crime" is horrendous.. it makes the assumption that an act is a crime, and even when used in the context of making it legal the act still remains a "crime".
 
Last edited:
No.

What can possibly be moral or logical justification for outlawing the point of life - sex ?
 
As a crime prostitution is not victimless.

It's illegality creates a dark underbelly that is rife with victims, whether it be human smuggling, a pimp beating up his hoe, a john beating up his hoe, an std being brought home to an unsuspecting spouse, taxpayers, or hell even the government for non reported income.

These victims are not from a consensual act between 2 adults, these victims are because that act is illegal.

Just a point here but if prostitution were to become legal then regulations could be set up to where such things as mentioned here would not happen.

For example:

If legal then a "john" would be stupid to beat up his "hoe" as the reason that they do so now is because prostitution is illegal...so the "hoe" won't go to the police for fear of being arrested herself.

Human smuggling is mainly used by criminals because of rich guy's "tastes". IE 10 year old girls or "virgin" chinese etc etc. So doubt that would stop. But then again human smuggling is a whole nother catagory in itself.

STD's could be made to be checked for regularly if someone is in this field of work. IF made legal. As it stands there is more of a chance of contracting an std from a prostitute because they don't have regular check-ups.
 
I'm assuming we'll hear some religious arguments (about not corrupting our children or some such other BS...imo) in favor of keeping it illegal, but I seriously can't think of a single logical argument for doing so. :confused: (not to mention the fact that trying to outlaw something as basic a need as sex would be like having Congress make gravity illegal..........& then trying to enforce their new law outlawing it)
 
Last edited:
Just a point here but if prostitution were to become legal then regulations could be set up to where such things as mentioned here would not happen.

For example ...

exactly my point.

These things happen because it is illegal.

just like drugs,

The act itself is mostly harmless relative to a prohibition which is disastrous.
 
Last edited:
I can see absolutely no good reason to not legalize/Tax & regulate it.
Since we all know it's a victimless crime & impossible to end legislatively, why not legalize it?
it's not a victimless crime, but possibly should be legal.
 
It should be legalized, but not legitimized.

Let me explain.

I don't think the act should necessarily be illegal. IE the act of exchanging goods (cash) for service (well...um "service"). I don't mind certain. I don't mind a bit of regulation in regards to where said things can be advertised or offered.

By legitimized however is I mean I don't think it should be an out there in your face lets promote it as a possible path of employement type of thing. Its ultimately still an adult only entertainment venue. I wouldn't want to see it legalized and then in some way glamorized or pushed as a mainstream thing. Not saying pass legislation against such, but I would hope (and think) it'll be treated like sex shops, strip clubs, etc in regards to general community acceptance and forms of advertising/pervasiveness in the culture than something more "legitimate".
 
Interesting.. Three responders say that prostitution should remain illegal, yet they have nothing to say.
America, lets enter the 20th century and leave the 16th century.
Tax and regulate prostitution, as the civilized countries do.
Follow the example and leadership of Nevada.
 
It should be legalized, but not legitimized.

Let me explain.

I don't think the act should necessarily be illegal. IE the act of exchanging goods (cash) for service (well...um "service"). I don't mind certain. I don't mind a bit of regulation in regards to where said things can be advertised or offered.

By legitimized however is I mean I don't think it should be an out there in your face lets promote it as a possible path of employement type of thing. Its ultimately still an adult only entertainment venue. I wouldn't want to see it legalized and then in some way glamorized or pushed as a mainstream thing. Not saying pass legislation against such, but I would hope (and think) it'll be treated like sex shops, strip clubs, etc in regards to general community acceptance and forms of advertising/pervasiveness in the culture than something more "legitimate".
i completely agree, how weird is that?
 
I can see absolutely no good reason to not legalize/Tax & regulate it.
Since we all know it's a victimless crime & impossible to end legislatively, why not legalize it?

I do not believe there is any rational reason as to why prostitution is illegal. I think we can regulate the industry better, they can form a union for wages and such (no more pimp), the health standards can be enforced and such. Plus there's the tax revenue and such. Keeping prostitution illegal is stupid IMO.
 
I'm assuming we'll hear some religious arguments (about not corrupting our children or some such other BS...imo) in favor of keeping it illegal, but I seriously can't think of a single logical argument for doing so. :confused: (not to mention the fact that trying to outlaw something as basic a need as sex would be like having Congress make gravity illegal..........& then trying to enforce their new law outlawing it)
Nice way to foster debate. Carry on yesmen.
 
It should be legalized, but not legitimized.

Let me explain.

I don't think the act should necessarily be illegal. IE the act of exchanging goods (cash) for service (well...um "service"). I don't mind certain. I don't mind a bit of regulation in regards to where said things can be advertised or offered.

By legitimized however is I mean I don't think it should be an out there in your face lets promote it as a possible path of employement type of thing. Its ultimately still an adult only entertainment venue. I wouldn't want to see it legalized and then in some way glamorized or pushed as a mainstream thing. Not saying pass legislation against such, but I would hope (and think) it'll be treated like sex shops, strip clubs, etc in regards to general community acceptance and forms of advertising/pervasiveness in the culture than something more "legitimate".

On one hand I agree on the other I don't.

I agree because I'm a father. I agree also because I don't always try to offend other peoples sensibilities.

I don't agree because I think that hiding things from kids just hurts the kids in the long run, and in today's day and age it's damn near impossible for children to not know about sex by 8-10 years old. Heck at 6-7 years old I was playing truth or dare and seeing girl's bodies. Didn't know what the heck I was doing...just knew that others liked me for it. (that whole acceptance thing) So why not just start teach them about sex when they start asking about it? Which is surprisingly young. :3oops: :p I think that doing so would make them more responsible about it and not make it so taboo...and we all know how teenagers react to things that are taboo.....
 
Just a point here but if prostitution were to become legal then regulations could be set up to where such things as mentioned here would not happen.

For example:

If legal then a "john" would be stupid to beat up his "hoe" as the reason that they do so now is because prostitution is illegal...so the "hoe" won't go to the police for fear of being arrested herself.

Human smuggling is mainly used by criminals because of rich guy's "tastes". IE 10 year old girls or "virgin" chinese etc etc. So doubt that would stop. But then again human smuggling is a whole nother catagory in itself.

STD's could be made to be checked for regularly if someone is in this field of work. IF made legal. As it stands there is more of a chance of contracting an std from a prostitute because they don't have regular check-ups.

The hookers in Amsterdam and the Netherlands are not required to get an STD check. Trust me on that. And I have had sex with prostitutes in Germany, Denmark, Netherlands, Belgium, and Austria, Czech Republic. And I have always used a condom. And you know what? No STD. Not once. And none of the girls are made to take and STD test. Except for in Austria, I think? Austria was expensive. Actually now I remember in Austria the hookers are requiered to take an HIV test every month. When you have sex with a prostitute you have to use your head. Look at her and look closely. Talk with her somewhat to get to know her-that'll help for a lower price-and you'll know what type of girl you are having sex with. Remember that the majority of girls are like you. They don't want to get a disease. If a girl offers bareback bj's don't take it. I remember in Germany that was always a problem. The hookers said they didn't like the taste of latex in their mouths. AAnd if she is offering you bareback sex don't take it it means she probably has something nasty.

But what I'm trying to say is that yes it should be legal and condoms should be readily available. The condoms will prevent the majority of the disease transmission. Like roughly 99.97% of the time the condom will protect you from viral and bacteria disease. But everynow and then a bacteria might sneak in. And you'll get something that can be easily treated with antibiotics.
And the first time I had sex with a "normal" girl I ended up getting chlamydia.
So really this stigma that hookers are invested with disease is a lie. Maybe streetwalkers yes, but turn it into something like that of where its legal. And stds won't be so common.
 
Should prostitution remain illegal?

Is this a trick question? I should never be charged, on the other hand if the ladies want to tip me, well thats a different story ;)


Seriously, I think it is down right silly for it to remain illegal. Its the only thing I can think of right off that is legal if free but illegal if not.
 
Back
Top Bottom