In all honesty, I wouldn't vote for a Muslim.
I wouldn't vote for someone who associates himself with a religion that has, in my opinion, caused so many human rights violations and violent acts around the world. Honor killings, oppression of women, death penalty for gays, etc.
I know someone is going to respond by saying that there are plenty of "liberal Muslims" but honestly, I think that's just a guilt thing. I think they know that a lot of Islam is morally wrong, but they feel guilty so they still pretend to practice it. It's the same with so called "cafeteria Catholics". The thing is, if you actually truly believe, you would believe that having a gay lifestyle, for instance, would cause you to have eternal damnation. It's doublethink. I do not want a President that practices either practices doublethink or supports human rights violations.