- Joined
- Jan 4, 2013
- Messages
- 9,122
- Reaction score
- 3,751
- Gender
- Undisclosed
- Political Leaning
- Undisclosed
As has been noted already, we would not and should not be told of the CIA's successes.
But I'll give you a few in which the CIA played - had to play - a crucial part. The capture of bin Laden, for one. Another one would be JFK's stare-down of the USSR over the missiles in Cuba, since they had to be the ones who told him what the Soviets had and did not have.
When we keep nations like Pakistan from falling apart and radicalizing, the CIA is almost certainly a part of that. When Egypt's American-supported dictator Morsi fell, did Egypt start hating America? No. Almost certainly because of the CIA, we were able to know who to contact within the new regime there in order to keep them on our side. It's the CIA that's letting us know who's the good guys and the bad guys in the protests going on in Thailand, which Chinese bigwigs are angling to improve their standing in the Party, and which South American dictator is being supported by drug lords. And they work with other nations around the world - like Englands MI-5 and Israel's Mossad - to try to advance our nations' different interests.
What the CIA does is for the most part the grunt work that gets the State Department (and other government agencies) the information it needs in order for America's diplomatic efforts to be more effective. The CIA does some things that are very wrong and no mistake - but that's not a symptom of the CIA being a grand failure. Instead, failures by the CIA are much more often instances of failures by the Executive Branch.
The successes you list are all examples of the CIA's intelligence gathering activities, which are not particularly controversial. It is when the CIA and other intelligence agencies go beyond intelligence gathering and into covert assassinations, political manipulation and sabotage, military operations etc. that they exceed their authority, undermine democracies and create hostility towards the USA and unpredictable, but not surprising, blowback.