- Joined
- Jul 8, 2012
- Messages
- 47,571
- Reaction score
- 16,958
- Gender
- Female
- Political Leaning
- Moderate
That's not necessary.
When the founders wrote "endowed by their Creator" and "self evident", they were referring to a simple understanding. Everyone (extremely rare exceptions based on specific circumstance) wants to live. One cannot deny ones innate desire to live. It is natural, then, to presume that others have the same desire.
Universal (extremely rare exceptions) desires, recognized by society, are socially natural rights. They are not rights derived by imagining man alone with nature, or any kind of individual natural state. After all, rights are a social construct and thereby have no meaning without the existence of the 'other'.
Thus, some rights are natural socially. It doesn't matter if they came from a God or aliens or whatever. The important thing is that we recognize that they are self evident via simple logic and reason.
Other natural rights include freedom of religion and self defense. These are things that everyone desires. These rights are self evident.
Let's remember that when discussing natural rights, we are not discussing rights that arise from a state of nature but rights that arise naturally (self evidently) from society.
I guess I can agree with that.