Let's say... next month there is a big news story of a terrorist attack stopped in the finals stages, like it was gonna go down that Monday before. You learn not only was it going to happen, but that your place of business, the flight you were on... whatever, was the target. You'd be DEAD right now if it had not been stopped.
A few months go by, and it comes out that the information to stop that attack was obtained through water boarding or worse.
Would you demand the "torturers" be tried for their "crimes"?
I mean this in all seriousness.