Yes, and they should be integrated with the males
Yes, but keep their units seperate from male units
No, but women should be given some basic infantry skills beyond basic training
No, women should never serve in a role where they may encounter combat
"Another point well made . Especially about the old white dudes." - smartaleck
The military of the US contains many Blacks, Hispanics etc as well as whites. So why were whites singled out?
Now in your defense I think the line Deejay said was similar to saying it is a "good old boy network" or something to that effect. It is bigoted, but not along racist lines.
Racist no, sexist is most likely.
No Lives Matter
It should be based on performance, not gender; If a woman could do the job better than a man then let's do it.
Now exceptions in both cases to that rule exist, but they are so few and far in between it is not worth it.
No Lives Matter
If I'm no offend about my husband being called a old white dude why should you be? I know some people here don't have a sense of humor but really not to even know a joke when you see it?
Some people are only here to be serious and to prove they are right and everyone else is wrong and that's their thing and good for them. If you want to make a mountain out of a molehill more power to you.
I have stated over and over I'm not here to get in arguments with people who already have their minds made up . It's a wast of time to me. Thats my thing.
Hope you have a beautiful Friday. Stop and smell the flowers or in some cases pollution Have fun smile life is short.
I can't believe this thread is so popular.
Women in the infantry. Women on the "front lines" shouldn't be an argument since women have been on the front lines in Iraq since 2004. But actively carrying the 0300 MOS?
The American military is unlike every single military in the world. We constantly deploy to Cold Weather Training, Desert Training, Mountain Warfare Training, Jungle Training, etc. all over the world. A female in the American infantry doesn't mean the same thing as it does in other nations militaries. They would not be asked to hang out within their borders or stand a post in a shack within their borders or deploy occassionally when it's time to go to work. We have seen the pictures of packs, weapons systems, and battle loads but we don't stop to consider these pictures in mountainous or cold weather environments.
The vast majority of women could not stand the rigors that the vast majority of men can. Truth sucks, but there it is. For example: I just graduated a course for Gunnys. There were 99. Four of which were women. During the Confidence Course portion, all four women fell off the cable and into the water because they could not hold themselves up or pull their legs back onto the cable to shimmy or slide to the end. Of course, a few men fell too, but 100% of the women did. This is not a militay arena that should be "open" to women as it is for the men. That being said, maybe there should be a special indoc for women who actively wish to be a "Grunt." Only the few would meet the standard.
And by the way, the "old white man's club" argument merely seeks to deny the truths, which make some of us uncomfortable.
Last edited by MSgt; 08-06-09 at 08:59 PM.
First of all I being a woman really did want to be informed on this subject It only takes a little resoning on anyones part to realize women are not physically fit to do the job of a grunt as some stated. The problem I had was their might me a few women that could do it and that they should be able to at least try . Just because I knew the majority of women couldn't do it didn't make it fair that the few women who could do it couldn't get a fair chance to prove it one way or the other.
I like you idea that maybe their could be a special indoc for women who met the standards to be grunts. I"m really happy that you would be willing to give them a chance. most women cannot do the physical parts of being a grunt because nature has made them smaller and with less muscle mass but their are a few women that does not apply but like you said probably only a few.
It is so nice to know that someone in charge of women and men in the military has such a open mind and a willingness to give women the same chance as a man. I know men can incourage women to do thier best and you are one of those people..
I'm glad that women get to prove themselves one way or the other. Doesn't matter to me as long as they get the chance. It's nice to know that our kids both male and female in the military have someone like you to lead them.
Thank you so much for all you have sacrificed to be in the military. I for one am a grateful citizen. Thanks
Hmm. 100% of the four. That would be... um, four of them, right?I just graduated a course for Gunnys. There were 99. Four of which were women. During the Confidence Course portion, all four women fell off the cable and into the water because they could not hold themselves up or pull their legs back onto the cable to shimmy or slide to the end. Of course, a few men fell too, but 100% of the women did.
And "a few" of the 95 men fell off too.
How many is "a few"? More than four?
If there had been 95 women and four men in the course, do you think it's possible that all four of the men could've fallen?
Do you think all 95 of the women would've?