• This is a political forum that is non-biased/non-partisan and treats every person's position on topics equally. This debate forum is not aligned to any political party. In today's politics, many ideas are split between and even within all the political parties. Often we find ourselves agreeing on one platform but some topics break our mold. We are here to discuss them in a civil political debate. If this is your first visit to our political forums, be sure to check out the RULES. Registering for debate politics is necessary before posting. Register today to participate - it's free!

Do you follow dietary restrictions imposed by your religion?

Do you follow dietary restrictions imposed by your religion?

  • Yes

    Votes: 5 35.7%
  • No

    Votes: 9 64.3%
  • Depends on what kind of mood I'm in.

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    14

99percenter

DP Veteran
Joined
Oct 31, 2011
Messages
10,658
Reaction score
3,773
Location
Chicago
Gender
Male
Political Leaning
Very Conservative
I have a lot of jewish friends that eat pork and other foods that aren't kosher. I have some muslim friends that eat meats that aren't halal and drink alcohol. I also have hindu friends that eat steaks. Almost every catholic i know eats meat on fridays during lent. Everyone on this forum knows that im an atheist and i think religion is pretty stupid, but if you do choose to follow a religion why not follow what seems to me the simplest task of them all?
 
Don't have an organized religion. Pretty irreligious.

But I do have a funny story. Back in college, I had a Jewish friend who was uber conservative on everything....except staying Kosher. Went to Japanese restaurants and ate raw shellfish with him, had pepperoni pizzas, went to the nearby wendy's and got cheese burgers...you name it, he broke the kosher rules.

Then I had an uber liberal Jewish friend who was RIDICULOUSLY Kosher. He would avoid any dairy item near a meat item on the buffet. Wasn't even in the same item! Just proximity! He freaked out when he accidentally took Chicken Cordon Bleu.
 
No, but I don't think that God cares what I eat.
 
I was raised in a Roman Catholic home and we followed the very few dietary restrictions that the church imposes.

Since being an adult and being pretty much agnostic I haven't followed them in years - decades.
 
Don't have an organized religion. Pretty irreligious.

But I do have a funny story. Back in college, I had a Jewish friend who was uber conservative on everything....except staying Kosher. Went to Japanese restaurants and ate raw shellfish with him, had pepperoni pizzas, went to the nearby wendy's and got cheese burgers...you name it, he broke the kosher rules.

Then I had an uber liberal Jewish friend who was RIDICULOUSLY Kosher. He would avoid any dairy item near a meat item on the buffet. Wasn't even in the same item! Just proximity! He freaked out when he accidentally took Chicken Cordon Bleu.

I noticed that too. Some of the more liberal folks follow their religion more closely.
 
No, but I don't think that God cares what I eat.

So then you are not a very good (insert your religion here). Would you agree with that sentiment?
 
So then you are not a very good (insert your religion here). Would you agree with that sentiment?

No, not really. I'm actually perfectly suited for my religion. I just don't believe that God cares what we eat. I don't view God as a parent or a judge.
 
Some at least.

He was like "****!!!" when he cut open the chicken and saw the cheese and ham. He got a new plate and discarded everything he had gotten.

Another think i noticed is that almost every muslim i know doesn't eat pork. They might drink alcohol and eat meats that aren't always hahal but they manage not to eat pork. Maybe that is the easiest to follow.
 
Another think i noticed is that almost every muslim i know doesn't eat pork. They might drink alcohol and eat meats that aren't always hahal but they manage not to eat pork. Maybe that is the easiest to follow.

HHAHA. Another funny story! I was eating dinner at the dorms with my friend and his Muslim friend. We were in line and he was asking "Hamburgers have ham?" And we go "No, no ham" and he kept going "You sure? Positive? You sure?" He kept insisting over and over for assurance until we had walked out of the buffet line.
 
Another think i noticed is that almost every muslim i know doesn't eat pork. They might drink alcohol and eat meats that aren't always hahal but they manage not to eat pork. Maybe that is the easiest to follow.

That does seem to be the case. Sometimes, I will cook a large pot of taco stew, spaghetti, or something that will feed a good-sized group, and take it to work for everyone. I work with several doctors who are Muslim, and I always make it a point to tell them it's beef, because they are devout about not eating pork.
 
Do you follow dietary restrictions imposed by your religion?

I follow dietary restrictions imposed by a Goddess.

My wife.
 
My religion doesn't have dietary guidelines. Only thing it really says is to eat and drink alcohol in moderation; I'm good at the second (my faith actually makes me drink more than I normally would) and working on the first.
 
Dietary restrictions always seemed more practical than moral to me. Given the problem with uncooked pork, it made plenty of sense to avoid it when holy texts were written. It seems harder to explain why god would deliberately create a tasty edible creature like a pig and then tell you not to eat it.
 
There's no serious dietary restrictions to follow.

I don't drink, but that's due to lack of interest.
 
My religion doesn't have dietary restrictions, so I don't follow any.
 
Then I had an uber liberal Jewish friend who was RIDICULOUSLY Kosher. He would avoid any dairy item near a meat item on the buffet. Wasn't even in the same item! Just proximity! He freaked out when he accidentally took Chicken Cordon Bleu.

Kosher food can only be prepared in a Kosher kitchen. Separate sets of pans and utensils have to be maintained for meat and for dairy, and any items meant for use on one must never touch the other. Meat and dairy cannot be eaten in the same meal. And if the kitchen is used to prepare anything that is not Kosher, then it's no longer a Kosher kitchen, and nothing prepared there is Kosher.

A strictly-observant Jew could not eat food from a restaurant that was not specifically Kosher.

The meat/dairy thing is one of many examples where the Jews started with a law that God gave them, and then, fearful of accidentally violating that law, created layer upon layer of increasingly-strict “hedge laws” to keep them safely away from any risk of accidentally violating the original law, and then more “hedge laws” to keep them from accidentally violating the previously-established “hedge laws”, and so on. Thus, they got from “Thou shalt not seethe a kid in his mother’s milk.” to making sure that they never ate any meat and any dairy together, and that they never prepared or ate meat using any pans, dishes or utensils that had ever touched dairy, and never prepared or ate dairy with any pans, dishes, or utensils that had ever touched meat.


As for myself, my Mormon religion prohibits the consumption of alcohol, tobacco, coffee, and tea; and although I cannot honestly claim, at this time to be a fully-practicing Mormon, I do strictly avoid these things. I must, however, admit to a caffeine addiction. The use of caffeine is significantly-discouraged by my religion, but not outright prohibited as long as it isn't in the form of coffee or tea.
 
As time has gone on, I have followed more and more of my religion's (Jewish) dietary restrictions. Currently, other than eating in non-kosher places, I follow them all (no pork, no shellfish, no milk and meat, etc...).
 
As time has gone on, I have followed more and more of my religion's (Jewish) dietary restrictions. Currently, other than eating in non-kosher places, I follow them all (no pork, no shellfish, no milk and meat, etc...).

What exactly counts as mixing dairy and meat? Isn't milk naturally stored in giant meatsack otherwise known as a cow?
 
The only faith-based dietary requirements I have is to not consume blood or participate in occult worship feats . Since I don't want to anyway, its not an issue. Acts 15:28-29

However, there's another side to the dietary code that you might find interesting. Christians are instructed to eat anything offered to them as guests when in a foreign culture. The implication is people could be offended if you reject their food and could thwart an opportunity to establish a relationship. Then there's the added advice to to ask what it is to keep from wanting to hurl. If you don't know you're eating cats and dogs...everything tastes like chicken anyway. :lamo

I use to live in a place where people ate the entire fish, heads included. I couldn't bring myself to do it but I don't recall anyone offering fish heads to me as a guest, just things you see on you plate when at local restaurants. The people know statesiders get freaked out by fish heads so they aren't offended.
 
I have a lot of jewish friends that eat pork and other foods that aren't kosher. I have some muslim friends that eat meats that aren't halal and drink alcohol. I also have hindu friends that eat steaks. Almost every catholic i know eats meat on fridays during lent. Everyone on this forum knows that im an atheist and i think religion is pretty stupid, but if you do choose to follow a religion why not follow what seems to me the simplest task of them all?

I absolutely do. Christianity forbids killing other people for food, and so I have always made sure that they were killed for other reasons instead.
 
I have a lot of jewish friends that eat pork and other foods that aren't kosher. I have some muslim friends that eat meats that aren't halal and drink alcohol. I also have hindu friends that eat steaks. Almost every catholic i know eats meat on fridays during lent. Everyone on this forum knows that im an atheist and i think religion is pretty stupid, but if you do choose to follow a religion why not follow what seems to me the simplest task of them all?

Any religion that says you cannot eat pork is wrong.
 
As an avowed, life-long Hoppist, I follow the one simple dietary law my religion has laid out for me.

No beer before breakfast.
 
Back
Top Bottom