The question you posed is 'Does your right hand have five fingers?'
You claimed there are 'only two' possible responses to this question.
You claimed there are no other responses that make sense.
What you failed to consider is that not everyone has a right hand.
The man in the picture cannot reasonably answer your question 'yes' or 'no'.
You might argue that since he has no right hand, he must answer 'no', since he does not have five fingers on his non-existent right hand. However, your question presumes he does have a real right hand, not an imaginary right hand. If you suggest that he has an 'imaginary' right hand, then you could 'imagine' any number of fingers on that hand. In that case, the answer could be six, or three or twelve fingers.
The bottom line is that I have provided a very reasonable scenario in which your yes or no question might have some other answer.