• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Should we be holding Mexico responsible?

Should we be holding Mexico responsible?

  • Total voters
    35
TheDemSocialist said:
Destroy a peoples economy, weaken their economy, only creates more people leaving that economy.
Click to expand...

Destroy what country?


Oh you mean the top 1% of Mexicans that are white and have everything? Those people? Those people could care less about 99% of the rest of Mexico.
 
Excon said:
There you go showing everybody that you too know not oif what you speak.

Your reply and others deflecting from answering were anticipated and the question formed specifically like it was.

It weeded out those who are unable to think on their own as the answer was totally dependent on their own beliefs. Yet they failed to see it.

Your posting on the other hand was addressed by your very own ridiculous comments.
Click to expand...

don't break your ankle backpedaling off your pretzel logic.
 
based on the question alone with no reasoning and no way suggested to do so of course not, its a stupid, ilogical and irrational question
 
AGENT J said:
based on the question alone with no reasoning and no way suggested to do so of course not, its a stupid, ilogical and irrational question
Click to expand...
:doh
No J, you are wrong again.

The "How" of a "Yes" answer is totally dependent on the answerer's own beliefs.

Why that is so hard for some folks to understand, is beyond belief.​
 
Excon said:
:doh
No J, you are wrong again.

The "How" of a "Yes" answer is totally dependent on the answerer's own beliefs.

Why that is so hard for some folks to understand, is beyond belief.​
Click to expand...

nope there is nothing you posted that changes my answer, nor was anything "wrong" lol
if you disagree simply point out what was "factually" wrong and then prove it, you will fail
the answer is no
and its still a stupid illogical and irrational question as many posted pointed out
 
ttwtt78640 said:
Would you hold LA responsible if one of its residents committed a crime in TX? Do you hold the US responsible when a US tourist commits a crime in another nation?
Click to expand...

agreed unless mexico has a country/government is found to be training people, offering direct incentives to come here and break the law, or somehow protects them the idea is silly as a general question.
 
"AGENT J" said:
nope there is nothing you posted that changes my answer, nor was anything "wrong" lol
if you disagree simply point out what was "factually" wrong and then prove it, you will fail
the answer is no
and its still a stupid illogical and irrational question as many posted pointed out
Click to expand...
Already did J. You are wrong and have shown you are unwilling to think independently of another's thoughts as the question asked required one to do.


The "How" of a "Yes" answer is totally dependent on the answerer's own beliefs.​
 
Excon said:
Already did J. You are wrong and have shown you are unwilling to think independently of another's thoughts as the question asked required one to do.


The "How" of a "Yes" answer is totally dependent on the answerer's own beliefs.​
Click to expand...

translation: you cant thats what we thought lol
all you did is post your OPINION, your OPINIONS on the matter and don't mean anything

there will be no further response to you until you can provide FACTS showing how anything i said was FACTUALLY WRONG

facts win again
 
"AGENT J" said:
translation: you cant thats what we thought lol
all you did is post your OPINION, your OPINIONS on the matter and don't mean anything

there will be no further response to you until you can provide FACTS showing how anything i said was FACTUALLY WRONG

facts win again
Click to expand...
:doh iLOL
As I thought you still don't get it or you are playing a game.
I asked the question.
You failed to understand that an answer is totally dependent on your own reasoning, not someone else's.
Which you should have if you had read the thread.
So what you said was factually wrong. As it was answerable without any reasoning provided.
J ~ based on the question alone with no reasoning and no way suggested to do so of course not,​
So you were purposely playing one of your silly games again or you just didn't get it.
Either way you were and still are factually wrong. Reasoning didn't need to be provided.
 
Can't say that I blame Mexico for people wanting to come here and work.

I can and do blame our government for not fixing the problem and I guess I'm a simpleton because I believe with all the technology that we have today a big ol' fence should fix the problem.
 
Rentoc said:
Can't say that I blame Mexico for people wanting to come here and work.

I can and do blame our government for not fixing the problem and I guess I'm a simpleton because I believe with all the technology that we have today a big ol' fence should fix the problem.
Click to expand...

What can you do when people are so desperate for a better life..They'll die tryin?
 
twixie1 said:
What can you do when people are so desperate for a better life..They'll die tryin?
Click to expand...

Honestly, that's on them. There are ways to come here and work legally. There are avenues available to become a citizen legally. I am not against immigration, I am against ILLEGAL _________________. (fill in the blank)
If it's not legal, I am against it.
 
Rentoc said:
Honestly, that's on them. There are ways to come here and work legally. There are avenues available to become a citizen legally. I am not against immigration, I am against ILLEGAL _________________. (fill in the blank)
If it's not legal, I am against it.
Click to expand...

Do you not think that if these people were allowed to work legally..they wouldn't..

How can they become American citizens when they have nothing?

You could always send them all back..then you'd have to clean your own toilets..pick your own fruit..and work for less than nothing!

Have they really taken something away from you??
 
twixie1 said:
Do you not think that if these people were allowed to work legally..they wouldn't..

How can they become American citizens when they have nothing?

You could always send them all back..then you'd have to clean your own toilets..pick your own fruit..and work for less than nothing!

Have they really taken something away from you??
Click to expand...

I already clean my own toilet.

Pretty easy for someone from an island country to speak about this topic. How many desperate people sneak over the border of England each year?

It's not a question of what they are taking from me. It's a question of what is legal and what is not. It's a question of what resources are being used to support them, and what accountability there is for them.

I have a daughter who was involved in an automobile accident with an illegal. Her car was totaled, she was injured pretty bad and there was no recourse for her as the other individual simply disappeared into the shadows again.
 
Excon said:
There you go again showing you do not know what you are talking about. :doh
No one on this end said they agreed with your suggestion.


And no one has to present any specifics.

Again, what is it you do not understand about the following?

The "How" of a "Yes" answer is totally dependent on the answerer's own beliefs.

Why that is so hard for some folks to understand, is beyond belief.​
Click to expand...

I understand that you are trying not to give any specifics. Without specific action it's a BS question like "Should more good things happen?" It also assumes that the government of Mexico is in some way responsible, which you have also failed to address.

The Mexican government is innocent until proven guilty, and unless you can do so they can't be held responsible. If you can prove it beyond a reasonable doubt, then there's what the sentence would be. Which you also won't address.
 
Rentoc said:
I have a daughter who was involved in an automobile accident with an illegal. Her car was totaled, she was injured pretty bad and there was no recourse for her as the other individual simply disappeared into the shadows again.
Click to expand...

I feel bad for your daughter and for your family's bad luck. How is the Mexican government to blame?
 
Rentoc said:
I already clean my own toilet.

Pretty easy for someone from an island country to speak about this topic. How many desperate people sneak over the border of England each year?

It's not a question of what they are taking from me. It's a question of what is legal and what is not. It's a question of what resources are being used to support them, and what accountability there is for them.
Click to expand...

We have thousands of illegal immigrants..

'Complacent' Home Office loses 175,000 illegal immigrants | Daily Mail Online

And we have more in Sangatte..France waiting to jump lorries to get over the English channel..

Mostly from Africa...

The streets of Calais | Reuters.com

Italy..

More than 800,000 African immigrants headed for Europe - Italy police chief - timesofmalta.com

You don't know jack!!
 
rocket88 said:
I feel bad for your daughter and for your family's bad luck. How is the Mexican government to blame?
Click to expand...

They aren't.

The comment was in response to another member.

I voted that the Mexican Government was not to blame. In my opinion it's the individuals who are to blame. They are the ones breaking the law.
 
From what I have read, the total number of illegals in the UK is less than 600k. Less than 600K!!!!

This country has more than 5 Million illegals.

You are correct, I don't know Jack. Never met him. Is he a pretty decent fellow?
 
Rentoc said:
From what I have read, the total number of illegals in the UK is less than 600k. Less than 600K!!!!

This country has more than 5 Million illegals.

You are correct, I don't know Jack. Never met him. Is he a pretty decent fellow?
Click to expand...

I don't know..I believe his last name is Sh*te though..

You are a bigger country..so obviously you will have more illegals...not a small island as you have pointed out..
 
twixie1 said:
I don't know..I believe his last name is Sh*te though..

You are a bigger country..so obviously you will have more illegals...not a small island as you have pointed out..
Click to expand...

Thank you for confirming the point of my original comment.
 
Excon said:
Should we be holding or attempting to hold Mexico responsible for their Citizens that cross over and become illegals?
Yes or no?
Click to expand...

dont eat tex mex:roll:
 
Medusa said:
dont eat tex mex:roll:
Click to expand...
Why?
And when you answer that, how about stating just how you think your statement is relevant to the topic.
But let me guess, you already know you can't because what you said is irrelevant.
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top Bottom