• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Rape and Clothing

Rape and clothing correlation

  • I suspect women are wearing revealing clothes in most rape cases

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • I suspect that a man/woman will rape regardless of the victims clothing

    Votes: 24 26.4%
  • I think some women are inviting dangerous attention when wearing revealing attire

    Votes: 5 5.5%
  • I don't think clothes have anything to do with rape

    Votes: 52 57.1%
  • Other

    Votes: 10 11.0%

  • Total voters
    91
Dance? That's it? Doesn't seem like a fair trade IMO. It's like women who accept the free drink and refuse payback in the back seat after last call.

Are you assuming that every woman needs a man to pay for her drinks to dance with him? Hell, I asked my husband to dance the first night I noticed him. I don't need a drink to dance with a guy who is capable of dancing. Now this guy we referred to as "Twirly" he required a drink payment just to deal with him, but he knew I was taken and continued to come back, so...
 
Assumptions much? You cannot possibly say that most potential rapists prefer sluts. You simply can't know this.

And if they think all women are sluts anyway, then there is no reason that they would differentiate between women based on what they were wearing.

Maybe stupid men believe that women dressed a certain way are easiest, but even that I doubt. Plus you would still need to gain the woman's attention for enough time to get her to agree to go somewhere "less crowded" with you in order to reach a point to get to a "misunderstanding". Otherwise, that isn't a misunderstanding but a blatant rape situation and it would go back to the preferences of the individual rapist.

You're right. There is some assuming. I'm not a rapist. I can't ask anyone I know because they're not rapists either. I'm just cutting to the chase with Occam's Razor here.
 
Are you assuming that every woman needs a man to pay for her drinks to dance with him? Hell, I asked my husband to dance the first night I noticed him. I don't need a drink to dance with a guy who is capable of dancing. Now this guy we referred to as "Twirly" he required a drink payment just to deal with him, but he knew I was taken and continued to come back, so...

Not at all. I'm just saying that women who accept free drinks should be aware that it's not because he "wants to get to know you better".
 
And he would be wrong, which is why we send such people to jail.

No where have I implied that clothing is an actual form of consent.

Are you kidding? This is what you have been implying throughout the entire discussion . . . that girls who dress in a certain manner are sending out certain signals. This is what we have been arguing about the whole time!

We're not talking about people you know. :shrug:

Didn't you ask me what I think when I see a person dressed in a certain way? You did, and I answered your question, and now you're telling me we aren't talking about people I know? :doh

Why would it? You're not a guy, so you're not deliberately looking for those kinds of women.

On the other hand, however; if you see a man come in wearing a greasy stained T-shirt and ripped blue jeans with four days worth of stubble on his face, are you not going make certain assumptions about him based off of his style of dress?

What about a man wearing an expensive suit instead?

Be honest here, Chris.

I have been nothing but honest, so I don't know what you're insinuating, but anyway NO, I wouldn't judge a person's character based upon their choice of clothing. I would base my opinions based on a person's actions.
 
Are you assuming that every woman needs a man to pay for her drinks to dance with him? Hell, I asked my husband to dance the first night I noticed him. I don't need a drink to dance with a guy who is capable of dancing. Now this guy we referred to as "Twirly" he required a drink payment just to deal with him, but he knew I was taken and continued to come back, so...

He's saying that he thinks spending time with women is useless unless they "put out."
 
Are you saying that women who go to bars don't deserve respect?

th
 
Not at all. I'm just saying that women who accept free drinks should be aware that it's not because he "wants to get to know you better".

And men need to realize that just because you buy a drink for a woman, doesn't mean she wants to sleep with you. If you can't handle that, only buy drinks for women you know beforehand will sleep with you.
 

It's obvious that some men here on DP don't really think much differently from your average rapist then. Interesting! What could it mean?
 
And men need to realize that just because you buy a drink for a woman, doesn't mean she wants to sleep with you. If you can't handle that, only buy drinks for women you know beforehand will sleep with you.

Well, men who are desperate really don't have much of a choice but to beg and plead and then rape I guess, perhaps sometimes they use alcohol and drugs because they can't get any women otherwise. :roll:
 
It's obvious that some men here on DP don't really think much differently from your average rapist then. Interesting! What could it mean?

Or it has to do with the fact that most men are sheep.
 
You're right. There is some assuming. I'm not a rapist. I can't ask anyone I know because they're not rapists either. I'm just cutting to the chase with Occam's Razor here.

It doesn't work that way though. Plenty of guys out there who are going to try for the women they are attracted to, which isn't always going to be the one dressed the sluttiest, even for most guys.
 
Or it has to do with the fact that most men are sheep.

Or it's the difference between a man and a complete and utter loser.
 
I found this very interesting study done about college students and what factors they might consider in order to assign "blame" to one party or the other in a rape. This study is from 2007.

Here is the conclusion (link below):


The study investigated the hypothesis that college students would view a woman
who dressed provocatively as more responsible for a sexual assault than a woman who
was dressed conservatively; however, it was not supported by the data. This finding was
not consistent with previous literature, because there was not a significant main effect for
“attire” in terms of her responsibility. In order for this hypothesis to be supported by the
data, the college student’s would have needed to agree that a provocatively dressed woman
is more responsible for a sexual assault than a conservatively dressed woman.

For example, in previous research, Kanekar and Kolsawalla (1981) found that
provocative or seductive appearing victims were assigned more responsibility for rape,
than were non-provocative appearing victims. Previous literature also states that some
participants feel that the victim’s dress is under her control and is a reflection of internal
trait and that dressing in a very provocative was is reflective of promiscuousness and is
one type of sexual invitation (Lewis & Johnson, 1989), however these hypotheses were
not supported in the present study.

The second hypothesis, that college students would view a woman who drank
alcohol as more responsible for a sexual assault than a woman who had not drank, was
not supported by the data. This finding was not consistent with previous literature,
because there was not a significant main effect for alcohol consumption in terms of her
responsibility. In order for the hypothesis to be supported the participants would have
needed to agree that a woman who had drank alcohol, is viewed as more responsible for a
sexual assault than a woman who had not drank alcohol, as found in previous literature.
Richardson and Campbell (1982) found that both male and female college students
viewed the victim of rape as more responsible than the perpetrator when she was drunk.

Another study that was not supported by the present study was that women who drink are
viewed as more responsible for an assault than a woman who does not drink (Blume,
1991).

The third hypothesis, that predicted a significant interaction in that a woman is
viewed as much more responsible for an assault if she was dressed provocatively and
drinking rather than if she was dressed conservatively and drinking, is also inconsistent
with previous studies, there was no significant main effect for college students’ views
about the woman’s responsibility, when she was viewed as dressed “provocatively” and
drinking.
For example, previous studies found that more blame is placed on the victim if
she was seen as dressed provocatively, as opposed to conservatively (Abbey, Cozzarelli,
McLaughlin & Harnish, 1987). Furthermore, even though previous literature shows that
the woman is viewed as more responsible for an assault when she had been drinking than
a woman who had not been drinking (Blume, 1991; Campbell, 1992), these college
students seemed to disagree.

http://libres.uncg.edu/ir/uncw/f/funchesk2008-1.pdf
 

About her outfit, I would agree that it is NOT an outfit I would ever wear, but I would not say that she is "slutty" because of it. Instead, I would say that she doesn't know how to dress very nice. Her skirt is much too short. To be fair, she is lifting up the shirt in the photo to show her tattoo, and her back is to the camera, so I don't know just how revealing the shirt is, but from the back, if she just let it down I don't think the shirt is a problem. It's just spaghetti straps, but I don't know how much boob is showing, so it's kind of hard to make a good assessment.

Or at least I wouldn't wear a skirt that short out in public. :mrgreen:
 
About her outfit, I would agree that it is NOT an outfit I would ever wear, but I would not say that she is "slutty" because of it.
The first thing I notice about that pic, right after I look at her T&A and cute face is scars on her left arm that indicate that she's a cutter. A self mutilator. A sign of serious emotional issues.
 
The first thing I notice about that pic, right after I look at her T&A and cute face is scars on her left arm that indicate that she's a cutter. A self mutilator. A sign of serious emotional issues.

I didn't notice that. I was too busy looking at her clothing. How sad. I would think that a lot of girls who go out and sleep around all the time with just whoever they meet at a bar are probably suffering from some kind of emotional disturbance. :(
 
About her outfit, I would agree that it is NOT an outfit I would ever wear, but I would not say that she is "slutty" because of it. Instead, I would say that she doesn't know how to dress very nice. Her skirt is much too short. To be fair, she is lifting up the shirt in the photo to show her tattoo, and her back is to the camera, so I don't know just how revealing the shirt is, but from the back, if she just let it down I don't think the shirt is a problem. It's just spaghetti straps, but I don't know how much boob is showing, so it's kind of hard to make a good assessment.

Or at least I wouldn't wear a skirt that short out in public. :mrgreen:

I just keep thinking I know her. She looks so familiar to me. If I did know her, it would likely be from Hawaii.

Actually, it does make me think, doesn't location make a difference for where you might see certain clothing worn though? In Hawaii, particularly the bars in Waikiki, bikinis and flipflops are common in some clubs.
 
Depends how you define "revealing".

I full length dress and top with turtle-neck or whatever could be revealing, depending on how an individual views things.


But IMO....no.
 
Let me put it this way:

IF clothing IS a factor in some rapes, that points towards a cultural issue - namely that we think outward appearance indicates internal intent/opinion/whatever, and further, that some rapists are attracted to said persons because they are, however much we might dislike the idea, part of our culture....


As humans in general, we tend to view the outward appearance of a person as highly indicative of their internal self.
Fat person = lazy, possibly stupid, low self-esteem (caused by cultural views, in part?), lack of self-control, etc, etc, whatever.
Scantily dressed female (or male?) - likes showing off her body, probably to attract sexual partners..."slut" is the term that comes to mind...

Thing is, those are actually true in many cases, but how much of that is because the cultural views of such give (in the case of the scantily dressed person, possibly the fat person) people ideas/templates.

And yes, i said fat person...IMO it's BS to use some "PC" term instead - we all know what the terms mean, even if we don't admit it.
 
I just keep thinking I know her. She looks so familiar to me. If I did know her, it would likely be from Hawaii.

Actually, it does make me think, doesn't location make a difference for where you might see certain clothing worn though? In Hawaii, particularly the bars in Waikiki, bikinis and flipflops are common in some clubs.

Sure, definitely in colder climate parts of the country people are going to be dressing with a LOT less skin showing. :lol: It's too cold for all that! Maybe that's why I don't see as many "scantily clad" people around my area.
 
Are you kidding? This is what you have been implying throughout the entire discussion . . . that girls who dress in a certain manner are sending out certain signals. This is what we have been arguing about the whole time!

Because it's true. A person's style of dress does send off certain signals to the people around them, regardless of whether it is intended to do so or not.

Frankly, even that is a cop out, as in most cases, a person is not oblivious to the signals in question. Most people actually choose their style of dress with the deliberate intention of sending those kinds of signals out in the first place.

Just because it tends to happen, however; does not mean that it justifies rape. I never so much as implied that.

Didn't you ask me what I think when I see a person dressed in a certain way? You did, and I answered your question, and now you're telling me we aren't talking about people I know? :doh

Yes. We were talking about first impressions. If you already know a person, their clothing can't very well make a "first impression," now can it?

I have been nothing but honest, so I don't know what you're insinuating, but anyway NO, I wouldn't judge a person's character based upon their choice of clothing. I would base my opinions based on a person's actions.

A dirty slob in a T-shirt and a clean cut man in a nice suit walk into a bar and / or night club one after the other.

Which one would you rather flirt with? Which one would you rather have approach you?

I don't believe for a single second that you wouldn't make some kind of assumption about these men based upon their style of dress. Frankly, if you wouldn't, you really need to.

There is a difference between "open mindedness" and simple naivety, after all.

He's saying that he thinks spending time with women is useless unless they "put out."

If you're only in the bar for the explicit purpose of finding someone to have sex with in the first place, it's kind of hard to argue with his logic. :shrug:

About her outfit, I would agree that it is NOT an outfit I would ever wear, but I would not say that she is "slutty" because of it. Instead, I would say that she doesn't know how to dress very nice. Her skirt is much too short. To be fair, she is lifting up the shirt in the photo to show her tattoo, and her back is to the camera, so I don't know just how revealing the shirt is, but from the back, if she just let it down I don't think the shirt is a problem. It's just spaghetti straps, but I don't know how much boob is showing, so it's kind of hard to make a good assessment.

Or at least I wouldn't wear a skirt that short out in public. :mrgreen:

Do you really think that she fell into that outfit by accident, or that she is completely unaware of way in which it leads people to view her?

Let me put it this way:

IF clothing IS a factor in some rapes, that points towards a cultural issue - namely that we think outward appearance indicates internal intent/opinion/whatever, and further, that some rapists are attracted to said persons because they are, however much we might dislike the idea, part of our culture....


As humans in general, we tend to view the outward appearance of a person as highly indicative of their internal self.
Fat person = lazy, possibly stupid, low self-esteem (caused by cultural views, in part?), lack of self-control, etc, etc, whatever.
Scantily dressed female (or male?) - likes showing off her body, probably to attract sexual partners..."slut" is the term that comes to mind...

Thing is, those are actually true in many cases, but how much of that is because the cultural views of such give (in the case of the scantily dressed person, possibly the fat person) people ideas/templates.

And yes, i said fat person...IMO it's BS to use some "PC" term instead - we all know what the terms mean, even if we don't admit it.

Of course it's cultural. It's not like clothing is a part of our intrinsic biology, after all. However, just because it's cultural, doesn't mean that there isn't some truth to it.

These kinds of stereotypes tend to exist for a reason, after all.

It doesn't work that way though. Plenty of guys out there who are going to try for the women they are attracted to, which isn't always going to be the one dressed the sluttiest, even for most guys.

99 times out of 100, those guys are going to be going home alone. :lol:

Such a huge stereotype it isn't even funny. A guy doesn't have to be aggressive or testosterone poisoned to rape a woman. The geeky guy can be just as likely to rape a woman.

Perhaps not. However, the groups most notorious for date rape tend to be frat boys and athletes.

Neither clique is known for attracting particularly "meek" varieties of men, or men with especially respectful attitudes towards women.

I think way too many guys in this conversation are going off of either their personal attractions and attitude or the stereotypes of men that are out there. I am going off of my experience with men.

We actually are men. We know how men think, and I'm willing to bet that we have more experience dealing with other men than you do.

While not every man will go after "sluts," not every man is promiscuous either. Promiscuous men do tend to overwhelmingly go after women they perceive to be "slutty," precisely because they know that there is a much higher likelihood that they will put out.
 
Last edited:
Because it's true. A person's style of dress does send off certain signals to the people around them, regardless of whether it is intended to do so or not.

Frankly, even that is a cop out, as in most cases, a person is not oblivious to the signals in question. Most people actually choose their style of dress with the deliberate intention of sending those kinds of signals out in the first place.

Just because it tends to happen, however; does not mean that it justifies rape. I never so much as implied that.

MOST of the women are dressed at least somewhat provocatively.



Yes. We were talking about first impressions. If you already know a person, their clothing can't very well make a "first impression," now can it?

Yes, but since I've known people who wear biker shirts and things like that who do not actually own a bike, then I know not to jump to such conclusions.

A dirty slob in a T-shirt and a clean cut man in a nice suit walk into a bar and / or night club one after the other.

Which one would you rather flirt with? Which one would you rather have approach you?

That depends on a lot of different things. For one thing, you are assuming that I would think the first man was scummy, but I would not think that. MY first impression would be that perhaps he just got done working and was just coming in for an after-work relaxing drink.

Maybe the guy in the suit is an obnoxious ass or something. I mean, there IS more to a first impression than clothing. :roll:

I don't believe for a single second that you wouldn't make some kind of assumption about these men based upon their style of dress. Frankly, if you wouldn't, you really need to.

There is a difference between "open mindedness" and simple naivety, after all.

I know, I am open minded, and you are naive. :)


If you're only in the bar for the explicit purpose of finding someone to have sex with in the first place, it's kind of hard to argue with his logic. :shrug:

I suppose you have a point, but that doesn't make it any less jerky.


Do you really think that she fell into that outfit by accident, or that she is completely unaware of way in which it leads people to view her?

Well, I think she is trying to be sexy, but the outfit is really not sexy but more cheap looking. I will say even kind of skanky looking, and to me there is a BIG difference between sexy and skanky. :mrgreen: HOWEVER, I would not think that SHE is skanky, just that she doesn't understand what "sexy" is.
 
Back
Top Bottom